Game Trailers have compared both EA's Skate and Activision's Tony Hawk's Proving Ground, they finished of with an overall score of 23.7% for Tony Hawk and Skate winning with a 76.2%. The games were scored on Graphics, Tricks, Controls, Modes, Objectives and Extras.
You can view the full breakdown of the scoring on Game Trailers and they also have a HD and Standard definition trailer comparing the skateboarding games as well.
110°
10°
20°
30°
20°
Ad 
20°
