Submitted by Kamikaze8 1461d ago | opinion piece

Bach Inadvertently Calling Many Gamers Childish

Loud Mouthed Gamers: Speaking in an interview with Rock, Paper, Shotgun, Patrick Bach Executive Producer of Battlefield 3 has given his opinion on how his game will be more mature than other games out there. "We are trying to do something that is more mature. Mature not being gore –some people confuse the two. That’s childish actually, to want more blood. I think games need to grow up a bit." Does he inadvertently call everyone that produces and plays games such as Gears of War childish? (Battlefield 3, Industry, Patrick Bach, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

Septic  +   1461d ago
Talk about making mountain out of molehills
"Technically when he says “I want games for grown-ups,” hes calling everyone that plays Mature rated games, which are only for those who are 18+, by legal means adults, children. Does that make you angry? Because it makes us annoyed."

That's a sweeping statement if I ever read one. I think the author is really taking a lot of what Bach is saying, too literally. Bach is alluding to the use of blood and voilence just for the sake of it. His comment stems from the announcement that you cannot kill civilians in BF3. That, understandably, could strike at the heart of any maturity BF3 is aiming for because it wouldn't really serve any purpose (unless the game was experltly crafted around collateral damage and the psychological affect it can have on soldies- which is not what BF3 is about).

Like I've said before, using blood and gore can enhance the experience in a game and help it become mature. It's just a matter of how you utilise it.
tiffac008  +   1461d ago
That's actually a good point, I never would have thought his comments would be a shot against BF3 than any other thing.

Still some of his comments are far from the truth like players will mostly choose to be bad when given a choice?

We choose the path we take in games to see the difference between them not because we want to be evil. Not to mention its added replay value to the games we put our hard earned money to.
#1.1 (Edited 1461d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
wallis  +   1461d ago
I think the real issue at hand here is he seems to think BF3 is going to be a first for real "mature" gameplay. He talks almost as though all other mature games rely on gore. Not to mention "I think games need to grow up a bit" is pretty unfair considering games like deus ex, mass effect, witcher 2, portal, half life, limbo and braid have shown a load of maturity in their storylines whilst the last single player offering DICE gave us was bad company 2. Enough said.

Yes some games rely on gore but only some and at the end of the day what's wrong with a little bit of fun in a game? I don't see what's immature about a game, or movie, that's silly and over the top and fun. No pihrana 3D isn't as mature as citizen kane, but that doesn't mean it has no place in this world.

I think games themselves are right on track. They've exposed me to more interesting ideas, narratives, worlds and ideas than any movie and they come up a close second to books. The only thing I think needs changing is the industry's obsession with milking gamers for every last penny.

Also let's not forget he probably shouldn't be lecturing anyone on maturity considering that Dice has spent the best part of the last year doing nothing but trying to measure the size of their cock against call of duty's. And whilst I applaud battlefield 3 for trying to give us a serious experience the truth is I don't want to be told what to do. If I want to shoot a civilian I want to shoot the God damned civilian.

If I want a controlled experience I'll watch a movie or play call of duty.
#1.2 (Edited 1461d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Hufandpuf  +   1461d ago
When you give players the option to do bad things, of course people will do them, not because they are bad people, but just to see what happens.

On topic: battlefield 3 will have serious tone without it going onto the area of bad taste. People who want mass destruction, also want non-stop chaos in the game (and maybe the choice to kill civilians also?). That's childish. The guys at DICE are trying to give you believability, think of it as a mix between The Hurt Locker and Black Hawk Down.
NiteX  +   1461d ago
But war itself is childish and immature... sooo yeah...
cpayne93  +   1461d ago
That usually depends on what side you are on.
cpayne93  +   1461d ago
Who disagreed with me? It was childish and immature to fight Hitler in WW2? Would the mature thing to do be letting Hitler exterminate people and take over the world?
Leathersoup  +   1461d ago
If Patrick wanted to actually make a mature game he wouldn't be pandering to the war genre itself so he's being just a bit hypocritical.
hazelamy  +   1461d ago
a storm in a teacup sure, but insulting your potential customers is never a good move i'd have thought.

but then i don't know what kind of bizarro world marketing school that guy went to where it's considered a good idea.
MARKUS_MAX1MUS  +   1461d ago
Hes honestly not far off at all

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Tembo the Badass Elephant review - BritXbox

30m ago - Britbox writes: A new 2D platformer from Sega and Game Freak (the Pokemon guys) means to put t... | PC

Dungeon Souls Creator On What Makes For A Good Action-Based Roguelike

32m ago - Siliconera spoke to Mike Studios about living in the shadow of the Souls games and making a good... | PC

The Wii U Games You Need to Play in August

Now - Let's take a look at what Nintendo will be offering throughout the month. | Promoted post

Street Fighter V Beta CheatCC Preview

34m ago - 60% V-Trigger Combos? Mid combo V-Trigger activations? Look at what is becoming the center of Str... | PS4

Mario History: Super Mario Sunshine - 2002

1h ago - NL: It was a bold move from Nintendo to launch the GameCube in 2001 without a Mario game. The ta... | GameCube

One Year Later: Professor Layton Vs Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney

1h ago - NWR: Presenting a new feature we hope you don't have any objections to. They said it would ne... | 3DS