GB : Uncharted 3 EDGE score has arrived and it has done well. You can check out all the scores below.
EDGE giving a PS3 exclusive a 9?! (I know they gave some PS3 exclusives the same or even a better score, but it's rare) Omg this game is gonna be awesome! :D
They gave UC2 a 9 as well.
they usually take the score down a bit if the sequel doesn't improve on the previous game, I guess U3 is even more awesome then the awesome U2
yh they did give uc2 a 9 and they are quite tough on reviews so its a great score. I don't really expect uc3 to outdo uc2 in terms of ratings even if its a better game
Regardless of Edge's practices, Congrats ND.
when you guys say "EDGE" who are you talking about? because I think EDGE has different reviewers for games so the person who gave LBP2 a 10 may not have the same opinion as the person who gave U3 a 9, that's why its hard to compare their review scores if say U3 got a 7 and a game like Dance Central got a 9
"they usually take the score down a bit if the sequel doesn't improve on the previous game, I guess U3 is even more awesome then the awesome U2" Not if you believe Adam Sessler at G4. He gave Uncharted 3 a 4 out of 5. That site gives all kinds of games a 5 yet this game gets a 4? Maybe they shouldn't give many 5's. That's why a 9 is great from EDGE. That's a great score. They rarely give a 10. G4 gives out way too many 5's.
Don't be surprised if someone at EDGE gets fired this week.. EDIT: BTW they gave Halo OSDT a 9. I think this is worth noting. Seriously. They gave it a 9.
They gave Little Big Planet a 10. Looking forward to picking up this issue of EDGE tomorrow. Want to read their Skyward Sword review and get a proper look at their Uncharted 3 review beyond just the 9/10 score it got. All the AAA games coming this autumn is ridiculous. I'm barely done with Dark Souls and Arkham City, and now we have Battlefield 3, Skyward Sword, Uncharted and a whole host of other games I can't be assed to mention inbound. Thank fuck for my formative assessment week in mid November T__T Praise the lord.
They are also going to post their Skyward Sword review online tomorrow. http://www.next-gen.biz/rev... I'm shocked that Edge gave Uncharted 3 a 9 because of their trolling status. I was expecting a 8 or their Infamous 7s.
LBP got 10/10. Every remastered version of Zelda got 10/10. But Edge is retarted anyway.
you spelled retarded wrong :/
"Every remastered version of Zelda got 10/10" ummmmm edge only gave Zelda OOT a 10 so i dont knw what ur gettin at. Anyways Uncharted and Zelda FTW!! I have a Wii And PS3 ,Xbox sux cuz they have no exclusive.
^^lol look at this guy and his little wiinis.
Its a F****ing 9! 9 and next comes 10! Its a freaking awesome score...F**K!
dude LBP is not just original it's fun it's fresh it's MIND BLOWINGLY AWESOME... and finally it's as original as originality can get
So do the conspiracy theories end here or shall we wait for another exclusive game to score lower than 9 and let the theories re-surface again?
They'll continue and get worse. Look bellow you (or above you) for proof.
You mean the statistical anomaly where they rate 360 exclusives higher than PS3 exclusives? Statistically speaking, they are a long ways from righting that wrong. No one thinks it's a conspiracy, it's just consistent bias - where it's easy to see how it's unfair. https://skydrive.live.com/v...
I don't know if the "conspiracy theories" will end, but the statistical bias certainly doesn't. This game series, and the British made LBP are the only two large exclusives to have bucked the trend on Edge PS3 scores. If anything they are the exception which proves the rule. Hell, the fact that you're in here in such a rush to use this score is testament to how rare such a score from Edge on a PS3 exclusive is.
EDGE 9/10 is like a 20/10 anyway i'm super happy right now
Here are the scores: Skyward Sword  Uncharted 3  Batman AC  Dark Souls  Rage  Super Mario 3D Land  Forza 4  Disgaea 4  Ratchet All 4 One  Ace Combat  Dance Central 2 
Forza 4 was given 8/10? About time
Yep, just above the 7/10 GT5 got there last year
@humbleopinion Don't forget, that we are talking about Edge. 7/10 for PS3 exclusive from Edge is not so surprising as 8/10 for an Xbox360 exclusive.
You cand add 1 to 3 points on each ps3 exclusives scores from edge, so it's a 10 ;)
And why cant you fools on here take there review at face value, instead making up some scoring rule to suit your own neads in justifying your opinion on a game you havent played. This dosent just apply to U3 but to any PS3 exclusive you feel youve been wronged on, a review is an opinion of one person yet whenever a review dosent meet the expected score on N4G you cry foul play and that the magazine is biased to another console. Edge is a magazine of the highest quality which I have enjoyed reading for many years and of course Ive not always agreed with there scores, but guess what that is my opinion I certainly dont go crying about!! Back on topic this game is going to awsome release cant come soon enough.
@Kikizoo sounds cool You can also add 50 points to all PC and 360 reviews, so Forza 4 would be a 48/10 :)
if you look at all the review scores coming in than you know UC3 is gonna get all mid to high 9s. I believe this will win GOTY unless skyrim out does it which also can happen now i can't wait till 11-1-11 to get my copy of the game sad that none of the stores in my area are doing midnight launch
People continue to complain about Edge giving bad scores to PS3, but when you actually take the time to see what scores they actually give PS3 games, it's not that much different from any other console.... Just saying, but haters gona hate.
