Gaming Nexus writes: "One of my favorite games of years past was Disciples II. It wasn't perfect, but the elegantly simple battles, dark-fantasy atmosphere, and sometimes-maddening area control elements hit the perfect chord for me. Sadly, the nostalgic feelings for that earlier title make the shortcomings of Disciples III all the more painful. Somehow, Disciples III: Renaissance manages to recreate most of the aesthetics of that venerable series while completely failing to recapture the fun." D+/A+