Another multiplatform game, another round of comparing. This time it's Skate on the 360 & PS3. Pretty nice done, same place, same tricks, about the same shots.
couldnt tell a difference whatsoever. thats good i guess
Barely see the different, PS3 version have different grown texture though (look at the slow motion part)
but something THAT small really doesn't matter these 2 games look identical.
Nothing sticks out to me that would make me say it looks better on either console.
Which in a way sucks. Because that means the game could look better if fully optimized for one or the other.
Instead we have a game generation of multi-port games that never reach potential either because it is not exclusive to one console or the devs are afraid of pissing off Sony and MS so they water the games down to look near identical on both consoles... We don't win as gamers with this sort of strategy.
look at the ground
The ps3 version has better lighting,crisper textures .
look at the railing which looks red in ps3 version and pink in x360 version
Yeah couldn't tell the difference, although the camera seems to be further back in the PS3 version
The only difference I noticed was the detail on the pavement. The ps3 had more detail, but other then that, it looked almost completely identical.
The xbox 360 version was much better, you better look again and pay attention.
Blind fan boys is what you are.
Im getting it for the PS3.(if i get it)
Maybe you're blind, I'm no fanboy, I own a 360 only, and I can clearly tell that the ps3 has a slight edge. You sound more like a fanboy then anybody else who's posted objectively.
You can ollie higher in the PS3 version.
Did you sell yourself for an xbox 360?
Pretty good, PS3. Considering that you're a stop notch DVD and Bluray player, rivalring $1000 bluray and Denon DVD players.
More ground detail in the PS3 version. The lighting is more realstic at the very end of that video on that sea shell fence contraption. But that's subjective. I KNOW, for sure, everyone else would say that the xbox360 looks more contrasty, but in my humble opinion, I think the washed out colors on that contraption is more realistic. That's how it would truly look in real life.
Hey, if comic book artists used real human anatomy for their comic book characters, I'm sure spiderman or wolverine or the hulk won't look as good as they do to the comic book reader's eyes, despite the way out of proportion anatomy. That's why some people might not like the washed out look on the PS3. It's more realistic. TOO realistic. Gamers might prefer warped, super hot intensive colors even though they know that in real life, it won't look that way. For me, I prefer the washed out faded look of realism over cartoon saturation anyday. I did't spend so much money on home entertainment equipment to get artificial colors and saturations, did I?
Version is slightly hazy, you'll notice about half way through.
I expected u to like the ps3 version what a surpize
No, I don't... They just looks the same all the video.
its really hard to take that comment seriously when your avatar is a guy peeing on a ps3. yeah...
I don't agree that the PS3 version looks hazy. It looks clearer. More detailed and better lit. It could look a lot better if it wasn't just a port.
looks good on both consoles, I am sure people will be staring too close to their monitors to try and find any differences.
Best comment in a long time
But the differences are so minute it really doesnt matter. Here are a few that I picked up on in the HD version close up shots.
The ps3 version is crisper and more anti-antialised.
The xbox 360 versions floors do not have as much texture, marks etc. on them as the ps3 version.
The ps3 version has deeper lighting effects and more particle reflection than the 360 version.
But other than a few MINUTE, and im talking MINUTE differences, both versions seem to be absolutely identical and looks and sounds awesome! A real challenger to the Tony Hawk franchise which has so far dominated the skating video game market.
lets talk outta our asses now
you gott 4:1 agree:disagree ratio
this show how biased this site is
But only when you slow-motion the frames and run in HD, if you are playing at normal speed on SD then there is no different what so ever.
first off both camera angles are slightly different, so you can not sit there and talk about different ground textures when they are at different ranges, so hence varying detail (stupid), then you want to talk about lighting and particle affects, whoah really (what particle affects?). And then lighting, ummm, different camera distances mean different contact with light and at a different observable angle.
Man yall really try hard to see things that aren't there, and then you talk about graphics like you really know what they are using. Unless your the developer of this game, we shouldn't hear who is using AAx2 or x4, and hdr, and dynamic lighting, particle affects, NOTHING. The funny thing is that there are a lot more Sony supporters on this site, and i have nothing against sony, but it's fans are worse than XBox and Wii fans combined, it might be because of their sheer number but yall really have to get a life. Enough with validating your purchase, be happy with what you got, the only people who should really have a reason to pay attention to these comparisons are the people with both or all three systems. All you sony only's and Xbox only's need to stop!
Goodness, are you a detective or someting. Minute particle effects...?
they look Identical, with the PS3 getting a tiny bit of the edge, about 99.9 percent Identical.
-there are more pedestriants in the ps3 version
-the hills in the xbox360 version have greater dynamic color, but it ends up not looking uniform with the trees in front of them, which have a less dynamic color.
But I don't care about board skating...
nice to see this game though
*Sigh* Another multiplatform game another comparison video so here we go. At least the PS3 is starting to show it's true colours and prove that it can keep up with if not better the 360
I can't even tell
the only thing i noticed that the ps3 had better ground textures. also the shoes were a little blurry on the 360 version. all i care about is that i want a dang demo of this on psn!!!