The Europeansites lile edge n eurogamer thought they are high class but their traditions says otherwise. they sit on their high horses for what? I am so glad Sony PlayStation endured the likes pf them sites. The truth will keep on marching on! Rock on PlayStation!
How lame is Gamingbolt that they can't post their own review they have to post Edge's?
That is an incredible score. This and zelda are going to be incredible!!!!!
doesn't it make you wonder why the headline isn't about Zelda? or how about something neutral..."Edge Scores for November."
Actually their magazine cover has zelda all over it.
that has nothing to do with my point.
Same as Uncharted 2 then.That's certainly good.I enjoy EDGE and their unbiased reviews particularly towards Playstation franchises.
Hahaha well done colbert, well done.
So I only have one week with BF 3 before Uncharted 3 start knocking on my door? Shit. To make matters worst I only have a two weeks with Uncharted 3 before Skyrim drops. Damn these idiot publishers and their hard on for releasing all the games in the 4th quarter.
I know! Makes no sense really... IMO if you make a great game it will sell good no matter what time of year it is unless you release it around the same time as a bunch of other great games.
Why buy the whole seat when all you need is the EDGE ! Congrats ND
Eight more days! I can't wait.
Ummm sorry, that's been cancelled :P
Noooooooooooooo! (Checks my amazon pre-order list)...... -______- jerk :)
To all the disagrees - I was referring to Eight Days, the cancelled IP from Sony Is there a site somewhere, where jokes don't have to be continuously explained?
actually i think its on hold, not cancelled. http://www.neoseeker.com/ne...
Nice to see this and Zelda getting such great scores, can't wait to pick them both up :D
I love EDGE, people complain, sometimes they do focus by and large they are consistent reviewers one thing im worried about with UC3 is the length, yes it will be an amazing ride but I would have preferred no MP and whatever time they spent on the MP they spent on making the SP a cople of hours longer
R U EFFIN CRAZY!!!!!!
thats really great , as the site said about U3 got the same socre as U2 "it must have impressed them a lot to maintain that score", IMO the game is awesome no matter what the score is.
A rarity indeed from Edge......nice to see it
EDGE garnered a lot of attention these days due to its review scores. Its gud to see UC3 a 9 (UC2 got 9 also, btw) along with Batman,Dark Souls. And My God! Skyward Sword! Seems Mission Accomplished for Naughty Dog! Anyway we r not surprised, Been expecting that given the Pedigree of ND!
Edge still sucks.
yep agreed nothing changed here they still sux they lost every credibility when they give infamous2 7/10 and they can't give uc3 a 7 or 8 bec they know that this game is pure awesomeness
i have to disagree, they are one of the few to really use their 10 point scale where 7 is ok and 8 and above is exceptional
Edge can kiss my ass even if they gave uc3 a 10.
Edge and gameinformer reviews are great...
Really a 9 yet Zelda...as ALWAYS, gets a perfect 10. It's probably not even the game thats good it's just the franchise, because it's Zelda they feel the need to give it a perfect score. Same happened with Twlight Princess, it wasn't as good as other Zelda games yet everyone said it was perfect.
I think you're right - reviewers give some games/series a much easier time than others. Zelda always gets high scores. Likewise CoD seems to be a favourite. Gamereactor gave BF3 an 8.5 today with an 8 in "Graphics"...it gave Black Ops a 9 in graphics. If any game was as nitpicked as GT5 most games wouldnt come close to a 9 or 10.
LOL they give it an 8 for graphics, yet Black Ops a 9... No way...<checks review> That's just BS and they know it. God I wonder what they'll give MW3.
Isn't this argument flawed since the only Zelda game they've given a 10 to was Ocarina of Time... so.. yeah... you're point that they grade only on the franchise, wouldn't make much sense if the 3 in-between Ocarina and Skyward Sword didn't get 10
WOW...Edge gave a PS3 exclusive an outstanding score and some of the people here are still not satisfied.
some folks think edge has some kind of bias agenda against PS3 exclusives........which is foolish since they gave a few exclusives high scores in the past.
The foolish thing is to believe they are not bias since they gave a few exclusives some high score. a guy has already given the proof they are biased toward ps3, nobody can deny the fact : it's easy, check all the ps3 exclusives scores from edges, and compare it to gameranking or metacritics (even with biased reviews inside !) than do the same thing with nintendo and xbox exclusives...you'll see.
Edge has only given 9 games 10/10, and of those 9 one was an Xbox exclusive (Halo 3) one was a PS3 exclusive (LBP) and 3 were Wii exclusives(SMG/SMG2/LoZ:SS). 85% of the games they review they score lower than the average review score, they score everybody low. Source - http://www.metacritic.com/p...
I am more than satisfied with the score. I just disagree with most of EDGE's reviews/review scores. 8 times out of 10 EDGE is harsh and criticize games too heavily. For instance, in just scores, RAGE just got a 7 instead of an 8 or 9, Forza 4 got an 8 in contrast to a 9 or 10, and All 4 One got a 6 in place of a 7 or 8. Personally, All 4 One is a 7, Forza 4 is a 9, and RAGE is 9. EDGE does seem biased a lot of the time but EDGE reviewers can have some highly disagreeable opinions sometimes. If you look at the reviewer who gave Dance Central 2 an 8 you'll see that that same reviewer has given better games worse scores. I'm not saying Dance Central 2 isn't fun or that it didn't deserve an 8 but if that gets an 8 then a clearly better game should get an 8 or above as well.