New York Times: Kinect leaves hand controls in the dust

Seth Schiesel reports in the New York Times (Nov 4):

"Nothing since the Wii, certainly not Sony’s imitative Move system for the PlayStation 3, approaches the ambition and technical achievement of Kinect in potentially reshaping the mass home media experience."

He is particularly impressed by the way that by simply uttering voice commands the XBox serves up ESPN programs, movies, music and games.

He sums up the Kinect experience as: "Welcome to the future"

Read Full Story >>
The story is too old to be commented.
tatotiburon2636d ago

good and amazing reviews so far. kinect adventures was a let down but surprising kinectimals is getting some love from reviewers. As espected dance central and your shape fitness are the killer apps this holidays.

can't wait to get my kinect next week

big_silky2636d ago

i'll wait until the 2nd wave of software to get one but much crow will be eaten on n4g the next few days.

GamingGamer2636d ago (Edited 2636d ago )

so far this is only good review... and not from gaming site.

IGN- "it actually doesnt work...well. sorta"
they said they give it higher score for its casualness and such..

Kotaku- "We've both had issues with some Kinect games not recognizing a gesture here or being slow to respond to another"

" the voice-control fail us once in a while, forcing us to repeat whatever we barked at the Kinect. He's had it worse"

"some games simply break, like the time Kinect Sports didn't let him detach a virtual bowling ball from his virtual hand."

Engadget 6/10

Cnet- 3.5/5 even though MS owns them

Destrutoid- not so good...

@disagrees. care to explain?? kinda sad xbox fanboys cant handle this...

A Cupcake for Gabe2636d ago

What the hell is this line: "Nothing since the Wii, certainly not Sony’s imitative Move system for the PlayStation 3, approaches the ambition and technical achievement of Kinect in potentially reshaping the mass home media experience."

What the f'ck is this fanboy anti-sony remark here for?

Masamori Sumimura2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

Are you kidding me? you took all the bad reviews and named them. what about the ones that gave it a good score? you'Re forgetting them? or do you want me to post them for you?

Kinect Review (Strategy Informer) 9.5/10
ElectricPig 5/5

Kotaku ''If Microsoft keeps supporting it, and if its flaws can be patched and improved through software, Kinect can be revolutionary.''

GalaxyNextDoor '' And like Xbox 360 itself which has evolved over time, Kinect’s software will grow just the same. As I said, you’re banking on potential with Kinect, and with Microsoft’s massive support for the wonder sensor - the future of motion gaming on the Xbox 360 is only limited by the power of the game designers behind it. ''

HolyOrangeCows2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

Yep, the fanboys are already here. "OMG OMG OMG! Newspaper reviewer is impressed! It must be awesome!!!"

Yep. Those 2 no-name site reviews totally cancel out that everyone else says that Kinect doesn't work well.
So long as you've got yourself convinced.

-GoldenTimeLover-2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

He gave five sites (IGN, Kotaku, Engadget, Cnet and Destructoid). You only gave two (Strategy Informer and ElectricPig). Plus this site, NYT.

GamingGamer wins.
EDIT: Where did that 9/10 came from? I cant see it anywhere on the site.

gigaware2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

Troll please I can quote bad things said about Move. I guess if I were a PS3 fanboy I'd be upset too if some media outlet that has more in common with average people than gaming media clowned my console. This is why you chose to post only the negative statements from those review from varying grading contexts. There no point {8-bit}

CVG 8.8

CathyLorrain2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

It would be one thing if it was just small random sites reporting all these major problems. But it is the major gaming sites that are the ones talking about huge problems.

So either Kinetic is flaky enough that it is only working some of the time for some sites. Or sites like the New York Times are just taking Microsoft's press/review kit and passing it off as a review.

Shang-Long2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

read the article....
its more about entertainment capabilities then its game console aspect. but i said before it has a chance to succeed especially in the home entertainment side

not sure where that 9/10 came from through theres no score on the page

Masamori Sumimura2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

He gave five websites so what? The Websites he named all said some Positive and Negative stuff about kinect but he only posted the Negative stuff and all the other fanboys jumped on the agree button. I bet you guys dint even read the reviews.

