Submitted by gonzodamus 1909d ago | opinion piece

Videogames as Art: Does it Really Matter?

Dick Ward writes: "Last week the internet was abuzz yet again with the Twittering of angry gamers because Roger Ebert refused to categorize videogames as an art form. But really, why does it matter?" (Culture, Industry)

ReBurn  +   1909d ago
Whether something is art is in the eye of the beholder. I've disagreed with so many of Ebert's movie reviews. I've loved things he's hated and hated things he's loved. To me this is no different.
rockleex  +   1909d ago
It depends on what kind of games you've played...
And what kind of gamer you are.

The majority of movies aren't art. But there have been so many movies throughout history that enough of them were bound to become pieces of art, just enough so we can consider movies in general as art.

If every movie that I've seen were just mainstream cow dung, I would never consider movies as art. The thought of "art" probably has never crossed those people who love watching mindless mainstream movies anyways.

In any case, Ebert hasn't played any games at all. So how would he know whether certain games can be considered as art or not?

To me, Ico and Shadow of the Colossus were art. The Last Guardian will be next. ^_^
#1.1 (Edited 1909d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
gonzodamus  +   1909d ago
I've never bought the 'pick and choose' argument. If you're considering 'Ico' art, then I think you've got to consider 'Gears of War' art too. You can call it bad art,but if one is art, then why isn't the other?

Ico and Shadow of the Colossus are great games, but why is 'Ico' art while 'Mega Man 2' is just a game?
donator  +   1909d ago
Agreed. Art is subjective so there's never going to be a consensus on whether games is an art medium. Some people think taking a bathroom urinal and turning it on its side is art, some do not. To each their own.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

The British Racing Invasion Arrives in the Forza Motorsport 6 Garage

6m ago - A new batch of touring cars have been officially confirmed for Forza Motorsport 6. Featuring i... | Xbox One

Review: Life Is Strange Episode 4: Dark Room -- Hardcore Gamer

28m ago - Hardcore Gamer writes: "The meticulous preparation, timing and execution necessary for effectivel... | PC

VII Things That Final Fantasy VII Cannot Lose!

Now - We’re going to see a lot of changes before the upcoming FFVII - Remake sees the light of day and we should be okay with that. But here is our list... | Promoted post

Bring it Back #3: Crash Bandicoot

1h ago - Crash Bandicoot started as one of the 3D platformers on the Sony Playstation and became one of th... | Culture

Why I can't stop playing Rocket League

2h ago - Though it hasn't been out for long, it's already abundantly clear that Rocket League, the new gam... | PC

Lost Dimension Review from averagenobodys

4h ago - Does the newest Atlus title stack up? | PS3