460°
Submitted by gameangel 1637d ago | screenshot

BFBC2 - Xbox 360 vs PlayStation 3 comparison

Gameswire has compared screenshots of the recently-released PS3 and Xbox 360 demos of Battlefield: Bad Company 2 to see which version has the early lead. (Battlefield: Bad Company 2, PS3, Xbox 360)

« 1 2 3 »
SL1M DADDY  +   1637d ago
This is one of those games...
Where you buy it for the console where you have your friends at. The single player will be pretty good but in the end, you buy these kinds of games for multiplayer and nothing makes multiplayer better than with friends.
BeaArthur  +   1637d ago
Couldn't have said it better myself. I always by multiplayer games based on which friends are getting it on which console. Unless of course one version is severely inferior to the other.
APOFISBORICUA  +   1637d ago
BUT DICE SAID THEY WERE GOING TO BLOW...
UNCHARTED 2 in the graphics department with their vistas. Thats NOT what I see in these vistas. The game at least looks better than Modern Warfare 2. Also the difference in ligthning is because how each console handles it. I really doubt this game really push the PS3 as hard as Uncharted tough...Anyway I have it pre ordered..

PEACE AND GAMING!!!!!
D4RkNIKON  +   1637d ago
I have said it before and I'll say it again..
It is a multiplatform game, the differences are purely graphical and they are going to be just like every other multiplat game.. It will either look identical on both systems or it will look slightly better on one console (PS3 or 360). The graphic differences in multiplatform games are so small that you HAVE to do screen shot comparisons side by side at full res to even notice a difference. That is what is so funny about this. Fanboys on both sides try to argue as if it makes a single difference. The game will play the same on both consoles and every one will enjoy it equally.
#1.3 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(12) | Disagree(7) | Report | Reply
Montrealien  +   1637d ago
Scale > Graphics imho APOFISBORICUA

ex: Mag
D4RkNIKON  +   1637d ago
@ Disagrees
Oh I am sorry, this game will be so much better on one platform than the other. What was I thinking!?!
TheDudeAbides  +   1637d ago
@1.3
exactly
superrey19  +   1637d ago
@APOFISBORICUA
They never said BFBC2 was going to look better than Uncharted 2. They simply said they wanted reach their level graphically but that ultimately, you cant really compare the two because of the huge difference in map size and destructibility.
StanLee  +   1637d ago
Is it me or is there something seriously wrong with these screens? Neither seem to represent the actual game.
IaMs12  +   1637d ago
Yes ive been playing the 360 demo lately and those screenshots seem really dark. Also DICE have stated that when it launches it will look even better then the Demo. Probably not much but hey better then nothing, either way it looks good
A Cupcake for Gabe  +   1637d ago
It looks exactly the same on both. The point of this game isn't to cause a fanboy war, it's to end that god-awful POS Modern Warfare 2.
pangitkqb  +   1637d ago
Will try all three demos (PS3, 360, and PC) myself
But these images are encouraging for sure. I'm really not concerned about which of the 360 or PS3 is visually better, simply because if graphics were my major concern I would Buy on PC (max settings on highest resolution ALWAYS looks best).

So really, where are the most friends going to be and where are the tightest controls will determine all.
DaTruth  +   1637d ago
"it is a multiplatform game, the differences are purely graphical and they are going to be just like every other multiplat game.. It will either look identical on both systems or it will look slightly better on one console (PS3 or 360)."

Yes, but you get to beat owners of the other console over the head with it! WOW FUN!!!/sarc
#1.12 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
PoSTedUP  +   1637d ago
@#$%
if these screens are true the ps3 version is a mess. am i the only one that cares? i paid $500 for my ps3 and $65 for a game, i want the best. this is the reason why people boycott s***. it is not that i am not a true gamer, i am a true consumer that pays good money for my s***. this has been going on for so long now and i may miss out on a good game because of my beliefs about being equal, i dont feel like i am being treated equal here.

that is if these screen are true... this is my way of venting ok.
D4RkNIKON  +   1637d ago
@PoSTedUP
Seriously? Those screens look better than MW2 and people bought that game like mad. They don't even look bad, I don't know what you are smoking.
MGSR THE HD VERSION  +   1637d ago
"sigh" yeah, i knew from the start the sequel was going to shine on 360. it all started from the first game with it having better textures and framerate, so you can't help to not see the concept of all that porting over in the sequel.

