Submitted by Bboy_Izilla 1444d ago | article

Uncomfortable Realism

Isaiah Taylor of Couchbound.net writes: "Violence in video games usually date the game itself. Clearly, violence will consistently escalate to feed the sadistic habits of consumers. Battlefield 3 [a game I'm looking forward to, may be venturing into a territory of uncomfortable realism, which may be what gaming needs" (Battlefield 3, Culture, Mortal Kombat 9)

rabidpancakeburglar  +   1445d ago
I've got no issue with seeing someone get blown to pieces in a game but if it was real life I'd be sickened. No matter how realistic games get the aren't real life, people realise that. I agree that realism is more vital in gaming as it just makes games better.
#1 (Edited 1445d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
morganfell  +   1444d ago
To people that have actually been in a combat unit, not even the graphics of BF3 can provide realism. Devs always sabotage themselves with conventionality.

The BF3 reveal vid was good for about 8 seconds. Then the weapons carry immediately robbed you of the suspension of belief as they fell back on the same old tired positions.

At the briefing table the the marine on the far left was good MOCAP but the overly demonstrative body movements of the CO ruined it. Then the tactical movement began and it really choked. The "flag everyone doom weapon view" is the biggest detractor from realism in modern shooters.

Thank goodness an established shooter will change that next year with it's new mechanics. If developers are going to get close to realism, more than graphics are needed. Not every soldier, airman, sailor, or marine sounds like some juvenile. Body positioning and movement, including lack of it must be heeded.

Ragdoll physics need to be reformed. And what happens when a person is really shot or injured should be presented. It isn't pretty, especially when someone knows they are going to die, but that's realism. Sociologists say that games inure us to violence but it is actually the developers whose failure to present realism that sanitizes killing.
MariaHelFutura  +   1445d ago
I like realism in certain types of games.

Uncomfortable Realism (see video)

Related video
TheKindRoost  +   1444d ago
It's probably just me but I didn't find the vid that disturbing, it's perfectly natural(prey and predator). Now what I find disturbing is seeing the vid of children that are victims of war.
#2.1 (Edited 1444d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
SpLinT  +   1444d ago
It's probably just me but I don't find that disturbing.
MariaHelFutura  +   1444d ago
I don`t find it distrubing, I love it. I find death intriguing. Things die, I`ve accepted that. I do feel sorry for the goat though, that`s a rough way to go.
#2.1.2 (Edited 1444d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report
rabidpancakeburglar  +   1444d ago
WTF was that??? That was one of the funniest things I've seen in ages
e-p-ayeaH  +   1444d ago
I like realism to a certain degree but BF3 is not one of those games that i should take seriously by any means.

I remember back in the day ( 1990´s ) not liking to shoot bad guys in the head because it felt to brutal and unnecessary but since that become such a normal thing in the shooter genre i got used to it like everyone else.
#3 (Edited 1444d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
HeavenlySnipes  +   1444d ago
Games can't be realistic
Battlefield isn't realistic COD isn't realistic none of the games out are. (Maybe Arma or whatever its called)

Reason being because then it wouldn't be fun.

You think if a car blew up 10 feet from you from an RPG you'd have all limbs in tact. Or that you could chuck a grenade with ease? Or even survive a grenade in close proximity? When you get shot in a game you are crippled then have to work in an office for the rest of your life because you are not fit for duty lol.

Games could have realistic elements to them to make them unique, but no, no game can be completely realistic.
Ducky  +   1444d ago
I don't think that's the side of realism they're focusing on.

This is more so realism on a visual level (i.e. the situations that the game tries to recreate and what it shows you) rather than a gameplay level.
#4.1 (Edited 1444d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
thugbob  +   1444d ago
"Games could have realistic elements to them to make them unique, but no, no game can be completely realistic."

No duh sherlock. All you did was state the obvious.
ForROME  +   1444d ago
Games should be real and should be violent when its the point of the game, people who are effected by violence in video games, should not be playing video games

End of Story
iamnsuperman  +   1444d ago
It is a shame that these titles strive for realism but fall short. The whole one man army thing is why these games fall into the normal military FPS category and not the true military FPS. I know this guy is talking about graphics but what he really should be focusing on is the other usually forgotten realism. I want a game that involves company/platoon attacks not this recky patrol being sent in to take down a company, where the enemy AI is organised as always trying to get into cover while out flanking you, where your friendly AI are competent soldiers and where tactics actually matter and not this waves of enemies which can be beaten if you hit the deck and take what is being thrown at you. I think this is a step the FPS needs to go where you actually think about what you are about to do and how you will execute your objective
#6 (Edited 1444d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
blackhammer  +   1444d ago
I want Six Days in Fallujah.
BeastlyRig  +   1444d ago
Wait till Arma3!!
mamotte  +   1444d ago
I want games to be fun, no realistic. Somehow, I dont like realism in games at all, I prefer Portal, and bulletstorm... not another military shooter, with more polygons.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

MOBA Fever Claims Yet Another Victim

2h ago - Oh great, it’s another one of those articles about a new MOBA player that’s shamelessly falling i... | PC

Assassin's Creed Chronicles: China Review - BGU

2h ago - "It was unfortunate that Assassin’s Creed Chronicles: China came to an end as soon as it did. 15-... | PC

Study Game Design at DeVry

Now - DeVry University, is an accredited* university offering you the flexibility of over 90 locations, online courses and a wide variety of bachelor's a... | Promoted post

Review: Will Fight for Food | Hardcore Gamer

2h ago - Will Fight For Food is a charming mix of an RPG, a point and click adventure and a belt-scrolling... | PC

Mortal Kombat X Review | Gaming Union

2h ago - Despite a petty want for prettier visuals, Mortal Kombat X is still a fantastic debut on the new... | PC

Age of Wonders III and Eternal Lords Review | Gamestyle

2h ago - GS: Age of Wonders III is a big and imposing game and the sort of thing that requires several hu... | PC