Try our new beta! Click here
Submitted by Valay 1507d ago | news

First Uncharted 3 review is in

The first Uncharted 3 review is in from a Spanish magazine. (PS3, Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception)

Alternative Sources
« 1 2 3 »
Shanks  +   1507d ago | Well said
"This is the highest score the publication has ever provided for a game."

holy shit.
joydestroy  +   1507d ago
sucks i have to wait about 4 days after the 1st to play it. this is going to be an amazing game and is going to take up all of my time until ME3 drops in '12
ApplEaglElephant  +   1507d ago
Uncharted 2 is currently second highest rated game
this generation on metacritic. Next to GTA4 which i feel overrated since it was released early in the cycle.

I wonder if Uncharted 3 will break Uncharted 2's record.
Ares84HU  +   1507d ago
4 days only???? I have to wait till the 25th of November to get my hands on it. Because of my
TurismoGTR   1507d ago | Not a reply | show
VazquezOra   1507d ago | Spam
zeeshan  +   1506d ago
ND are THE devs man! Bring it on ND!!! This could very well be GOTY 2011 even with Gears 3 and Skyrim around :)
Alpha_Gamer  +   1506d ago
98 on Metacritic? I don`t even see how that`s possible.

Virtually every single score would have to be perfect for that to happen. There would be a cushion for and handful of 9.0`s and that`s it, all the rest would have to be PERFECT.

Unlikely. Especially since since almost every PS3 exclusive this year has been, in my opinion, underrated.
harrisk954  +   1506d ago
Although I'm a huge PS3 fanboy, your statement is simply not true. Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 both are higher on Metacritic than UC2.

Uncharted 2: 96
SMG 1 and 2: 97

GTA4 sits as #1 at 98.

EDIT: WOW... although early, the PS3 version of Batman: Arkham City is sitting at 98!
#1.1.7 (Edited 1506d ago ) | Agree(20) | Disagree(2) | Report
ModsLoveMe  +   1506d ago
Naughty Dog, the inventors of the AAAA games.
gta2800  +   1506d ago
I'm currently replaying Uncharted 2 and attempting to get the platinum before U3 comes out. So excited! As of right now, Uncharted 2 is in a tie with God of War 3 for my favorite game this gen.
oddhead  +   1506d ago
I am forcing my self to wait 11 days. I won't have to work, and I'm going to eat some mushrooms and trip my fucking balls. Going to try to beat the game in one sitting
HappyGaming  +   1506d ago
I cant afford it :'(
Stupid uni!!!!
DrakesOnAPlane  +   1506d ago
Gumtrol, can't afford it? Sell some stuff.
starchild  +   1506d ago
This game is going to be incredible, just like the first two.
DaTruth  +   1506d ago
I just replayed Uncharted 2 for my platinum too! But I lost my save game in a YLOD so I had to chart hard again, just so I could be allowed to chart Crushing!

Edit: Just saw the new PS3 commercial this minute during Fringe. That was much better than I imagined!
#1.1.14 (Edited 1506d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(1) | Report
LadyGaga  +   1506d ago
I don't understand how a game with a multiplayer that so many fans of the series complain about can still get rated so highly.

Multiplayer is never weighted correctly in reviews. It's either everything in reviews, like MW2 or Black Ops, or completely ignored, like in MGS4 and possibly U3.
NeutralGamer  +   1506d ago
Uncharted 2 is at third place now :o)

The goddamn Batman swooped in and took the second place with a 98 metascore.
Pacman321  +   1507d ago
Only 19 (or 18 for USA) days left!
buddymagoo  +   1507d ago
It's too long! Too many possibilities for death.
inveni0  +   1507d ago
I agree. Each Uncharted release ranks right up there with the other big days in my life, like getting a driver's license, turning 18, turning 21, etc. Of course, at my age, there's not much left to look forward that could explain my excitement.
beatrixkiddo  +   1507d ago
Someday you'll add losing your virginity to that list as well. Sorry, couldn't resist!!! :) Bring on Uncharted 3 baby!!
inveni0  +   1507d ago
I'm married with 3 kids. I don't get to have sex now unless I want more kids or I feel inclined to be overly nice to my wife. So...