for ps3 gamers id stick with mw2 as ps3's version looks wayyyyy closer to 360's version than this game. :)
http://www.gameswire.net/co...
Maddens Raiders  +   1637d ago
Neither of the screens -
look right and certainly don't look like the beta I was playing on my BraviaXBR6. meh doesn't matter to me what these people say a/w

day one.
GreenRingOfLife  +   1637d ago
Darn the 360 wins, I have the PS3 demo tho but now I wish I had the 360 one
SilentNegotiator  +   1637d ago
Definitely getting it on PC
Both console versions are too jagged and have awful screen tearing issues.
jack_burt0n  +   1637d ago
a comparison uses rgb limted shots GTFO
Hanif-876  +   1636d ago
The Xbox360 has higher contrast than the PS3 version. The only thing DICE has to tweak/correct is to put the in-game contrast on the PS3 version to 8 or 75% to match the Xbox360 counterpart "please note that the game doesn't say 8/75% its just simply the contrast bar that you bump up in the options menu" :-)
PoSTedUP  +   1636d ago
@ dark
im not comparing this to MWF2 and im smokin every developer that can't make two games look the same on both consoles once i see them. >: \
Saaking  +   1636d ago
cool. I haven't decided what version I'll get yet. I'll have to wait and see.
#1.22 (Edited 1636d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
badz149  +   1636d ago
I don't really care if it look better on 360
because I only have a PS3 and this game is looking way better than the 1st based on the demo. but I might play this on my pc. I think my HD4850 still got some extra juice to push this game to 1080p. or is it?
ThanatosDMC  +   1636d ago
Maybe it's the destructible environments that is making the game act like this... there's screen tearing on the PS3 version, btw. Hope they fix it.
WildArmed  +   1636d ago
@1.3
but but if MY console version has 3 more pixels then.. then I'll have more fun and and and the gameplay will become better.. and the story will become better!
You know!?
Coz the 3 more pixels allow for extra content and special ending that the console YOU have can't do!
vhero  +   1636d ago
PS3 looks better and they look the same yet when 360 looks better you fanboys are quick to say so *tut* *tut*.
BeaArthur  +   1637d ago
Either way it's going to be a great game.
Pennywise  +   1637d ago
The PS3 version, on the other hand, benefits from more subtle lighting, enabling you to see much more detail in any given situation.
^This matters more to people playing the game rather than whose rocks look better.
hoops  +   1637d ago
Adjust the lighting and contrast and its the same
commodore64  +   1637d ago
... speaking of detail, what happened to the fence in the ps3 version?
http://www.gameswire.net/co...

Is that to do with the lighting?
Motion  +   1637d ago
@Commodore
No, it probably has to do with destructible environments. Come on now, you're smarter than that!
#3.3 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(14) | Disagree(8) | Report | Reply
Chaos Striker  +   1637d ago
nevermind, Motion beat me to the punch.
#3.4 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
thewhoopimen  +   1637d ago
@hoops
It's not a lighting contrast difference hoops. Look at this shot in broad daylight:

http://www.gameswire.net/co...

There are two stacks of pipes on the ground . The piping stack on the right shows the same detail of light between ps3 and 360 versions. 360 is only a shade darker.

On the otherhand, looking at the shadows cast by the left stack of pipes... the blacks are crushed in the 360. The difference between light and dark should be similar if they were using the same lighting model.

This suggests they are using two different types of lighting. Please do not construe this as a console endorsement. Dice might just be experimenting.
#3.5 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Pennywise  +   1637d ago
Commodore - REALLY? A fence? REALLY?
bjornbear  +   1637d ago
@hoops
been playing for 2 hours, and the fences look great ;)
commodore64  +   1636d ago
Yes, you guys are likely right.
It probably is to do with destructible environments.

I was initially thinking it might have had something to do with that myself, however, it has happened before on ps3 that textures and detail, as well as objects, have been intentionally left out of the ps3 multiplats.

This is no secret.
A precedent has been set on ps3 in this regard numerous times.

So yeah, it wouldn't have been the first time on ps3, right?
If it turns out it is in fact due to destructible environments, I ask you to please forgive my assumption that past history was indicative of future returns.
#3.8 (Edited 1636d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
hoops  +   1637d ago
Game looks the same on both with respect to different contrast.
Adjust that TV folk and it will be the exact same.
Frulond  +   1637d ago
well... if you look at the screenies in HD you'll notice the 360 version its more aliased than PS3... don't know if they where trying to make this unnoticeable by adding more contrast.
wicko  +   1637d ago
The 360 isn't more aliased, they both do not have AA enabled. Equally jagged.

