230°
Submitted by skynidas 1739d ago | review

GameDaily: Uncharted 2: Among Thieves Review

GameDaily writes: "That said, embrace the experience developer Naughty Dog has crafted, because it is one of this generation's best. A tried-and-true system seller, Uncharted 2 is the reason we play video games". (PS3, Uncharted 2: Among Thieves) 9/10

« 1 2 »
LordMarius  +   1739d ago
No, not good enough

I understand complaining about the camera but the snow effects not being realistic, tell me another game were you seen better snow
#1 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(42) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
ToastyMcNibbles  +   1739d ago
have to agree... when you go so far as to complain about your steps not leaving footprints in snow then you know this game is perfect lol
Simon_Brezhnev  +   1739d ago
this is gamesdaily now we have to wait for edge
callahan09  +   1739d ago
GameDaily is a really low-brow, silly website that gets hits being controversial, and this review is a bit flawed, but it's not as bad as some of the others that have scored the game 9's... At least GameDaily is more consistent. They didn't give 10's to Halo 3 or Gears 2 either, which if they had you could argue they've got obvious double standards across the PS3 and 360 for this type of action game.
mxdan  +   1739d ago
Thats ridiculous. I have a hard time calling any game reviewer credible in this generation. No one reports on anything relevant to me... Would I care if the snow print doesn't leave a giant streak? NO I wouldn't. They are simply looking for something to whine about. They don't focus on the actual experience I'll have!
#1.4 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
BulletToothtony  +   1739d ago
well they gave MGS4 8/10
http://www.n4g.com/News-156...

so what can u expect..

this is what they had to say:

"People are just upset because they are fanboys and I gave MGS4 and 8/10"
#1.5 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
jammy_70  +   1739d ago
no no no
put it on 360 it wud of got a 10!
why do sites do this!? its f**king SAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!

and why is he taking a close look to put the game down???.....
#1.6 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
MeatAbstract  +   1739d ago
While 9/10 is a great score and no complaints about it, I agree with many of the posters above. Snow footprints, what the hell?

Its a shame games reviewers want to take themselves that seriously that they won't simply enjoy a game but critically analyze such minor details.

If you want to bash the realism of the game, why not just go all out say "AND HOW COME WHEN NATHAN GETS SHOT HE ISN'T WRITTHING AROUND ON THE FLOOR IN PAIN WITH A BULLET LOGDED IN HIS ARM!?"
rucky  +   1739d ago
"by GameDaily Staff"
C'mon Chris Buffa at least be a man and show your name. It's not like you haven't shown your unprofessional journalism before.
#1.8 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
BulletToothtony   1739d ago | Spam
randomwiz  +   1739d ago
in gametrailers, they said the camera programmer deserves an award, and the snow felt really real.
heroicjanitor  +   1739d ago
So let me get this straight
They started from 10 and then dug for reasons why it isn't a 10, and came up with snow prints and the camera isn't perfect? So it was impossible to get a 10. Should be an article entitled "Why Uncharted 2 isn't as perfect as everyone says it is". They didn't review the game fairly or objectively, their score was in place before they played it. Terrible site, wouldn't recommend.
#1.11 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Mr Logic  +   1739d ago
A perfect score does not mean a perfect game.

It just means a game pushes boundaries and expands on good concepts and makes new ones.
RememberThe357  +   1739d ago
Immortal Kaim
lol

I don't care what scores these guys give. They suck. PERIOD.
dreamcast  +   1739d ago
Good score, but I can't take a reviewer seriously when he brings up metacritic at the beginning of the review. They obviously aren't confident enough to review the game without referring to what real reviewers think about it.
badz149  +   1739d ago
WOW!
talking about nitpicking, here we have the saddest out of all!! if there's anything wrong with the "game" itself thus hindering the experience, yes, I'll agree deducting some marks but for this game, they chose to deduct a point on the SNOW?? teh fvcking SNOW?? how many games have these guys reviewed and they focused on footprints?! this is just too stupid, it's mind-blowing!
twoface  +   1739d ago
Is what BulletTooth dug out the entire review?
3/4 of the review is about some microscopic complaint issues and irrelevant remarks about metacritic scores. I have not been reading reviews for a long time (I usually try out demos). Can someone enlighten me if this is the sad state of reviews nowadays?
Face Palm  +   1738d ago
@ 1.10
And that's coming from GameTrailers of all sites!

GameDaily says no snow footprints? I just played the demo a little bit ago and my character made snow footprints. That was in a MULTIPLAYER DEMO and typically the mutiplayer aspect of a game has slightly worse graphics that the single player, same thing goes for a demo vs the final game.
#1.18 (Edited 1738d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
LinuxGuru  +   1739d ago
From the review:

"But as Nathan walks on the snow, shouldn't his feet make imprints into the ground? Instead, it just looks like the snow billows underfoot, disappearing in the classic video game manner all footprints usually disappear."