HolyOrangeCows2635d ago

"but much crow will be eaten on n4g the next few days"

Right, because you will associate the sales numbers to quality. It's not hard to guess what you'll say:
"See! Those PS fanboys were wrong! Look at these great sales numbers; Kinect is obviously amazing"

badz1492635d ago

that's what we call as "gimme a piece of that $500m"!

Sitris2635d ago

"For all the talk of revolutionizing the Xbox 360 experience and making gaming more natural/ accessible, it's bordering on absurd how broken Kinect is when it comes to something as simple as working in your home."

"I have to put this bluntly: If you don't have at least 8 feet of unobstructed space between where you plan to place the sensor and the limit of how far back you can stand, Kinect will just not work right. Placing it on top of your television will give you an extra foot or so, but still, those who live in apartments, plan to use Kinect in a bedroom, or otherwise have "unconventional" living room layouts are, for all intents and purposes, screwed."


GamingGamer2635d ago

that guys point was that I named MAJOR 5 gaming website.

while u named 2 no-name gaming website. and score from one of them is not even verifiable apparently.

it seems you are pretty desperate.

Longrod_Von_Hugendon2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

Much crow will be eatin'...but by you.

If you can look at this video and say that kinect preforms need help. Major fail like we've been seeing all along.

ChineseDemocracy2635d ago

I don't know, something seems a little bit off to me.

I want to see some independent reviews from smaller game sites, see what they think.

The general consensus with the PSMove was about 7-8/10, the reviews for kinect seem to be a little bit more inconsistent.

cooperdnizzle2635d ago

The thing is all the sites that gave it a good review are NOT GAMING sites. Every gaming site i have seen has given it a low score. Ill take what the game experts say. Not some lame old reviewer!

raztad2635d ago

"The general consensus with the PSMove was about 7-8/10"

Not exactly. PSMOVE was 8-9/10, and most reviews considered the software lineup when assigning the final score. Which IMO, is pretty unfair for a hardware review. I doubt you will see people doing the same for Kinect.

nycredude2635d ago

"Nothing since the Wii, certainly not Sony’s imitative Move system for the PlayStation 3, approaches the ambition and technical achievement of Kinect in potentially reshaping the mass home media experience."

This line right here tells you everything you need to know about this review. Throw it in the garbage.

+ Show (17) more repliesLast reply 2635d ago
BornToKill2636d ago

amazing reviews?!

keep telling yourself that.

Coffin872635d ago

Since when is New York Times the source for legit video game news?
They're freaking MAINSTREAM, and mainstream hates shooters.
So yeah ...

lokiroo4202635d ago

I guess this will be the review to clutch and refer to? hahahaha

Omega42635d ago

I agree I must say I'm pretty shocked how well most of the software is being received too MS should have released these reviews earlier.

cliffbo2635d ago Show
PostApocalyptic2635d ago

He's going to eat those words.

yewles12635d ago

No he's not, he's already got his "fee".

badz1492635d ago

people buy Kinect and figure out that it's not what they were told it was and leaves Kinect collecting dust leaving other controllers with itself in the dust!

truegame2635d ago

Some of you guys can fight about the review (Good or Bad). However, after ready the review, I did not see any score of 9/10. Could someone point me to the score? or did the poster make up a score? which is wrong to fit his or her agenda.

Christopher2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

***Lee, a tech-savvy 20-something who is rarely impressed by my various electronic wonders, turned to me and said his first words since sitting down perhaps three minutes earlier, “Are you kidding me?***

I would think any tech-savvy person in their 20s would already know pretty much everything there is to know about Kinect. Either the author takes some liberties with this story or his friend isn't tech-savvy.

***while it incorporates ridiculously advanced technology***

I weep for people who honestly believe this.