...Elena is really, really hot.
Mr Tretton  +   1506d ago
"Of course, at my age, there's not much left to look forward to"

you're only in your 20's dude. you're relying on video games as something to look forward to life...that's sad.
HappyGaming  +   1506d ago
I like how inveni0 didnt put down my childrens birth as an important day in his life but he put down the release of Uncharted 3!!!

I kid I kid :P
Hicken  +   1506d ago
This conversation is utterly ridiculous, and yet I utterly love it.

"unless I want more kids or I feel inclined to be overly nice to my wife" made me laugh so hard.
inveni0  +   1506d ago
@Mr Tretton
I'm in my 30s.
RedHotChiliPepaSpray  +   1507d ago
Soooooooo fuc*in excited. Getting this for my bday gift. :D
FlameBaitGod  +   1507d ago | Helpful
Luckily i can translate cus my native language is spanish :D!


Uncharted 3 is a complete adventure, that will take us threw exotic landscapes, bringing awesome shootings and fights in dangerous tombs


From a artistic point of view, uncharted 3 is a marvel. Never before have we seen environments so amazing.


Platforms continue to be clear: By just having a quick look you will see outstanding platforms(dangerous or difficult) where you can go.


Chole, Elena, Sulli... all the good people from uncharted 2 return. If you dont know them, you will lose some details in the drama... but nothing TOO important.
Alpha_Gamer  +   1506d ago
Nice, thank you =)
pipipi  +   1506d ago
what about the gay stuff check out the pic of sully and nate "hand to hand" !!!!

LOL pinches putos
nemey  +   1507d ago | Funny
so its only 9.9

preorder canceled!
TheFallenAngel  +   1507d ago
I just canceled it too
perdie  +   1507d ago
lol you guys are funny
AsunaYuukiTheFlash  +   1507d ago
Same, I don't buy a game unless it scores a 10/10.
Oldman100  +   1506d ago
Yah same here, i'm going to get michael phelps push the limit and a kinect instead.
SnotyTheRocket  +   1506d ago
HappyGaming  +   1506d ago
Naughty Dog clearly lost their touch their games are no longer perfect :/
vickers500  +   1506d ago

You must have some pretty low standards. I only buy games that score 11/10.
Cosmit  +   1506d ago

You must only have GT4 then lol. :P I kid I kid.

I demand nothing less than perfect!
The_Con-Sept  +   1506d ago
You don't even know about the hidden 20/10 games.... They can only be found in the BLACK MARKET!
Jamzluminati  +   1507d ago
Well game of the generation confirmed.
Psfan999  +   1507d ago
For a while I was planning on blowing this off and just getting Skyrim and picking this up later, but it's definitely now become a priority for me to get asap!
vickers500  +   1506d ago
Well, one review doesn't confirm anything, but yeah, U3 is looking to be quite amazing, and certainly a contender for game of the year.
Jamzluminati  +   1506d ago
Bitch please. It's been confirmed since it was announced.
bigrob904  +   1506d ago
i have money to get either this or skyrim. i am currently debating whether to get this or skyrim but this is pushing me toward uncharted because U2 is one of my favorite games of all time. either way i wont have to wait too long to get the other but still, i'm having trouble deciding.
vickers500  +   1506d ago
Well, personally I'm a firm believer of judging the quality of something only until I play it for myself, but I guess some people have the special ability to see into the future.
FanboyPunisher   1507d ago | Trolling | show | Replies(5)
Undeadwolfy   1506d ago | Trolling | show
RockNRoller  +   1506d ago
like one great man once said," Live me the fk alone, im playing uncharted" now i shall write my will and say good bye to all my loves for 11.1.11 comes i'll be in The World only God knows
ChrisW  +   1506d ago
Wow... I just clicked on a link to a site that has only 3 lines of information about Uncharted getting a high score.

