Games on Smash ask the question "What If Uncharted 3 Sucks?"
The chance of uncharted 3 sucking is about 0%
What if these "journos" had something to say? My Lord the world would be doomed.
Watch the vid first before commenting!
^ "What if someone actually watches the video?" :D
you know why it wont suck? 2 words: Naughty Gods
"what if someone actually assigns an appropriate title?" :D
What if someone stops using sensationalist titles to engender hits and then when they are called on the carpet they stop falling back on "Watch the vid!" or "Read the article!"? Here is a hint pal. The title IS part of the article. Idiotic questions asked in said title with the design induce hits is a crap, TMZ paparazzi quality attempt at journalism and has no use for persons seeking intelligent and insightful commentary.
^^What if people on N4G grew up? That way journos wouldn't have to rely on flaimbait titles to get people on this site to listen to them.
. THE MOST PATHETIC WAY TO GET ON N4G .
What if pizza sucked?? What if big breasted women didnt turn you on anymore?? uuugh..
More than a handful is a waste.
I got big hands so..
@BeOneWithTheGun......Thats just sad!
i am a gay and even i like big breasts but pizza does suck sometimes
I'm assuming none of you actually watched the video. The title is VERY misleading. He basically questions if UC3 will get the critical acclaim that UC2 got and he says that it probably won't. And hes right. God of War 2, Killzone 3, and LBP 2 were all arguably better than their predecessors..yet they all sold less and got less critical acclaim that their first iterations.
I think you mean GOW 3. Anyways the fact that some sequels improve on their predecessor but still get lower scores is due to the fact that standards and expectation have changed. Reviews arent a science or something where a better looking sequel or better playing for instance automatically scores higher. Even gamers themselves dont sometimes seem as hyped for some sequels. Sales prove it for KZ3 or LBP2 for instance like Logic already said above. UC3 probably isnt going to score as high as UC2 and I bet the same for Mass Effect 3.
Uncharted 2 took a giant leap from Uncharted 1, and it's going to be tough for ND to top that. The game isnt going to suck, but fans are setting themselves up for disappointment if they are going to hype that the media will give it more than they gave UC2. Like many games, it will score the same or slightly lower IMO (especially with websites like IGN and Gamespot now operating on a 0.5 meter) The logic that a sequel deserves more because it adds more isn't so obvious as people think-- you can't, for example, give a game a perfect 10 just because the previous title got a 9.9 because likely there may be a new flaw or two. Just look at Jak 1 and Jak 2. The maturation of that game was excellent. Jak 3 was great, but Jak 2 was still the more impressive, more improved title. UC3 will be great, but if the game "sucks" it will be because fans are trying to hype it as perfection
"UC3 will be great, but if the game "sucks" it will be because fans are trying to hype it as perfection" YUP, pretty much. The people with the lowest expectations from a game are ALWAYS the ones who will have the most fun with it.
What if cows start flying and i turn into a women?
That's mandatory. :P
'womEn' And you would have proved that Multiplicity is in fact possible
grammar nazi @bushlitter ;)
"What If Uncharted 3 Sucks" : I don't think that's even possible
i don't think it's possible, either. UC1/UC2 were GREAT fun - i find it impossible to believe that a talented dev like ND would all of a sudden mess up a franchise that has been so good for 2 previous games.
"Or maybe scallops will fly out of my pants!"
Honestly this is one of the only titles with Skyrim, Infinite, Rage and Arkham that I am almost certain will be blind buys. You know what I mean? Rage is looking to be my dark horse this E3 and my show surprise probably will be Bioshock Infinite.
i think the car combat in rage looks like kick-ass fun.....but the rest of the game has that "been there - dont that" feel to me. skyrim, batman, resistance3 are the games (besides UC3) coming out this year that are preorder "day 1" for me.
Did you watch the whole Wells trailer for Rage? I was getting that Bioshock vibe from the atmosphere and the graphics look phenomenal. There seems to be something special with ammo affecting the gameplay in cool ways. I have all the PS3 resistance games and will get R3. Actually I forgot that the game is coming out this year aswell. LOL!
if UC3 sucked .. the world would implode .. creating a black hole sucking the universe back into a single particle ..... yes its that serious
I do get the impression critics will not score U3 like U2, or at least hold it to unrealistic/unfair expectations because U2 was so successful. There's a sense that because the last game got it's fame - they won't give the new one the same recognition just to try to share the spotlight. No U2 isn't perfect, it can be boring, but so can ANY game.
It will hurt an up and coming franchise which would be disappointing. Lets hope it doesn't I have every faith in Naughty Dog's ability
it's already had 2 iterations and both have been spectacular - this series has passed the "up and coming" tag.
Amy Hennig...enough said.
Possibly the leading female video-game designer.
possibly the lead video-game designer in the business, great writer too...I'm a bit biased though as I loved the LoK games more than any other and the SP in Uncharted has been my favorite this gen.
Yea because uncharteds success was all due to her fruits of labor ? Not the dozens of Talented Engineers, and artists that worked for her but left the studio after Uncharted 2 for other studios. Uncharted 3 will be like Mw3 a game hurt by a less talented studio, Infinity Ward and Naughty Dog are no longer the same studios they were 2 years ago. Both had all of their talent stripped.
@ soccomnick Your opinion means nothing on this site. You do nothing but trash PS3 exclusives and everything that has something to do with them. Please, just do everyone a favour and stop posting because you have absolutely nothing beneficial to contribute to conversion, and besides you only have one bubble so there is nothing much that you really can say.
