Play-mag says: "Hard as it may be to believe, Red Dead Redemption hasn't taken over my life as I expected it to. But why? Is there something wrong with me?"
I don't get critics and whiners. It seems greater the game, greater the dissatisfaction.
Actually, the game hasn't "grabbed" me either. Not that there's anything wrong with the game. Honestly, I just don't like games like GTA anymore. They take out detail and depth and replace it with a big world with ultimately lifeless characters roaming it.
Yeah I was disappointed at RDR as well. It's a good game, but it feels too much like previous Rockstar titles. After a while you just can't shake that "been there, done that" feeling. There's nothing wrong with the people that didn't enjoy RDR that much, even if they're a minority. People are allowed to have different preferences in movies, music, cars, even in women. Why not games?
I love RDR but it hasnt hooked me either. I played it loads and loads , maybe too much when i first got it. Then I took a break from it. . and have since not been able to go back to it. Its like its not THAT addictive , more of a spectacle than a great game. Im still glad i bought it but i really dont think it deserved scores as high when it didnt take into account the longetivity of the game.
Great game, but the open sandbox world game thing just doesn't do it for me. For me I start playing and end up doing everything except the story. Which is fun, but.... it just ends up being long tedious. I guess I'm just ol' school because I enjoy liner games.
...but you know that feeling you get when you get a new game and you HAVE to complete it so you play everyday until the game is finished? Well I have yet to get that feeling with RDR. I enjoy playing and it's engaging when I am playing but there is a lot of nothing but plenty to see if that makes any sense. Likewise I totally agree Major Jack and this statements is very well articulated... "They take out detail and depth and replace it with a big world with ultimately lifeless characters roaming it."
I agree with every reply in this thread. I don't know what I was expecting and I thought the game was awesome - for the first 3 hours. I also couldn't get over being distracted by the technical issues in the game. I stopped playing it when Peace Walker came out and instead of going back to RDR I went back to GTA:TLAD & BOGT
Me either. I played it for less than a week then gave it away.
No matter how much I tried I just could not get into the story and holding x and listenning to some crap i dnt care about got really old. Personally it is the most overrated game i have ever played.
What? Seriously? Actually when I think about it, some big-name games haven't grabbed me either such as Bioshock and Fallout 3.
...but KNOW I waited to late to play them. By the time I got around to them I enjoyed them but wasn't very impressed :(
Yeah, were kinda in the same boat. :)
I loved it at the start, then went through a long period where i thought it was a bit pedestrian, maybe its the GTA style structure, you go here something goes wrong and then you shoot aload of people but I loved the ending I thought it was so awesome
I thought the ending was stupid. The rest of the game was good but not great. Far too repetitive and too many glitches. I did get to 100% completion but only because I hate not finishing. I will definitely not be trying for the platinum, I'm done with this game, I've had enough.
Yeah, I'm very close the %100 mark and I still can't seem to pick it back up and continue. After the ending I was done.
even force myself to get 100% in the story and I platinum almost every game i get. Not my kind of game at all.
Single player was good, but multiplayer...i played for about a week, and then got bored.
is it just me or did the ending with john's son end too quick?
way to quick all you did was travel to the otherside of the map
I'll go back to playing RDR soon because it is a great game, but I got bored of it, especially the multiplayer free roam, so I'm playing Transformers WFC right now.
I played 35 hours of the single player and completed 98%, then lost the will to carry on. It may not float some peoples boat but this game was very good indeed. Not stressful, it was fun, intriguing, had a good story, some twists, graphically looked wonderful, gave you reason to keep going and altogether was worthy of the money spent. It is each to their own I mean there are a lot of people that love GTA, I didnt I got bored. A Lot love Metal Gear but that is one series that does absolutely nothing for me at all. Strange but true. Transformers at the moment though, a good game on hard.
I completed it 100% and IMO the game is overrated. There should be train heists and stuff like that. It has alot of cool ideas that have very unispired gameplay. I miss the whole GTA:SA/VC formula.
Uninspired gameplay. It's very clunky and unresponsive and at times can be just plain boring.
I actually am enjoying it more than I thought I would.Currently playing this and Borderlands (which has me sucked in)
It served it's purpose. I am done with Red Dead. Once you beat the very good campaign and play online a few weeks it becomes a repetitive mess.
from start to finish
I'm not alone!! The game really hasnt "grabbed" me either. Sometimes I've just stopped while riding to a mission or place I havent been, look around and see nothing but rocks and plants. Absolutely nothing to do between point A and B Maybe kill some wild dogs or rescue a trader. But then I'll be travelling for hours, so screw it, I got to go get these missions done I tried just like the article writer, but I just find the game boring compared to the stack of games I could play instead. So I find no reason to put RDR in rather than something else
The roaming thats almost "in real time" feeling adds to immersing me in the game. But you always have the option to setup camp and "teleport" wherever too.
I thought it was a really good game. I enjoyed it a lot more than GTA 4. I was totally impressed by the graphics. The realistic look of the landscape and natural environments just blew me away. The gameplay was really fun and enjoyable, and the storyline was solid, very good. I also really liked the wildlife aspect of the game, not too many games get it that near perfect. The fact that it's a Western game also attracted me and you dont get too many of them around. I understand the reasons why it may not be to everyone's taste but I thought Rockstar did a great job on creating a game for one of the least explored genres in gaming. I'm not really big into multi-player aspects of gaming
Totally. 100% completed now, phew .
I've completed the main storyline of the game. I'm still yet to do everything 100 per cent though. I thought the ending was brilliant, but sad at the same time. I'm still doing all the side missions and activities that I did not get around to doing during the main storyline. I don't play it as much as I do now since completing the main storyline, I only put it on when I just wanna mess around, do random missions and explore the land and wildlife. I cant see what the complaints are about personally. I think every gamer should have this in their collection, whatever flaws it may have, its a well-made, excellent game. The pros far outweigh the cons in this case.
I was completely and utterly immersed in the universe, more so than GTAIV.
I was hyped to the moon for this game, but it ultimately dropped me flat on my face with it's boring world, cattle rustling and horse breaking mini-games, repetitive missions, easy difficulty, lame ending, and of course the glitches galore that most games would get slammed for. Don't get me wrong, I still had some fun with it, but I simply feel that it is not even close to being the perfection that so many reviewers and gamers alike are making it out to be. 8.5 tops from me... and that is being generous.