130°
Submitted by Gamedot 1383d ago | review

Dead Island review - Gamedot

"Dead Island was a fantastic idea but sadly does not deliver. Features of the game can be found elsewhere and in better form, meaning Dead Island leaves a feeling of disappointment that you only get when it throws it down during your two week holiday to Majorca..." (Dead Island, PC, PS3, Xbox 360) 5/10

jessupj  +   1383d ago
While I think 5/10 is a bit harsh, I think the combat wasn't very polished at all.

For fear of looking like a wanker, I'm very good at most games and usually am very quick to learn a new game and analyse my performance as I'm playing.

But in Dead Island I seem to die more often then I should. Because of the limited range and the sluggish movement of the character, it's very hard to come out of a 1 vs 3 fight flawlessly.

Before you call noob, I have 3 Demon's Souls platinums

It's fun, but not satisfying, not like Demon's Souls.
despair  +   1383d ago
I thought the combat was pretty decent, I play on the PC so I don't know if that makes a difference. But I learned which weapons had range and how to hit and fall back and of course use your kick which is invaluable.

I also found the game to play and feel much better when you reach act 2, I'm a ways into that one right now and my enjoyment of the game increased quite a bit.

But I can see how people are turned off by it but I like it a lot and the melee combat system works well, especially when you play tactically instead of swinging wildly. The idea is to avoid groups as they surround you and retreat and attack at your convenience.

PS: gotta love the shock mod on a machete.
#1.1 (Edited 1383d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
jessupj  +   1382d ago
O yeah, shock mod Machete is my go to weapon. Love it when it crits on a thug.

One thing I do love doing in Act 2 is agroing a bunch of zombies, jumping on the hood of the car, and continue to merrily swing away at my leisure. That is one thing that is very satisfying.

Guess I'll just have to keep perfecting my technique though.
#1.1.1 (Edited 1382d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
strange1986  +   1383d ago
I think you're supposed to choose your battles. Your character isn't a super-powered juggernaut, so sometimes it's better to avoid conflict altogether. If that's not your style, just spam the hell out of the jump kick. The game would be waaay harder without it.
candystop  +   1383d ago
This isn't L4D which is why the zombies are harder to kill and done so perfectly. I didn't start to like the game until act2. Dead island doesn't feel like your typical run and gun which may be a problem for some. The game is a 9 in my book and so far the best zombie experience I've ever played through.
MadMax  +   1383d ago
Game deserves nothing under an 8!!! Fantastic game and a great ride!
MysticStrummer  +   1383d ago
It would be an 8 if the amazing number of bugs didn't make it a 5. I've given up on trying to play it until the next patch rolls out for the PS3 version. Buggiest game I've ever played.
despair  +   1383d ago
never played fallout 3 did ya?
MasterD919  +   1383d ago
Look at the scope of Fallout compared to Dead Island....And they were on top of a lot of the major issues and still released patches years after.

IMO Fallout>Dead Island but that's coming from a someone with the Fallout guy as his avatar =)
despair  +   1383d ago
I wasn't saying that fallout is a bad game or that some of the bugs weren't understandable (they could've fixed a lot of the easy to find ones before release), neither was I comparing it to Dead Island.

MysticStrummer said Dead Island was the buggiest game he played and I know that the buggiest game I ever played was Fallout 3 followed by Fallout NV, see the connection to my post :)
#3.1.2 (Edited 1383d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

7 Female Characters Changing the Face of Video Game Heroes

14m ago - Playboy: When it comes to main characters in video games—and even secondary characters to a large... | PC
20°

Japanese Game Composers Made A Free Album To Get Closer To Western Fans

55m ago - Want a free album made by some of the top Japanese game composers? Well, here you go. | Culture
Ad

YoYo Games, home of GameMaker: Studio

Now - Game development could not be simpler with GameMaker: Studio, the fastest and easiest to use 2D game engine! | Promoted post
20°

Anima: Gate of Memories Will Be Released In The Next Few Months

55m ago - Action RPG Anima: Gate of Memories has been greenlit on Steam and will be released on PC within t... | PC
20°

7 Video Games That Had Gay Marriage Before it was Cool

56m ago - Hicuo: "The world of video games has its own issues when it comes to inclusiveness, and as in the... | PC
40°

Is E3 still relevant?

1h ago - GG writes: "This is my third time at E3 and I've seen first hand the changes and impact that live... | E3