Amy is someone I would love to hangout with.
. ...releasing the game at the same time as MW3 and Battlefield 3 is near suicide for Uncharted. I suspect they will do what they did with GT and move the release from November to the end of December. Uncharted, the franchise, has a slightly different demographic than FPS COD or Battlefield but ND is trying to bring a little of COD to the franchise to try to tap into the massive market that COD has created. CoD Elite will be tough to beat this year for anybody.
I agree that the fall lineup is very congested, but Uncharted is a AAA franchise so I doubt it will be hugely affected. I would not release any new IPs in November though, that's for sure.
You also fighting against the biggest new ip assassin creed, and you fighting against the most anticipated rpg skyrim. Big big novemeber.
November is more than overpacked: AC, Skyrim, UC3, MW3, BF3, Witcher 2, Forza 4, MGS HD Collection. Some of the games above are going under for sure unfortunatly.
gamestop is going to be full this december....full of moms buying mw3 for their kids
i wouldn't take MW3 if you gave it to me for free. unless treyarch makes it AND it has zombies - i don't buy - and i only buy those when the used price drops to 25 or less on amazon. i've already preordered and think UC3 will be just fine.
There is no way Uncharted 3 can suck. If any game developing companies know the PS3's powers, it's Naughty Dog. Who even got the thought of Uncharted 3 being suck-ish? O___o
I will buy it no matter what.
what if gamesonsmash sucks ? questions over questions
LOL I was gonna say that. AND Uncharted 3 won't suck.
that is like you said gta games sucks,or metal gear solid games sucks. those are all masterpieces,and tey can't be bad!!!
its bringing more things how can it suck?
Adding more things means more things to account for. With weapon customization, the leveling up of boosters, medal kickbacks, and the ability to sprint..it will be harder for ND to balance the multiplayer because there are more factors to consider. The less factors in a multiplayer game...the easier it is to balance. More is not always better. Btw, watch the video. It has nothing to do with UC3 sucking. It just talks about the possible balance issues the game MAY have due to the new features I mentioned.
its good, but its not game of the year material as everybody (ps3 owners) made out. its just a solid action adventure game with great graphics, nothing really revolutionary about it.
The revolutionary thing about Uncharted is that it takes things from other games and blends them into perfection. I beleive it will be hard to find much wrong with UC3. I mean, name one major complaint about UC2?
The only bad thing I can see happening is if these websites we have witnessed on here for a long time don't truthfully say in their reviews how good Uncharted 3 is. For example I could see IGN giving the game an 8.0 or an 8.5 and giving a game like MW3 a perfect 10
sucks your time
What if Uncharted 3 sucks? it won't suck, and I can say that with 100% certainty and confidence.
Sorry could you tell me where I can get my advance copy of the game aswell? Cheers in advance mate.
Cheers for the sarcasm. If Uncharted 1 and 2 are anything to go by, which they are...its pretty obvious that UC3 won't suck; ND are competant developers, infact, they're one of the best developers out there. To suddenly make UC3 crap after building upon the formula in UC1 and 2, would be nearly impossible, unless you just hate on popular games. Will Uncharted 3 be the best in the trilogy? I don't know, I still prefer UC1 over 2, just (despite lack of multiplayer), but I still think UC2 is a classic.
@tigertron Dragon Age II says hello
@Bushlitter Unlike EA, Sony wouldnt push their developers to do a DA2.
plp watch the video the title is misleading hes not saying its bad
in negative sentiment, and insinuations. It's either a combination of what seems to be ture that Sony fans have the capability of being critical against Sony, while Xbox and Nintendo fans have an almost unshakeable commitment tot heir consoles or peoples psyches are absolutely controlled by the currupt media, maybe it's all of that. I never once heard anyone bring up the MAss Effects new focus on Gun attachments as ripping off COD from either side of "war" I never heard someone insinuate even with the shortcomings of Dragon Age anything whatsoever that could be a negative connotation towards Mass Effect 3. I forget which philosophical mind said this recently, but I have to quote him by saying "What's up wit that!
Just finished up playing Uncharted 2's multiplayer which I haven't touched since December 2009. I can tell you now, judging from that, the game WILL NOT suck
Can we have the same video for gears of war 3 too? Can we all shut up and let ND do their job? god!! seriously every single PS3 game has to go through the same BS. I don see this much criticism for DA2, Mass Effect2 or 3,or any other game that is deemed inferior to its predecessor.
you can say this about any game.
It won't suck.When God created the word'Uncharted'he also had to create the word'Epic'! Then he made up the word 'is' and stuck it in the middle! I either read that in the bible or made it up,either way it's true!
Its entirely possible, Time will tell.
There is none. Chance of it not living up to the hype? - Pretty high, considering how amazing Uncharted 2 was.
I doubt it sucks, but it'll be more of the same. If your a fan of it I am sure you'll like it. I wouldn't expect leaps and bounds with it though, as a less then two year development time is tough to really get that many improvements. It's actually the same development cycle as the Modern Warfare series. The last game scored very high, I hope to get the chance to play through it sometime this year, I have it sitting unopened on my shelf. I just think when your at the top there is nowhere to go but down, even if it's slightly down. I think people and reviewers are going to be looking for flaws this time around....
world will cease to exist
That's literally impossible. It's based off the foundation of one of this generation's most acclaimed games. Maybe it won't be as big of a step up as the second was, but it's still going to be amazing.