120°
Submitted by matgrowcott 1082d ago | article

One More Castle ¦ 5 Things We've Learnt About Video Game Journalism During The PSN Downtime

Mat Growcott of One More Castle writes:

'Video Game Journalism is something of a frowned upon set of work. People are only too ready to criticize pieces written only for hits, but it doesn't stop thousands of people flocking to your website for said pieces. It's an odd situation to work in, things that you're proud of very rarely get the hits they deserve.

Striking the balance between a level of professionalism and a level of pandering is difficult to do and I would say accounts for the reason thousands of blogs fall into obscurity every single month.

The past fortnight or so has offered an incredibly unique opportunity to examine ourselves as a collective. The PSN downtime has been covered by small blogs, respected sites and major news outlets, making comparison between each group incredibly easy. What we've discovered isn't shocking, more common sense, but it is interesting nonetheless.

Besides, an Expert told us. So, it's all true.' (PS3)

Chaostar  +   1082d ago
I've always thought that video game 'journalism' has been terrible but since the PSN went down we've seen the true extent of the desperate clamoring for attention.

As each vulture swooped down for a peck, re-writing the same news in a slightly different fashion, I couldn't help but wonder about the savagery of human nature and why it is that we, as a species, find such pleasure in the suffering of others.

The author makes a good point about 'experts' here. If websites were held accountable for their dubious sources we would see a lot less 'experts' voicing their opinions as fact.
#1 (Edited 1082d ago ) | Agree(11) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
matgrowcott  +   1082d ago
I think if my point is anything, it's that Journalism as a whole is pretty terrible, when judged by the general public.

Simply put, the day that well-written, smart critique gets the same sort of hits that trashy "best boob" type articles and scare-news gets, that'll be the day that Journalism as a whole gets better. But we, as writers, have to provide a product. If more people want the latter than the former, that's the product we're going to give.

Popular opinion is that that's in the hand of the writers. It's not. The quality of the Journalism is entirely in the hands of the readers and what they're reading.
Chaostar  +   1082d ago
I do agree that fault lies with readers clicking on obvious flamebait links but I see it as more of a viscious circle.

It takes two to tango.
matgrowcott  +   1082d ago
@Chaostar

Let me give an example. Back when Duke Nukem was reannounced last year, there had been rumblings that it would happen for a few days before. As such, I spent a few days writing a retrospective of the previous games.

It came in at a little under 4000 words. It was pretty damn good, even if I say so myself. In it's entire lifespan, that article got in about 600 hits. At the same time, I remember there being an article on here about "the 10 dirtiest bits in Duke Nukem" or something, which given how 'hot' it got and how many places I saw linking to it afterwards, must have got about 10-20 times that amount.

I agree that we could all use far less flamebait articles, but writing well takes a lot of time, and the payout isn't usually worth it.
Xof  +   1082d ago
I've never actually said this about anything I found n N4G, but that was... a very well-written article. I'm glad I took the time to read it.
Silly gameAr  +   1082d ago
It has been one joke after another with the gaming media. This whole PSN fiasco just bought it to a whole new level. Nothing but flamebait and trolling.
snyder2nyce  +   1082d ago
thank you
all the good articles get hardly any attention while all the ones with shockin headlines do. I remember this psn related article with the most hits with less than a 3 sentences.
OcelotRigz  +   1082d ago
All these comments pretty much some up the state of gaming journalism, or just journalism in general.

Two things was really apparent to me thru this whole fiasco, when someone is down, everyone is queuing up to kick them. Secondly, one word; "Exaggeration".
snyder2nyce  +   1081d ago
Lets see how many hits or how many actually took the time and read the whole article

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
10°

Grey Goo Interview with Petroglyph's Lead Designer

3m ago - SelectButton chats with Andrew Zoboki, Lead Designer at Petroglyph on the upcoming title Grey Goo... | PC
10°

Sportsfriends Developer Interview

4m ago - SelectButton chats with Ramiro and Noah from Die Gute Fabrik about the release of the competitive... | PC
10°

Are You The Games You Play?

4m ago - From EGMR, "I regularly wonder what defines us as gamers. Are we the games we play, or not? Norma... | Culture
10°

Heads Up, Mobile Gamers: Turtle Beach M1′s are On Sale

13m ago - In a world where the alleged “Dr.” Dre can sell musical contraptions for exorbitant amounts of mo... | iPhone
Ad

Dark Souls II Review

Now - Drew digs deep into Dark Souls II and delivers a first… | Promoted post
30°

A Video Game Meant To Take Us Back To The Physical World

16m ago - Mobile phones and computer screens can distract us from engagement in the real world and that's b... | Android