NowGamer: We've played both the PS3 and Xbox 360 versions of the game and we can categorically state that - other than a 600mb install on the Sony console - they're virtually identical...
Good to hear that...
There's gotta be more differences than that. When was the last multiplatform game that was 100% identical. It doesn't happen. Other than the install and the exclusive content there's gotta be more differences.
Great news. I was going to get on PS3 anyway as It's all I have. Looking forward to the UK release of Friday. (Apart from Portal on Pc :) It's free until the 24th btw on steam)
Maybe they are talking about meaningful, important differences. Meaning functionally, they look pretty much the same, which is all I really care about. I'm sure fanboys will find lots of insignificant, meaningless discrepancies with closeups of a static captures of a pixelated horse's tail or a slightly inferior rock texture or something to fuel endless internet conflicts. Don't worry, my friend, your time to shine in battle will come.
why would you want there to be more differences? If the game is the same for both then those on either side that are getting it will have the same experience. Whats so wrong with that?
Did I say I wanted differences? No. Will there be differences yes there will be because there has never been a multiplatform game this generation that was identical.
Tough luck, xbox fanboys. I know Splinter Cell, FF13, and Alan Wake left you sweating. Doesn't look like even TEH MULTIPLATS are about to help you out. Blame the site for this not being in the open zone.
Sorry, but I can't blame the site. It's on you if you can't help but acting like a child. And it's good to hear there's no real differences. Now my decision is down to exclusive content or the chance that a few friends on Xbox will get the game.
Once again DVD9 is holding back this rockstar san diego title, just wait for Agent by rockstar north (GTA series) which will utilise the blu-ray and the full power of the ps3.
so, we can finally say those neogaf posts were just stupid rumors.
Wasn't the NeoGAF business about resolution? They could differ a bit in resolution and still look pretty much the same, especially in motion. There are many factors that come into play besides the pixel count regarding how a game looks and how it performs.
How do you figure we can "finally" say anything? You believe everything you read without seeing evidence? I know some churches that would love to have your company.
No they're not. "virtually identical" is the new way of saying they're the same but leaves room for interpretation? LOL this no name site has both versions and are the only site talking about both versions. Hmmmm.
wasn't u just in another article talking about NeoGaf Being good for the sub HD info
It would be good to hear if they could have posted some evidence. Having someone say "They're the same" and give no evidence for their conclusion is hardly comforting.
"Red Dead Redemption: 360 & PS3 Identical" Why am I not surprised?
it is good to hear that hopefully those idiots who say otherwise will get it through their thick skulls
Music to my ears.. :) But.. I shall wait for Digital Foundry to get their hands on the game.
Digital Foundry is worthless for in depth non bias technical analysis he has been exposed for this time and time again. You are better off watching as much feeds of both versions or try them both out to get the truth.
Nice... but i want to see Lensoftruth analysis
I will get it for my superior PS3.
superior to my ps3?
because MY PS3 is superior to your PS3 because mine's fat and I said so... sorry, i tried this fanboy logic, it doesn't work =(
Even when the articles aren't intended to start some flame war, guys like you come in here and stink up the place. signed Omegaheat "I'm calling all fanyboys out" Look for that sentence from now on. It will be left in all of my comments, and when you see it fanboys run. No more of this crap, it's getting old.
@omegaheat come on now this is N4G, what do you expect? everyone likes to start flame war every once in a while. If you don't like here then don't come here. Oh yeah! and your not a fanboy eh!
Good news for gamers all around.
Good to hear that. Now fanboys can go back to school I guess.
Wow your acting childish with the superior ps3 version crap tired of seeing it. It is not needed be happy you got your copy and shut up. Stop saying its superior because of exclusive content if you wanna be immature and say some crap like that then say I'm gonna get the ps3 version which has more content on it. Its the same game neither is superior so shut up. Superior is based on how good the game runs on the console not based on content you get when you what preorder the game ? LMFAO give me a god damn break. Anyway I hope everyone has fun playing the game on both the ps3 and 360.
I just called out CR-Y-SIS. signed Omegaheat "I'm calling all fanboys out".
good for you! you want a cookie now.
