Is character death as a motivating game mechanic still really necessary?
It's a good way to give consequence for action and therefore gives meaning to interactivity. Though, these days, even death isn't much of a consequence as games have come up with numerous ways to ease the consequence of death (auto-saves for example) It's not just death though, the idea of failing in general is the primary motivator to do well. Death is the most common way to signal ultimate failure, especially when playing as a character.
Agreed. If you can just restart over and over, who cares if you die?
I think if a gamer loses some item or quest becuase of his failures, it can looked as as annoying. we want that 1005 completion. I like how heavy rain did it, where there were no continues or redos...the story never stopped. getting the gold/achievement in prince of persia for having less than 100 deaths was a good incentive for keeping your butt in check.
Most games are about surviving, so is life... ironically. Failing is perfectly natural.
The Prince of All Cosmos can't die, but being a disappointment to his father feels just the same.
It makes you *want* to die. I'M SORRY THE BALL WAS TOO SMALL, FATHER. I COULDN'T FIND ANY MORE CATS!
What about the games that charge you in game funds to respawn like Borderlands? Thats a primary motivator for me not to die...I'll run out of money.
It's not so much the death itself that holds consequence, but the fact I'll have to trek all the way back to where I F***ing died! Although knowing this always makes me play better, since I can't stand having to beat the enemies that I owned already, lol.
There are many alternate punishments is all kinds of games. Losing items, spending money, getting the wrong portion of the story, finding the wrong clue, etc...Like stated above, death is the ultimate "you hit rock bottom, now fix it" route. There is nothing worse than death. The better question is why do games fall to guns a majority of the time? If there are guns, you expect death, period. Meanwhile look at board games. Monopoly no guns, ultimate failure is going bankrupt. Risk, you dont use the guns, ultimate failure losing your territory....and so on.
The 08 Prince of Persia Reboot didnt have death, but the primary motivator for me was its story, gameplay and the world, It was amazing and beautiful
Agreed. There wasn't anything I DIDN'T love about that game.
I dont understand why Ubisoft hasnt made a sequel already? Imo, the original prince is pretty much done, and while the the three games were great, I heard the fourth was just a quick cash in. I would LOVE for a sequel to the cel-shaded Prince, all the more considering Enslaved wont be getting one.
I think, perhaps, fans of the original Prince gave new Prince a hard time. But with new Prince and Elika around, I could be cool not playing the old Prince and his stories.
N4G is a community of gamers posting and discussing the latest game news. It’s part of NewsBoiler, a network of social news sites covering today’s pop culture.