Seriously people! Just take a bit more time to write more information to MAKE OUR TIME worth visiting your crap site!!!
NeutralGamer  +   1506d ago
-Replied the wrong place-
#1.11 (Edited 1506d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
WhiteLightning  +   1507d ago
It beat Uncharted it IS possible.
sikbeta  +   1507d ago
The Power of The Naughty Gods! :P
Undeadwolfy  +   1506d ago
Haha nice!
Michael-Jackson  +   1507d ago
Scored higher than 2, looks promising then.
xX_Altair_Xx  +   1507d ago
9.9 is great; but I'm not a fan of the scale - what's the difference between that and 10?
SlickShoes  +   1507d ago
Learn Spanish and read the spoiler filled review and maybe you will find out haha.
PRHB HYBRiiD  +   1507d ago
where can i read the review??
Allelujah00  +   1507d ago
Its in Spanish but they have scans put up on that link. So if you can read Spanish then go for it!
Commander_TK  +   1507d ago
10/10 = perfection

Maybe the game isn't perfect for them? Common sense?
Fanbot   1507d ago | Immature | show | Replies(4)
PS3and4_HAS_GAMES  +   1507d ago
I'm with you on that one..either give the game a 10 or atleast a 9.5...really what diffrence does. .1 make
RedDragan  +   1507d ago
In particle physics .1 can means the difference between unlimited energy and negative energitc output.

What that means is Fusion could work and be sustainable, thus being an everlasting energy source. Thus changing the world forever.

OR, it could mean that Fusion remains in the status quo where we currently have to put more energy in that what we get out, and thus it will never be able to power the planet.


It is important... in particle physics.
LightofDarkness  +   1507d ago
There's also the whole mathematical debate about whether 0.999999999.....(ad infinitum) is equal to 1.

Sounds silly, but this debate often erupts in freaking death threats.
drummerx2709  +   1507d ago
@ RedDragan
You remind me of Sheldon from the Big Bang Theory hahaha
THC CELL  +   1507d ago
Because no game is perfect.
MariaHelFutura  +   1507d ago
Yes, RedDragan. Just, yes.
jony_dols  +   1506d ago

So you pretty much called RedDragan, an emotionless autistic spazoid.
Cosmit  +   1506d ago
I agree with RedDragon reminding me of Sheldon lol.


"Sounds silly, but this debate often erupts in freaking death threats."

Lmao I had a good laugh off of that one! :D
MGS_fanatico_  +   1507d ago
I think I know...
The game ended... :)
Ps3thebest   1507d ago | Spam
kneon  +   1507d ago
If I were a reviewer a 10 would never be awarded as that implies there is nothing they could have done better, and that's just not ever going to happen.
xX_Altair_Xx  +   1507d ago
A game is reviewed as it is, not as it should be in an ideal world. We can always do better but if it's better than the rest then it deserves the highest score possible.
NBT91  +   1506d ago
well a 1-10 scale does not necessarily have to mean that the 10 represents perfection, just because it is the highest score they allow, a 10 would just mean they thought it was amazing.

If I genuinely thought it was flawless and could not be improved in any way, I would mention that in the review and award it a ten. If I thought it was still a very special game, but with nitpicking flaws I would mention that and if it was nothing too serious, award it a 10.
schlanz  +   1506d ago
10 = absolute highest recommendation
10 =/= perfection
Christopher  +   1506d ago
Planescape:Torment is my only 10/10 game. It is perfection from the perspective of a RPG. Seriously, many of the things it did are still being used in so many RPGs today, including the conversation wheels in BioWare's games.
Prcko  +   1507d ago
This is the highest score the publication has ever provided for a game.

Tarantino_Life  +   1507d ago
Why 9.9 and not 10 lol! Anyways great score! Cant wait! The gamesradar and edge journalists called it one of the best games of this generation in their tweets! Nov 1 bring it on!!!
pr0digyZA  +   1507d ago
"Why 9.9 and not 10 lol! "

Probably provision in case there is an uncharted 4.
#6.1 (Edited 1507d ago ) | Agree(23) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
ThatArtGuy  +   1507d ago
That'll be 9.99
perfectCarbonara  +   1507d ago
Always bet on Drake.
InNomeDiDio  +   1507d ago
Not the DUKE? :(
GodHandDee  +   1506d ago
not after the last duke game
TheHardware  +   1507d ago
A 9.9 is not high enough...these guys are biased /s
ginsunuva  +   1507d ago
No they're owned by M$
TheHardware  +   1507d ago
uhmm the /s stands for sarcasm
ginsunuva  +   1506d ago
I know. I was being /s too.
RowSand  +   1507d ago
only 9.9 of 10 ? pre order canceled
TrueSix  +   1507d ago
happy bbirthday
RowSand  +   1506d ago
yo true get ur ass on socom 4!! demolition pack coming next week
SageHonor  +   1507d ago
9.9.. Just give it a 10.. lol why cant a game just get scores like 8, 9, and 10.. Whats deal with the .4's and .5's..
UnSelf  +   1506d ago
belal  +   1507d ago
i think the reason is because no game is perfect so 9.9 just means this is the closes you will get to being perfect.
Cloudberry  +   1507d ago
Why the shy 0.1 score?

