IGN: Where's the PS3 Red Dead Redemption Review?

Some of you may be waiting with much anticipation for Rockstar's next game, Red Dead Redemption. It comes out this week and if you'd like an early verdict on it, make sure you read our review of the Xbox 360 version. Unfortunately. Rockstar was unable to provide us with a copy of the PS3 edition of Red Dead Redemption early and so we've had to delay that review until we get a chance to take it for a spin.

Read Full Story >>
The story is too old to be commented.
sixaxis2985d ago

wtf, "Rockstar was unable to provide us with a copy of the PS3 edition of Red Dead Redemption " thats more than strange!

LaChance2985d ago ShowReplies(9)
Biggest2985d ago

I wonder why they're making 2 different reviews for the game. Aren't they supposed to use the same review for both versions?

BRG90002985d ago

If they received both versions, and they were reasonably similar, they probably would do just one review. Since they haven't played both versions, I agree the responsible thing to do is wait. If any differences are minor, they will probably just copy and paste the Xbox review into the PS3 channel.

HolyOrangeCows2985d ago

"[Update] We have received the PS3 version. The review will be posted just as soon as we've had a chance to put it through the paces"

Watch them go and give it a .5 point reduction for insignificant differences.

Trey_4_life2985d ago

The reason there is no PS3 version is because they are still playing the extra exclusive PS3 content which seems to add a lot more game play time

hassi942984d ago

What an absolute fanboy. An extra ranch area to give like an extra 10 hours + gameplay time. What a joke.

Karlnag32984d ago

couldn't agree more... I'm a playstation fan and even I think that has to be one of the dumbest things I've read on this site.

I also own a 360.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 2984d ago
captain-obvious2985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

tomorrow im getting this game and MNR
both on PS3

since one is exclusive
and the other i've already made a posse with some of my PSN friends
and add to that that exclusive content

Hellsvacancy2985d ago

YOUR pose? your part of my pose lol

captain-obvious2985d ago

yah you know the deal

and i really dont care if its mine or yours man i just wana play

we havnt played BC2 in a while
where have you been ??

Hellsvacancy2985d ago

Busy tryin to get those damn demolish kills man i did it though and Plated it

Only jokin bout the whole "pose" thing

Ill hit PM ya 2-night man if your online 4 a game, i noticed your rankin it the top 1000 players on BC2

Kratos Spartan2985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

It goes down tomorrow. Put up or shut up. Time to get serious.

If you ain't with me, you against me. Ride or Die.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 2985d ago
Blaze9292985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

all the PS3 reviews I seen so far have been positive.

WhittO2985d ago

hmmm weird, maybe they still need to polish off the ps3 version before release and didn't want it reflected on reviews so left it out ? lol

rob60212985d ago

yea i was thinking maybe they're pushing for a release day patch to help get the PS3 version optimized..

kaveti66162985d ago

There's no way to do that now. The game went gold weeks ago. And if IGN has to wait for an update to the PS3 version to download before they play it, you can bet your ass they're going to reflect that in their review.

himdeel2985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

...with respect to this game. Mainly because I already paid off my copy and secondly I made up my mind about purchasing this game after seeing the free roam mode. That mode with 7 other pals sold me on this game and it's reason enough for me to play RDR.

The only thing left to decide upon now is if I'm going to jump right into the free roam mode right away or try the SP campaign first. Outside of those thoughts I DO HOPE to NOT feel in ANY way like I did a few days after my GTA4 purchase.

EDIT: What I really would like is another video review now that I'd read the 360 Review of the game. I don't expect any differences in those write ups.

sixaxis2985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

well, update says: "We have received the PS3 version. The review will be posted just as soon as we've had a chance to put it through the paces."

so we will see what they write about it.

Odin7772985d ago

@ Parapraxis I have to say...I have noticed that pattern recently with reviewers. Hopefully its only a coincidence.

pixelsword2984d ago

From that point on, IGN has lost all credibility for me.

hassi942984d ago (Edited 2984d ago )

Commented in wrong bit

+ Show (7) more repliesLast reply 2984d ago
divideby02985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

yea....something is wierd...and I am buying the PS3 version...I am playing BC2 on Live, so I wanted to balance the online game playing

dgroundwater2985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

So you are jsutifying your purchase on PS3 by randomly letting us know you are currently playing BC2 on Live? Am I supposed to applaud your honesty or facepalm at N4G?

Anyway I wouldn't get too worked up by the news. This doesn't necessary mean development trouble or anything.

divideby02985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

^ I dont justify what I buy to anyone especially those on the net. Its just a comment I made..dont read into it.
I thought I read the PS3 was the lead platform, but not 100% sure

MGRogue20172985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

... Is it just me or is IGN kinda agreeing that the PS3 version is the best version of the game with this article?? :D

Rowsdower2985d ago

the way the article fails to imply anything of that sort leads me to the same conclusion.


aaronisbla2984d ago

first i was thinkin WTF is rowsdower talkin about then i read the rest of ur comment, bubbles

BRG90002985d ago

It's just you. IGN is explicitly saying they haven't played the PS3 version. At least not enough to make that judgement.

rob60212985d ago

How big is the hideout?? is it like a whole other town or what..? If it's a little shack then who knows which is better.

CR-Y-SIS2985d ago

Maybe MS ninjas got to the delivery man?

dc12985d ago (Edited 2985d ago )

Funny and out of order... all at the same time! Take a +plus Bub!

bronxgee2984d ago

LOL you the man bubble up

AKS2985d ago

Of the reviews of the PS3 version I've seen, all have been positive. The secrecy about the PS3 version is quite odd. No footage, few reviews, ect.

Christopher2984d ago

There's nothing odd here. In the U.S. media, it's typically the 360 version that is completely reviewed while the PS3, if at all played, is only done a bit to determine any peculiar differences.