I can see that my marketing is already working. You're following me down the page. Don't stop here. I check in everyday when I can. Thanks for being a fan. signed Omegaheat "I'm calling all fanboys out". Update: oops I think you have one more bubble left for commenting. Catch me in another forum AK46. Peace
@ omegaheat couldn't help myself, your posts were easy pickings. It's all good fun. Cheers also :)
Nicely said, however fanboys on N4G will forever be like this whether you like it or not.
Definitely agree with you. When the two versions are identical, I go for the console with exclusive content. PS3 version it is.
Exactly man I mean I'm happy the Ps3 version has the content. But the same time usually in all games when you preorder those exclusive content is usually available later on the online store. So Idk why people feel the need to brag about it. Its like they are trying to call out xbox fans to say something in response. I'm pretty sure the content will be available on the xbox if not already or they might get their on exclusive content. The more the merrier I say.
spoken like a true champion plus rep.
I never really notice things like Sub HD or whatever when I'm playing a game. I didn't even notice the screen tearing in Uncharted 1, until people told me about it. I (thankfully) can enjoy a game without thinking about that kind of stuff the whole time. But anyways, hearing this just makes me happy. Both versions the same, so both PS3 fans and 360 fans can enjoy the game just as much! Just gotta wait till friday... :(
Finally. No more fucking whining about this.
so why the 0.1 diff... since they go through the trouble of touting how they played both games, I didnt easily see what the diffs were...
^...thanx...they put up headlines to attention grab...score an incremental diff between them and dont say why...another article where headlines are looking for clicks...
...unlike some sites. Different opinions. Close call though.
has a 500 gig HD in it so id say its superior than most lol anyways im sure the game will be identical if not better on the ps3. we have exclusive content, xbox doesnt.
@divideby0 Two different reviewers apparently is why the scores are different. Doesn't matter. Who cares, enjoy the game no matter what console you are buying it on.
WHO THE F CARES.... ok thats more like 4 but you get the point.
people who were unsure about which version to get? i'd get it for ps3 cus that's where my mates are, but if 1 version was much better than the other i'd have to go for that
This is BS the RAGE engine was created on 360 and it is best on 360 This like GTA will be worse on PS3.
A lil whinny there Dellis? lol!
So you think R* didn't learn anything about working on the PS3 since then?
proof that RAGE was created on 360 now. thought so, because THERE ISN'T ANY. damn kids
please,no more of this BS!
Bad luck PS3 Haters!!! ;-D You tried to(yet again)hurt the PS3 but you Failed!!! ;)
come on, its 2010 =) even if they weren't identical, and 360 was superior, so what? people need to let go of this whole difference. if the games good, its good, some jaggies and frame rate drops won't change anything as for dual console owners, well, they are a minority anyway =P
This guy believes what "NowGamer" is saying, which isn't even concrete. Virtually identical is IMO saying almost the same.
getting this game for my ps3:-)
The guy that was spreading the sub-HD rumor for the PS3 version on Neogaf was banned there, then immediately went over to Gamefaqs to spread the same. It eventually was confirmed those off screen shots he was using came from a cell phone camera of somebody playing the PS3 version on a SDTV at 480p with component cables. What does it say about the idiot that was determining sub-HD based on those conditions or about the people that were choosing to believe the idiocy? It seems xbox fanboys are always the ones behind these kinds of efforts and are always the first to screech out the fanboy accusation at the same time. Gets really stupid after awhile.
Yea the picture was obviously a tube tv looking at the sides, then you could tell the jaggies were so bad they were worse than 640p..
Bligmerk is in the house to spread his filth and poison about the 360.
identical, then why does the 360 version get 9.4 and the PS3 9.3 from the same site ????? just wondered.
Great ot hear they are both top notch.. tnks ROCKSTAR ur awesome
If you look at both reviews you will see that they have different authors, so they will have different opinions on the game.
Glad to know Rage can Handle a game on PS3 with only a 600mb install, means Agent will definitely be able to take advantage of disk space.
I just wish those guys weren't obsessed about using 'default brightness settings' a reasonable person would adjust the lighting if they were a videofile that cared about graphics enough to care about the difference between versions.
that games can be made equal on both platforms.
i only have a 360,oh wel no exclusive content for me..
but it just concerns me about people on this site that love to instigate and brown-nose. Not only that, but I don't understand why sites have to have 2 DIFFERENT people for the same game on different versions? Wouldn't it be more worthwhile to their word if they had the same person look at both, or maybe those same 2 people look at them.