Who really cares? (except fanboys)
cant really be seen unless your sitting there for about 10 minutes staring at something.
I thought the 360 version looked smoother and better, but halfway threw they looked pretty much the same, and at points the ground textures even look sharper on PS3.
hopefully it means the dev's are getting better at delivering a good experaince on both consoles :D
mah comment got lots o' responsez, but none seem to relate to it! lulz
how fanbots are trying to show the 360 look just a little bit better but they are also forgetting the fact that all the dev kit use by ea and all other third partyies(excluding epic ) are only using the sppu leaving apartthe 7sppe(yes they are seven one deactive fro now ,just do the math 9-2 7 left)which mean they are only using 20% of the ps3's power at max(hey just do some research or search for interview with the devs ),while in the other hand they are doing second gen programming for xbox3fixme using at least 70% of its power at least .
hahah fanboy just owned themselves once again.
Edit sorry i forgot to mention they look exactly the same way but ps3 version has a little bit more texture and more trees in the background,i know is silly but i hate people sayin ps3 is worse while its the most powerful ever created game console yet
you owned your self and made of yourself a joke .
are you PMSing or what?
Where did that come from...
uh oh, new name "fanbots"..
both games like fine..Except the 360 had 5 more pixels.
your such an idiot
That is the most idiotic reply I hve ever heard.
Please dont come here again.
Jesus Christ Buddy it's just a game its just a video game console, don't you think its about time to leave your mom's basement and step outside to the real world? Because the percentage of you getting a girlfriend is 0-.9% *SNORT*
ok back to the comparison, they both look good stop getting you fanboy undies wet and just get the game.
I have been playing the demo over and over. Tony Hawk is toast. PS3 Xbox who cares what it looks like cause they both are not the greatest graphics but the gameplay is really really excellent. release day buy for me.
if you and only you do not buy anything from EA, EA will not have enough fund to finsh devlopment in this game.
if u r not buying anything from EA, Y R U in thread about EA game ?
I saw the 360 had a extra leaf on the tree! Anyone notice that?
i thought the belt buckle texture was way better on the 360 version. ill get it on 360 for sure
If you want 199 leafs you get the PS3 version but if you want 200 you get the 360 version. Just a heads up, if you see a leaf missing don't get mad at me.
I know dude I heard that the PS3's version's character has a slightly bigger nose screw that! im going with the wii version!
i see no difference whatsoever. on a different note i played the demo on xbl very fun game better then tony hawk
Glad to see good work from EA..at least so far. Not really a fan of skating but do appreciate the good work being put into multiplatform games just the way it shoud be.
Who disagreed with my comment and why???
Whoever did this video is a pro... Lot's of great work done.
I guess all the EA devs across the world could learn a lot from their co-workers from Vancouver... WOW.
does it really matter? they are both the same game i love skating games so ill love this for both systems.
man psychologists would love this place full of people seeing things where there is none. I wonder what name they would give for this condition?
fanboyism maybe ;)
1st that lame PS3 piracy vid now this. Does he wake and think ways to bash the ps3?
Well this time it didnt work.
The game looks the same until they zoom in then u can see the ps3 has texture to the ground other than that the difference are to small to notice.
just because he prefers the XBox360 doesn't mean he can't post something like this. They both look identical. He said nothing, and here you go bashing him, for what? You don't even make any sense. It was a great comparison vid, one of the best i've seen.
The PS3 wins by .1%. The ground textures were better and it seemed smoother. Regardless a great game, finally giving the Tony Hawk series a run for it's money(Oh who am I kidding TH just got beat like crazy)
Sweet for both platforms regardless!
THEY LOOK EXACTLY THE SAME TO ME.IF THE GAME WAS BUILT FROM THE GROUND UP ON EACH CONSOLE ONLY THEN WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO DO A TRUE COMPARISON.
It's funny how if you look through the light fanboyism you can see the clear message. No system wins. EA loses and we all win.
I'll just go and add a vote to: My eyes saw no difference. You could've fooled me which version was on which platform.
and should also also Stfu.
Negative news is negative news on here, are you noob...
On this article...which platform was the leading platform?
Mad cause i want your precious leader " The Mart " contributor status revoked.
"Negative news is negative news on here"
The Marts last post was on how to steal PS3 games. That right there should have got his status revoked. Now bringing back the comparison videos well guess what the two games are = so there is no "leading platform" Try again to put the ps3 down.
I u dont like what i say then ignore me already got 6 wouldnt mind if your 7.
Yep, both looked the same to me. Although some have mentioned the better ground textures on the ps3, I had to look at it again and I too have seen a little difference, but nothing to start an argument over it...
Mart finally posted a video in favor of the PS3, nice.
So all you PS3 only fanboys saying EA sucks and boycott EA and now there's a game that looks basically the same on both consoles, you still going to boycott?
You better boycott Crysis also, another EA title.
i thought they onnly published it, not devved it. same with Rock band
It still has EA on the box and that's enough to turn some away. Same way people say they won't buy anything with Microsoft on the package.
Anyway, I don't think people can claim "lazy developers" much longer.