Still, great score.
CynicalVision  +   1507d ago
Because scoring a game 10 implies that it's absolutely perfect.

Personally I hate it when reviewers give a game a perfect score, there's no such thing as perfection.
DigitalAnalog  +   1507d ago
"Personally I hate it when reviewers give a game a perfect score, there's no such thing as perfection."

Then we should also remove the 100% marks in exams as well since NO student is perfect either.
CynicalVision  +   1507d ago

That's completely different, a test involves answering questions right or wrong. I'm talking about reviews, implying that a game (or any type of media) is perfect is just absurd.
DigitalAnalog  +   1507d ago

Like tests, reviews should've at least certain requirements to reach top marks. What exactly is the point of as scale of 10 if no game is unable to reach that. We're not looking at an infinitude of progression in between 2 games. There is an end number ergo a score that can be obtained as long as certain requirements are met.

To say that there is no perfect game, yet place a score that requires a perfect game is a self-collapsing concept. If we're going to base our scoring system on this then it is the "flaws" that is the barrier to obtain a perfect score therefore it CAN be progressive. So if I can find so many flaws in the game within a 10 point scale NO MATTER HOW solid the game is, I can give it a 1/10.

What is really needed to clarify is that a perfect score means a game have EXCEEDED beyond all expectations and not judged based on perfection.
#12.1.3 (Edited 1507d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report
shikamaroooo  +   1507d ago
So they gave uncharted 2 9.5 and uncharted 3 9.9 their highest score ever given nice!!!!!!
Ddouble  +   1507d ago
It's a good start
Rampaged Death  +   1507d ago
I'd love to know what they knocked 0.1 off for.
marcoskids  +   1507d ago
Because u touch urself at nit
UnSelf  +   1506d ago
wouldve been funnier if u spelled night correctly.

still. lol
Az1mov  +   1507d ago
The question is have they ever gave a 10 and for what? GoldenEye N64 maybe?
Tarantino_Life  +   1507d ago
No this is the highest score they have ever given.No game was given a 10 by this mag
kikizoo  +   1506d ago
"GoldenEye N64"

Az1mov  +   1506d ago
It might seem surprising to you, but back then many gaming press reviews gave it the perfect score 99% I even saw a 20/20 in console+ magazine that I bought in 1997. Because that's what it was, a perfect game based on a movie and it didn't suck in'97.
Acquiescence  +   1507d ago
I'd better go to the shops and invest in some adult diapers today...
Judging by that review, I'm gonna be soiling my pants a lot once Uncharted 3 comes out.
Old McGroin  +   1507d ago
Great find OP!

9.9 outta 10, not to repeat what other people have said above but what possible reason could they have had to dock it 0.1?!
qwertyz   1507d ago | Bad language | show | Replies(2)
Pintheshadows  +   1507d ago
The only reason it got 9.9 is because they have to give a certain percentage of everything to Greece.
Biggest  +   1507d ago
Belly laugh!
Old McGroin  +   1507d ago
Very good :)
Noticeably_FAT  +   1507d ago
Seems like a lot of people are high on a single foreign publication. I will be getting the game anyway, but I'm not expecting it to be better then the last Uncharted game. When your at the top, only one place to go.

Also, I wouldn't be expecting perfect scores all over either, this hasn't been a great year for those, and I doubt the third game in a series get's many.