But yeah, contrast/brightness differences due to OpenGL and DirectX lighting.
Solidus187-SCMilk  +   1637d ago
the main difference I see is
taht the PS3 version has more fog.
LostDjinn  +   1637d ago
You can't be serious.
Why would you compare unfinished work with unfinished work just to feed the flamewar? It's either for hits or to reinforce the view that gaming journalism is a joke.
Well let me just say...outstanding work gameswire. Maybe next you could write about how a potato makes an excellent HDD.
#5 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Pennywise  +   1637d ago
lol... I agree. A compressed BETA is not representative of the final game. It rarely is...
Alcon Caper  +   1637d ago
not the beta, it's today's demo
Solidus187-SCMilk  +   1637d ago
hhha realy?
because this is the demo, which should be representative of the final product and some people have both consoles and would like to know the difference.
Pennywise  +   1637d ago
I meant to say Demo. DEMO - Compressed. I guess the 360 version has no worries since They rock out the compressed files, but the PS3 has no reason for compressed anything with Bluray.

I just dont think 1GB of files will represent the final graphics 100%.

Hate me all you want, but do you guys think before you push disagree on me, or you just dont like me because I call you all out on everything stupid you say?
Alcon Caper  +   1637d ago
haha, pennywise is so delusional it's hilarious
LostDjinn  +   1637d ago
Hahaha.
The demo disclaimer states:

"The preview levels and online performance are taken from a product that is still in development and as such does not represent the quality and appearance of the final product."

If you actually DL the demo you can read it. Funny that. I stand by my earlier statement.
#5.6 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Socomer 1979  +   1637d ago
This is retarded.
Totaly agree with the gamerzone right now.
This matters to no one. get the game and play with your friends.
if you dont have friends get the ps3 version and save money on online fees for dlc or another game entirely.
4point7BillionLoss  +   1637d ago
Confirmed - PS3 version FAIL
Once again the 8 core beast fails to deliver what a RROD mini PC can do ...
ELite_Ghost  +   1637d ago
funny how 360 fanboys go crazy about tv settings changed...

they're comparing demos retard...
avengers1978  +   1637d ago
If you really look at the shots then up close the PS3 version looks better, the stuff in the distance looks better on the 360.
Just look at the gun, the PS3 version has loads of detail, the 360 version looks black, but if you look out into the distance then the city looks crisper on the 360, and the PS3 version looks a little foggy. So how can this be? If these shots are comparing the two demos, well the ps3 beta was out two months prior to the demo being relased on the 360, that's alot of time to improve things.
PLAYstar  +   1636d ago
IMHO The Xbox360 version is the one that fails hard. If we are to look at realistic point of view & based on first pic, how is it possible for someone to see such small particles in full building or even the clear mountains from such a far distance?! Unless your telling me his wearing a microscopic goggle lenses or something. The lighting had all gone wrong.. Xbox360 version = Unrealistic graphical fiction
#6.4 (Edited 1636d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Comet  +   1636d ago
what the...?
On the 8th screenshot with the ladder, it shows one of my buddies, dofens getting a kill! What are the chances of that...!
Dance  +   1637d ago
Wait for Lens of Truth or Digital Foundry's in depth analysis
DelbertGrady  +   1637d ago
Where is videogamezone.de's comparison? lol! I don't like the in-depth comparisons that measure framerates, v-sync etc. They always favor the 360 version.
dragonelite  +   1637d ago
Yep from what i see both are the same only ps 3 is brighter why it looses its details in textures.

Both look the same.

And at 6.1 is that the reason you don't like those in depth comparison.
Graphics isn't all about that one frame but you need to look to the complete package.
SaberEdge  +   1637d ago
Screenshot comparisons are the most superficial kinds of comparisons you can do. I too will wait for the more in depth comparisons.

I already played the 360 demo and I have been trying to download the PS3 version, but it hasn't shown up in the store yet (or at least a few hours ago when I checked). Does anybody know when it is going to show up in the playstation store? I want to do my own comparison. That is what I usually do.
ASSASSYN 36o  +   1637d ago
This has to be the worst comparision I have ever seen. None of the images are reflective. Just in the general area of it's opposite. And Dice has already said that the final product will look better than the ps3, PC beta/demo and the 360 demo. So who cares for this so called comparision.
#8 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Tito08  +   1637d ago
The way I see it
Looks like it's being made on PC or 360 in mind, n the PS3 as the port, but it's best to see how the finished product will turn out, in each demo, it looks like one has something the other is missing, and vice versa!!!!
#9 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
ClownBelt  +   1637d ago
I bet Xbots will treat this as an exclusive since they don't have one. Failbox 360. Test in.
4point7BillionLoss  +   1637d ago
ME2 > UC2
confirmed, Xbox exclusives are not only better, they tell 10 times more !!!!