I don't consider this a review, but an opinion piece to sell the console by a person who obviously knows he's sending smoke up my ass with these type of lines. C'mon, I don't write gaming pieces for a newspaper, but even I know that this technology is far from 'advanced' as people make it out to be and has been around since the early 90s.

This is the same guy who had this at the end of his Move review: "But as a reviewer, I get this stuff free. For a family that has already invested in a Wii and lots of Wii games, spending the money to replace all of that on the PS3 and Move is going to be a tough sell for now, especially with Microsoft’s Kinect around the corner."

The reviewer had pretty much already made up his mind on Move vs Kinect back then. Buying a PS3 + Move is too expensive to replace a Wii, but buying a 360 + Kinect isn't.

Sorry, just not a very good review, if you could even call this opinion piece one since he really just said what he did and not how it worked or didn't work.

Ju2635d ago

Leaves hand controls in the dust. Especially when the only aspect of Kinect in that article described covers how great the voice control scheme works - not its content, nor any game play for that matter.

I must have missed something, because obviously in that regard both Sony's Move and Nintendo's Wii suck balls since they do not have any voice recognition built into their resp. gaming operating systems...otherwise this comparison quote is just a cheap shot at the competition for no apparent reason. NYT, huh?

Scary692635d ago Show
avengers19782635d ago

Listen there will always be controllers, and for the most part GAMERS use controllers more often then they will use motion control.

+ Show (8) more repliesLast reply 2635d ago
gigaware2636d ago

Most 99% of the masses core or casual will see Kinect as this review explains. No is going to be thinking about how many core games should come in the future and what they should look be like. No one is going to thinking about how kinect should perform with nothing to compare this tech to.

T9X692636d ago

"Nothing since the Wii, certainly not Sony’s imitative Move system for the PlayStation 3, approaches the ambition and technical achievement of Kinect in potentially reshaping the mass home media experience."

Damn that's harsh.

badz1492635d ago

that's not harsh, that's the smell of the $500m pie!

puamdefoke2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

What badz149 said,.. and CVG,.. lololololo,..

Guys you are buying a 3d eye-toy type device with 30fps with a lot of room-space required,..
What sort of games and interactions do you expect to have with it? (just think about it,...)
I am cool with Kinect,.. but they are charging you 150usd,..(is game included?) For f***** sake,..?!?

Actually I am shell-shocked how good reviews are,.. even IGN's and Endgadet's,..

Well have fun with it guys,..
I would go piss on MS HQ, if I bought it for so much money,..

thebudgetgamer2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

"Kinect leaves hand controls in the dust"

thats just dumb.

T9X692635d ago

I never said I liked Kinect, or that I support it, or that I'm getting it. I just quoted the article saying what they said was harsh. There was no need to include that in the article, but they did anyway, which is why I said it was a harsh thing to say.

thebudgetgamer2635d ago

i see your point and understand.

visualb2635d ago

its an asinine statement, almost too over the top to be taken seriously.

dtrain212636d ago

Its goin crazy here at Gamestop in Phx, well as everywhere else. I'll be pickin up Dance Central, Sonic Free Riders, and Kinect Sports. Gotta get my daughter Kinectimals cuz she's been wanting it.

cooperdnizzle2635d ago

Dance central? Please say your a chick. for the life of me i can't think of any guy gamer that would want to play a game where you dance. I only want to dance if there is a hot chick that makes me dance with her. End of story. I really don't think it would be cool at all dancing in my living room! Flipping lame stuff! Like i said i hope you are a chick writing that comment!

Redempteur2635d ago

Well dances games are on the spot this year

singstar dance
just dance 2
dance central

every console has his dance dance

only that ouendan/elite beat agents was on DS before them AND IS BETTER !!

LordMarius2635d ago (Edited 2635d ago )

Dang the liberal media is at it again
Sarah Palin was right

kaveti66162635d ago

Sarah Palin is only right in terms of her political leaning. In every orher category she is both wrong and mentally retarded. When I heard she had a baby with Down Syndrome, I said, "that makes sense,"

visualb2635d ago

her grandchild with downs syndrome >>> Sarah Palin