Nidzumi writes: "Welcome to the first ever edition of Reloaded Questions, a sporadically updated column where we debate specific areas of our industry. This week Sam Morris and Daniel Lipscombe debate whether Grand Theft Auto 4 succeeded in what it attempted.
Sam Morris: I see you've taken Vice City to your deserted island. As far as GTA goes, and I don't want to get into spoiler territory for my eventual desert island article, GTA4 has to be taken. As far as a living city goes, Liberty City nailed it."