So that's exclusives AND Multiplats now ...

Did you get your teeth whitened yet you stinky droids?
meatnormous  +   1637d ago
They tell 10 times more? What does that mean?
iistuii  +   1637d ago
Both the same
But more importantly, they both suffer from the lack of AA, JAGGIE. That's one thing that annoys me more than a dash of lighting effect or small texture differences. When you look at a fence or building or box it looks terribly jaggie.
#11 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Pennywise  +   1637d ago
They already said its built for each system separate... so the way you see it is WRONG.
ZeroX9876  +   1637d ago
another great work so that no fanboy can complain! :D
good job Dice for delivering the same awesome experience to both console (and pc too, but I'm still waiting for Battlefield 3 for that one)
Dave1351  +   1637d ago
wtf! why does 360 look better? I wonder if this is fake, IF THIS IS REAL SCREW YOU DICE!
ambientFLIER  +   1637d ago
Why are you so surprised? Bad Company 1 looked better on the 360. Mw2 also did. So...
talltony  +   1637d ago
You guys have selective reading or something?
They said they prefer the ps3 version for its better lighting. But whatever get it for whatever system you like more I dont care.
Major_Tom  +   1637d ago
Lol
talltony  +   1637d ago
Just downloaded off euro store! And.....
I can tell right off the bat that the ps3 version has much much better lighting. Everything else looks exactly the same but the 360 demo isjust soo much darker in some places. It hides alot of detail in the darkness. I swear the lighting differences are huge! Don't beleive me download both versions and see for yourself. I totally thought this would be the other way around this time.
sak500  +   1637d ago
bu bu but "you have teh exclusives".. 6 hour game, uncharted2 is so overhyped by droids and yet it is as linear as a track in a racing game. The painted fake scenery isn't worth $hit when u hv one narrow passage to just go through. It is like the old pc rail games
talltony  +   1637d ago
Yea sac
Everyone else is wrong about uncharted 2 but your right you know your games. Lol give me a break btw who said anything about uncharted 2 lmao!
tucky  +   1637d ago
It looks like there's a fog on PS3 snapshots ...
Otherwise, many snapshots show more details on the xbox version (more trees, a fence ...). Still a multiplatform won by the Xbox 360
Chaos Striker  +   1637d ago
I guess you are neglecting the fact that the environment is destructible? Aka, a missing tree and fence because it got blown to smithereens?

Try harder please :)
Solidus187-SCMilk  +   1637d ago
not sure about the objects but I know
taht the ps3 version has extra fog it looks like.
table  +   1637d ago
.
#14.3 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
divideby0  +   1637d ago
game (PS3 beta, Live Demo) is meh...and did you see those jaggies....I will play the PS3 demo tonight and the game will still be meh.
graphically not impressed and its the same game as last time pretty much
Skynetone  +   1637d ago
Shame the game fails
using the sniper, when you kill someone, the only way you know you've killed someone is a one second text at the bottom of the screen, which basically means zero satisfaction, and zero reason for me to buy this game

using machine guns you might hear a reaction when you kill an enemy

killing an enemy up close i put a clip into an enemy, he was standing holding his neck for like four seconds, not knowing what was going on i put another full clip into him, so my first clip put him into animation heaven and my second clip had no effect
HINDERIZATION  +   1636d ago
@3.5
if Uncharted 2 was overhyped, then how come it got GOTY?
lol
you phail
Sir_Ken_Kutaragi_  +   1637d ago
KILLZONE 2...
...LOOKS better than both Versions!!! ;-D

And 'KillZone 2' came out this time'ish last year to???!!! Hmm...

Anyway the 'BF:BC2' was Fun to play(on-line Demo on Euro-PSN today) ;)
NeutralGamer  +   1637d ago
I would say that there is an obvious difference, but not that one is superior to another...

The main difference is just the light effects and the brightness of the photos......
_vx  +   1637d ago
another FPS THIS GEN SUUUUUUUUUUCKS!!!!
^
Toman85  +   1637d ago
I remember those comparison with Modern Warfare 2, the one pic in the snow when mactavish grabbs u, nothin that grey was on my tv on the PS3 version. My tv has the same settings on 360 HDMI and PS3 HDMI with same contrast colour, brightness and so on

Im confused about this generation of consoles, so much hate for the PS3 and Sony...
My guess is all sites have on their hate PS3 glasses all the time.