What I mean by that is, the first game was solid, the second game improved upon that and a lot of the time the second game is the real deal, the third game usually get's reviewed as "more of the same". So I suspect Uncharted 3 will suffer from a bit of that, much in the same way as Resistance 3, Gears 3 and even Halo 3.
Tarantino_Life  +   1507d ago
That is quite possible. There are exceptions though. It appears Arkham City is getting great scores even though its another iteration of the batman series with some returning gameplay mechanics. Who knows Maybe even UC3 will follow that trend. But you are right there are more chances of the game following the'more of the same' comments from Reviewers. Thats fine though because it will be better then UC2 and that means it will be a mind blowing game irrespective of of the overall meta score!
Noticeably_FAT  +   1507d ago
Batman AC is the sequel though. I think a third title in that series might suffer a bit. I have both this game and AC preordered
nycredude  +   1507d ago
I think you need to take into account ND's past track record. Their previous 2 franchises had three games each and each successive game got better than the last. It's in there DNA man.
Chuk5  +   1506d ago
Jak 2 was much better than 3.
cpayne93  +   1507d ago
MW3 will have been the 5th cod game in the past 4 years, but we all know that it will sell like crazy. The again, cod may be a whole different animal all together.
E2M  +   1506d ago
Uncharted 3 is very different from it predecessors though which actually suprised me, I dunno how infromed you guys have been but there is a shit load of changes, first off the animations.. there completely different to the other predecessors entirely, the gameplay... you can use objects as weapons in SP such as a bottle, book etc.. more ways of taking down enemies like mid-air sidewards... I sprint, The menu are different from the signature ones uc1 and 2 did and did I mention the huge mp rehaul. I didn't expec these many changes myself but I don't think any reviewer can say its more of the same. Gears of war 3 (my best game played this year so far) did'nt do a quarter of that neither did the games you mention
KonaBro  +   1507d ago
girlwithturn  +   1507d ago
God! Can't wait.
Phantasm  +   1507d ago
9.9 - Well... nothing is perfect, only perfect intentions.
Wizziokid  +   1507d ago
so it begins
HaHa_Ostrich  +   1507d ago
I can feel EDGEs 7/10 already :)
girlwithturn  +   1507d ago
Unch1 - 80/100;
Unch2 - 90/100;
Unch3 - 100/100.
FearNoAngel  +   1507d ago
ssb3173  +   1506d ago
Lol, they give that score to everything :L
CryofSilence  +   1506d ago
Yeah. I hold Edge's word to very little, if any, value.
oweowe  +   1507d ago
9.9? What?!
Pre-order cancelled.

Changed to Day 1 purchase now. Just can't wait another 3~4 days of the delivery delay.
Croash  +   1507d ago
Well that's awesome! But I am not really interested in review scores this time around, since Uncharted 3 always was a Day 1 buy for me (well...3rd Nov is close enough...and my birthday!).

I just wonder how the French magazine PSM3 will review Uncharted 3 considering Uncharted 2 was given a 21/20 >:D ( )
#28 (Edited 1507d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
francknara6  +   1507d ago
French PSM3 is dead.Sorry.
Croash  +   1507d ago
Oi, you're right, and it happened 2 months ago :(
It's too bad, I really wanted to see how crazy that review would have been.

Thanks for the information!
Sugreev2001  +   1507d ago
Ah,the two sequels of my two favorite games of all time (other being Batman Arkham Asylum) are looking like they will top their predecessors without a doubt.
#29 (Edited 1507d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Ace_Man_6  +   1507d ago
9.9…… really? lol
narutogameking  +   1507d ago
yes 9.9.
« 1 2 3 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Désiré - Prologue: Walkthrough Guide

4h ago - Appunwrapper writes: "This is a complete step-by-step walkthrough for the iOS and Android point-a... | iPhone

Blaze Proves the Commodore Amiga Was Capable of Sonic the Hedgehog

4h ago - Carl Williams writes, "While Sega never supported the Commodore Amiga with any games, they did la... | Retro

HotLiked - What the Internet is talking about right now

Now - Kill some time at You will regret it... | Promoted post

Westwood Studios to Receive Industry Icon Award at The Game Awards 2015

4h ago - Host Geoff Keighley just announced that the defunct Westwood Studios will receive the “Industry I... | Retro

Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes – Tips, Tricks, Cheats, How to Beat, and Strategy Guide

4h ago - Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes is a new iOS and Android mobile RPG. | iPhone

Yokai Watch Dance Gets Two New Japanese Commercials

5h ago - Level-5 has released two new commercials showing off the game’s colorful and adorable gameplay. | Wii U