Oh my god would you like some cheese with your WHIIIIIIINNNNNEE
saint_john_paul_ii  +   1739d ago
yea, thats gamedaily, remember the MGS4 review? LMAO seriously, these guys just want to drop points can they have this fanboy feeling that they cannot allow a PS3 exclusive to get a perfect score.

BTW The MGS4 review, they gave it an 8. glass bottles wasnt real enough. think im lying? go to their site right now and read it.

"Uncharted 2 received so many perfect scores, is there anything it does wrong? Well, yes, there is."

Seriously, i really want to raid them so bad and spam them with poop and dead people, EA RAID STYLE!!!!!
#2.1 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(8) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
LinuxGuru  +   1739d ago
Poop and dead people? LOL
ultimolu  +   1739d ago
FailDaily strikes again!

Can't attack the gameplay so we attack the snow!

*shakes head*
popup  +   1739d ago
Is it a C.S.I review?
Morituri  +   1739d ago
Very Unprofessional Review.
So they basically scored it lower because of all the perfect scores it HAS been getting...? How about having some integrity and scoring it according to its own merits. Very amateurish to say the least.
SnuggleBandit  +   1739d ago
exactly what i got out of it...his intro basically set it up that way anyways

and with no real gripes it certainly appears to have some truth to it
#3.1 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Bodyboarder_VGamer  +   1739d ago
This is the weirdest review ever. The guy's not judging the game from his perspective but from what other reviewers failed to mention before scoring the game with a perfect 10/10. In other words, he wrote a review focusing in nitpicking...

*Leaving footprints in the snow will make this game more fun?

-No.

*Then it is not relevant, just nitpicking.

GameDaily fails miserably... Again. The score was good, but the actual review was a disgrace.
#4 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Unicron  +   1739d ago
Another poorly written review I see.

In b4 trolls saying people are "whining about UC2 not getting a perfect score."
Major_Tom  +   1739d ago
Huh? I thought this review was very fair and unbiased and the website layout is the best, the editors at GameDaily are unmatched.
YogiBear  +   1739d ago
@^^^^^
Ground Control to Major Tom, your circuit's dead, there's something wrong Can you hear me, Major Tom?
itchy18  +   1739d ago
lmao! the site is full of spam.
Nitrowolf2  +   1739d ago
"But as Nathan walks on the snow, shouldn't his feet make imprints into the ground? Instead, it just looks like the snow billows underfoot, disappearing in the classic video game manner all footprints usually disappear."
WTF?
what a lame thing to say
i think that was their only complaint, and for that they gave it a 9?
its a great score don't get me wrong, but honestly"No prints"
#7 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
randomwiz  +   1739d ago
I thought real snow was the really cool graphical feature in uncharted 2, like water was in the original uncharted
MajorJackHoff  +   1739d ago
This review is a joke.

If a site reviews this game, (I've now played the single player) and gives it anything below a 9.5, then they are a joke.
divideby0  +   1739d ago
this is nit picking to the nth degree...
this site should go back and look at the 9s it gave and I am sure there were way more issues with those games
RAM MAGNUMS  +   1739d ago
wouldnt it better to complain about drake...
using the bathroom?

Like, you play with drake 15 hours and he never takes a pi$$ or a dump in the whole time.
Even in MGS4, Akiba went.

That is really a crime in videogames.
We should all have characters who pretend to be real with real life graphics take a wiz in the corner from time to time. / sarcasm.
mirroredderorrim  +   1739d ago
He's probably emphasizing snow because Naughty Dog claimed it would be the best snow or something to that effect.

In any case, their wording does not match the actual score. It even comes off as feeling as if they are playing "mock-god" with the number, because they DO KNOW how people will respond.

I hope they all get brain cancer, for their dishonesty.
Die in a fire too - would be a bonus. But we can all dream.

*listens to come sail away by Styx*
HolaTarola  +   1739d ago
"He's probably emphasizing snow because Naughty Dog claimed it would be the best snow or something to that effect. "

Then I'm dying to see their Forza 3 review!
solidjun5  +   1739d ago
that was a um...
...weird review. Snow? Footprint? hmmm...
RAM MAGNUMS  +   1739d ago
he's upset because...
he wants to see drakes crotch get swollen when around girls.

he literally wants to ball gaze at nathan drakes privates and see some kind of shift from time to time. That way, he knows nathan drake is real.
Aquarius  +   1739d ago
I can't wait to eat this game for breakfast next friday :D

All of these 9's and 10's must be really disheartening for the bots :*(
#13 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
JonnyBigBoss  +   1739d ago
More like LameDaily.
mirroredderorrim  +   1739d ago
Their Forza review will garner a 8.5-9.3 I'm thinking. They will praise it until fat ladies in viking gear rain down on us all.
steck67  +   1739d ago
A nice score but seriously, what a lame excuse to downplay the game; snow isnt realistic? lol Werent Game Daily the same ones that gave MGS4 an 8 because the glass on the cars didnt break? They just have to find something to complain about, because the game is on well... you know.
NotoriousWarrior  +   1739d ago
Snow, i don't get why anyone would complain about the snow. No footprints, lol when the feet are so deep in the ground i don't expect to see footprints i see dragged snow cos that dragged snow hides the footprints anyone that played the Beta will know that.

