Spartans VS Jedi: Who would win?

David Hutchison from Coregamer: So over the years there have been many discussions amongst friends about who is there favourite character, what kind character they like and ultimately arguments about who would win. So today I’ve decided to take 2 cool warriors from great sci-fi settings and put them against each other to find out who you think would win: Spartans from Halo or Jedi from Star Wars?

[RememberThe357]

Spartans are badass, but Jedi have the force.

[MGRogue2017]

.. So? Spartans have epic beards.. well most of 'em do! :D

... And big muscles. Jedis hide behind their lightsabers.. Can't fight with the fists like real men. :P

[jozzah]

But the only reason that they can fight with their fists is because their augmented and could probably kill you with one punch.

[Game-ur]

The Mandalorian Wars

nuff said

[ChozenWoan]

Ohh you mean those Spartens... nm.

[Nugundam0079]

Jedi can fight with fists

[Lightsaber]

Jedi have

Lightsabers
Lighting
Force Choke
Force Push
Jedi Mindtrick
Jedi Healing
Jedi Speed

Spartans Have

Roid Rage

[dangert12]

I've never seen a spartan be able to do anything spectacular at CC range I reckon a Jedi would win as they can swing the light saber to deflect a host of bullets back at the spartan

[Why o why]

its jedi all the way...epic beards get sizzled with light sabers heat

[Halochampian]

are we going by spartans in the game or how they are seen in the books.

Because in the books they are monstrous. Fast killing machines that made Homer's gods look like children.

Give a spartan an Energy sword that would cut through anything and the Jedi wouldnt have a chance.

[Ilikegames76]

just use the Jedi mind trick and the Spartans will be killing each other in no time.

[bobdog626]

Cortona is in Chiefs Mine and she would see through it.I think they would both kill each other because of the sticky bomb.The jedi has no Armor to Protect him against that so the fight would be a Draw

[hakis86]

Really? Jedi va Spartans?
Coem on, the Jedi could just stop every needlegun or rocket with the force... What a stupid discussion:P GEEKS! :P

[TROLL EATER]

not sure bout spartan 3's though

[Halochampian]

Tank beats everything!

[Sanzee]

WORD

[avengers1978]

Jedi, The force is strong.
Spartans, have gear, and armor, but nothing that can compare to the Force and a Lightsaber

[EvilBlackCat]

JEDI

Now this is a good one.

Superman vs Yoda or any other great Jedi Master? you know what....

Superman vs Yoda & Emperor Palpatine. How about that?

[bobdog626]

I would say Yoda FTW.Magic and the Force are really the same.Lightsaber can not cut Superman but Jedi mine trick will work wonders on Superman leaving him helpless

[avengers1978]

@bobdog superman was trained by Martian Manhunter to protect his mind, and Martain Manhunter is one of the strongest telepaths in the DCU. Superman would destroy Yoda and Vader and Luke all at the same time.

[RedPawn]

Anyone who can warp & use lightning from their hands, is an instant stay away.

[Max Power]

Isn't that a Sith and not Jedi? I'm not the most knowledgeable in Star Wars lore and if I am wrong let me know.

[ndibu]

However it would be no competition. Force beats everything.

[RedPawn]

I'd like to see a Spartan pull a (BIG ASS) spaceship to the ground, just by shear will.

No in all honestly when they do the next HALO game/s, I hope we get to see more planets w/ravenous creatures, and a darker tone.

[Game-ur]

"I'd like to see a Jedi use his lightsabre to deflect an RPG"

Lighsabers are for beams, force push is for projectiles. It's obvious

[N4GAddict]

I have to go with Jedi

[crzyjackbauer]

depends what kind of jedi
in episode III most of them got pwned by a bunch of clones
lest see noble team take on a jedi

i think the only jedi that can deflect an RPG is starkiller
starkiller would pwn vader, luke and yoda at the same time

[Valkyre]

most retarded comparison of the week?

yep... i think we have a winner here!

Lets do a similar one:

Who is faster? Usain Bolt or the Road Runner?

Please vote!

[Mooshy_Muffin]

Come on, it's a Monday! Where's your sense of fun?

[Kurt Russell]

Valkyre has hit the nail on the head ^^

[Narutone66]

to go with the Road Runner. It's going so fast that due to it's downward force it can run on the ceiling upside down.

[Baka-akaB]

wouldnt it be better as spartan vs bobba fett type of mercenaries ? Or spartan vs the Clones ?

[TronEOL]

Now if that were the case, Spartans would wipe the floor with them.
But since it's Jedi VS Spartans, the answer to that question is obvious.

[Baka-akaB]

dunno Bobba Fett is usually and easily as good and strong as Master Chief . And what we seen from some battalions of clones in the tv series , books or comics is easy as good as spartans .

[crzyjackbauer]

Bobba Fet killed a bunch of Jedis for Vader
not all jedis are as strong as Vader or luke

[ElementX]

Ha, this is what N4G has come to? Which fictional character would beat another fictional character?

[RedPawn]

It's just fun, beats over 1/2 the garbage that gets posted.

[worm2010]

some where in the world some fanboy just got an erection from the title of this article

oh wait that place is N4G

goodbye bubbles,
here come 400 disagrees

[iamnsuperman]

Jedi of course...... Spartans are cool and all but they are like the Paras (still awesome) and the Jedi are like the SAS (just better)

[lonix]

Jedi vs Kratos

Kratos wins

[Eiffel]

Kratos turns to the dark side. And we all know what happens to the dark side.

Get owned two out of three movies.

[suckerpunch]

kratos FTW

[bobdog626]

Lightning is nothing to Kratos and Kratos Blades is like a part of him so they would parry the jedi light saber .The jedi would not stand a chance

[wollie]

nothing beats a jedi except maybe a wizard.

[Bathyj]

God, are you serious?

Which is faster? The X1, or Mariokarts?

Without shields Spartans would have a very hard time.

[suckerpunch]

1st of all jedi is lame and bullshit. U think jedi and their magic or force or whatever can really exist though natural process ? bullshit

spartan is more realistic and seems more possible because they are simply biologically and physically enhance superhuman ability (normal human ability elevated but no additional magic power or other elemental bullshit).

stupid jedi, star wars = lame. act as if the jedi is a religion, bullshit like destiny, fate, prophecy, see the future, chosen one......blah blah blah bullshit.

[Nugundam0079]

men with steel reinforced bones, bulky armor fighting aliens is realistic?

A jedi wouldnt even need a saber to wipe the floor with a spartan-Spartans are just Storm troopers who happen to not work for the empire.

[ChozenWoan]

just look at mah name.

[Game-ur]

@suckerpunch

You have a lack of faith my friend, look inside yourself and you will find the answer within.

[theonlylolking]

Jedi cant block a bullet going faster than sound.

[rakunado]

Doesn't even have to let the spartan get near him... force push, force throw... nuff said... rinse and repeat, until he gets bored then mind trick said spartan off cliff.

But I do think Spartans look cooler.

[Bobbie001]

This might be the definition of Nerd talk

[Baka-akaB]

well i dont any visitor from here isnt a nerd anyway

[coolbeans]

Mind trick ='s ownage by Jedi.

[ULTIMATE_REVENGE]

Me

[Solid_Snakeps3]

the forve indeed