Gamers game on, and game more we with all consoles, just game!!!!
bjornbear  +   1637d ago
i don't get the hate for this game here
i'm loving it =)

oh and those who complained about the snipers - you suck =P
iistuii  +   1637d ago
I Don't hate the game
Just the damn JAGGIES. They do make it look unfinished and just takes away the fine job they have done on the game itself.If you play it long enough they don't annoy you as much, but when you first put it on you can't help thinking they look terrible.
xg-ei8ht  +   1637d ago
Take a pic of the trees close up and you'll see the difference.

ROFL.
washingmachine  +   1637d ago
wotever,the ps3 version still needs AA,but i remember the first bf demo on 360 needed AA aswell. all them jaggies make the game look undone,but still,its really fun to play
Ashriel  +   1637d ago
so, wich one looks better in your opinion, guys?
X ziyad X   1637d ago | Spam
chazjamie  +   1637d ago
.....stupid, every single one of you
you idiots are blind.the ps3 doesnt even have the fence (in the pic). it certainly is the worst version. because (you stupid cretins aka ps3 fan boys) the 360 version LOOKS BETTER.

http://www.gameswire.net/co...
Voozi  +   1637d ago
@chazjamie
"you idiots are blind.the ps3 doesnt even have the fence"

And the 360 is missing trees, it's missing a tank. (I'm using the same logic as you)

Don't you just love DESTRUCTIBLE ENVIRONMENTS.
#26.1 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Chaos Striker  +   1637d ago
@chazjamie
LOL!!! Before criticizing others why don't you consider your statement.
1. this is the frostbite engine
2. this engine emphasizes destructibility.
3. a fence is missing...hmm I wonder, destructibility?

Take it from me, I threw a grenade at the fence and it was blown to smithereens. Again, destructibility? Like I said before to the other person above, try harder when you are being critical of something that you obviously have no clue about.

**darn, Voozi beat me to the point :P
#26.2 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
divideby0  +   1637d ago
psst..clearly you have NOT played the PS3 beta and just the 360 demo or you would have learnt
True_Religion  +   1637d ago
lol @ Sir Ken this retarded idiot.. he mentions in every topic this medicore shooter KZ2 which nobody play online at all.

Sir Ken likes to mention 2 games out of 600 available (KZ2, UC2), lol!

Once again 360 version wins in this comparsion. The PS3 is proud of having whased out colors.
CernaML  +   1637d ago
Actually the PS3 version looks better. You guys should... I don't know... actually PLAY both demos and stop using that magnifying glass on a couple of screenshots.
xg-ei8ht  +   1637d ago
You guys are funny.

THe PS3 VERSION IS BEST and does not have slowdown.

And the trees are not a mess like the 360 version.
iistuii  +   1637d ago
Er
forget the pictures, ive got both versions running side by side and they are almost identical, no slowdown but both very jaggie. Thats the main thing they both have in common, they both need more aa, much more. You see thats the beauty of having both consoles, you can see side by side with your own eyes and choose the best version, and my choice after this is the PC version.
#28.1 (Edited 1637d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
DaTruth  +   1637d ago
You have two televisions of identical size, make and quality sitting right next to each other?
iistuii  +   1637d ago
Yeah
We have a games room with all 3 consoles and a PC, all with Samsung 32" hdtv's and a dell 24" monitor for the PC. Look i couldn't give a toss who wins the console war etc, i just see what i see and choose the version i prefer, and they both look good but Jaggie.
themafia  +   1637d ago
ps3
looks better
themafia  +   1637d ago
READ...
You guys have selective reading or something?
They said they prefer the ps3 version for its better lighting. But whatever get it for whatever system you like more I dont care.
« 1 2 3 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
10°

Trials Fusion - Squirrel Scavengers Guide

9m ago - Jack and Geoff show you have to get the Squirrel Scavengers Achievement Guide in Trials Fusion. | PC
20°

The Letter Review | Hardcore Gamer

16m ago - The video from The Ring that killed everyone who watched it is a better movie than The Letter is... | Wii U
20°

Achievement Hunt #40

50m ago - This week's Achievement HUNT, brings you Jack vs. Gavin. | PC
20°

Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker - Hands-on Preview - GamesReviews

1h ago - From GamesReviews: "Nintendo has a new character. Well, they actually have a new variation of... | Wii U
Ad

The Walking Dead: Season Two Episode 4 – Amid the Ruins (PC) Review

Now - Drew delves into the penultimate episode of Walking Dead Season Two. | Promoted post
40°

Apex of Change- The Walking Dead Season 2: Episode 4 Review | Hey Poor Player

1h ago - This newest episode of Telltale's Walking Dead series receives a lull in momentum, but is well-cu... | PC
Related content from friends