A 9/10 is a great score but...u know its Uncharted 2, when i saw the link i knew they would give it a 9 cos it had the name GameDaily in the title.

"because it is one of this generation's best" saying that and giving it a 9 is not right, they gave so many games higher than a 9 yet the best doesn't deserve a higher score.
#17 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Transporter47  +   1739d ago
just wondering isn't there kind of a snow storm going on during the part of the snow
so wouldn't the footprints disappear anyways?
RAM MAGNUMS  +   1739d ago
yellow snow.
im sure drake had to pee.

why isnt that in the game???
downwardspiral  +   1739d ago
after reading about the snow complaint. I wouldn't be surprised if he complains about the pixels on drakes right ass cheek.
Hercules  +   1739d ago
footprints?
in the demo it looks real to me...
Obama  +   1739d ago
Written by the same guy who complained that you can't shoot bottles in mgs4???
BlackPrince 42  +   1739d ago
Failtacular
So they start the review by nitpicking, then move on to making criticisms not in line with any other publication, gloss over the best aspects of the game, and finish by giving the multiplayer just a few lines of analysis and completely ignoring the cinema mode.

Stay classy GameDaily.
spirited  +   1739d ago
they gave gears and gears of war 2 9 /10

same to halo 3
Rubberlegs  +   1739d ago
What a really odd review just from how it starts out. Its like he's trying to find faults that no other reviews notice. Maybe they did notice but didn't take them as faults? I don't know if thats his way of trying to defend the review just because he didn't score it a perfect.
I never had a problem with the camera view either when it came to the platforming in the first game. Other reviews have pointed this out but it was minor for them and didn't effect the score.
DigitalAnalog  +   1739d ago
"When expecting a perfect game, given the amount of tens bestowed upon Uncharted 2"
Any reviewer that believes (10/10 = "perfect game") should re-consider their career choice.
xg-ei8ht  +   1739d ago
What!

There's no bottle shooting in MGS4, Fail omg, wtf.

There's no colour in Gears, wtf. noooooooooooooooo

Dam, can't anyone just enjoy games
bjornbear  +   1739d ago
I LOVE teh score..
But I am deeply saddened by the reasons behind the score...=(
STICKzophrenic  +   1739d ago
ZomG teh 9~!1!! oH NOeS~1!!

I'm canceling my pre-order nao!!~1!
Alcohog  +   1739d ago
The complaints have nothing to do with the score you clown...read the review, the moron cites metacritic and other reviews in his own reveiw. Objective failure.
MeatAbstract  +   1739d ago
I find it so wrong to hate a 9/10 because I feel its a great score for any game to get. The fact is, they could not give good reasons why its a 9/10.

A great example of how untrustworthy gaming journalism can get were the Gears of War 2 reviews. I got Gears of War 2 when I got my 360, hearing of the amazing game it was, boasting great visuals, action and story. Ok, the last bit was a lie, but the first two still stand. I found the multiplayer unplayable, with a lot of the gameplay mechanics broken and when that wasn't annoying you, you were paralyzed by the unbearable lag.

The fact is, many reviewers overlooked this, looking more what a great game Gears 2 was under all these bugs. And while it was a great game, I gave up on the multiplayer aspect quickly because Epic never fixed the game for months on end.

So why is it game reviewers can overlook such horribly obvious bugs in a game and yet one comes out that seems to run great and smooth, they nitpick and poke at things that in any other game they wouldn't look twice at?

The fact most journalists seem to do this makes me see what gaming has become to some people.

On a final note. No, 10 does not mean 'perfect'.
#30 (Edited 1739d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
« 1 2 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Immersed Games’ New Online MMO is Going to Invade Classrooms Everywhere

10m ago - Twinfinite: Tyto Online is a new online MMO that plans to be just as educational as it is fun. Th... | PC
20°

Alien Isolation 25% Off; Sniper Elite 3 Receives 30% Discount At GMG

28m ago - One Angry Gamer "If you’re looking for some good deals to cash-in on during the torrid months of... | PC
20°

You're Blind In This Open World Stealth Adventure

30m ago - Nathaniel Liles writes: "AV is a stealth game, but it’s one in which you’re blind if you’re not m... | PC
20°

Alien: Isolation Crew Expendable and Last Survivor DLC will be released separately

56m ago - Pre-ordering can be a risky business these days but you won’t have to miss out on the The Crew Ex... | PC
Ad

Start Making Games for the PS4

Now - Want to design the next generation of video games? Start learning game design today. Click for more info on how to get started. | Promoted post
40°

Assassin's Creed Pirates Free This Week for iOS

1h ago - Hardcore Gamer: This majestic, open-world mobile game brings high seas adventures straight to the... | iPhone
Related content from friends