Another Comparison. This time is between Forza 2 and Project Gotham Racing 4 against Grand Turismo HD.
and it gives real life a run for its money http://www.gameswank.com/fo... seriously they should have shoved in the nissan GTHD pics too
i say GTHD is a little better than Forza. GTHD has more details, cleaner than forza. (PS: i dont care if GTHD will not have damage capability) GTHD is the winner. (yea i know you Forza fanboys going to start flaming wars. Just get your forza and i get my GT. both will not die anyway. it is just a game)
This Sony fanboy gives the overall win to Forza 2. I gave up on the franchise after GT2 due to no realistic damage - switched to Colin McCrae Rally & TOCA for a more real driving experience. Remember - GT is up to version 5 while Forza is only version 2. GT5 better have realistic damage or else it's going to get pawned - however good it looks.
that the playfield has been set, am curious to know what ya all think about the screenshots because only one word comes to mind :AMAZING!
grr i can't believe i approved this. It's GRAN turismo
Why did someone disagree to this? It is "GRAN" Turismo, not "Grand." Yeesh...
we all know that the xbox fanboys(well,most of them) are going to say F2 looks better..... but the truth is GTHD looks better. F2 does look fantastic,but according to this pictures, GTHD looks the best,and thats that...no need to start arguing.
Gran Turismo simply kills all competition. Gran Turismo has some PGR4 for breakfast and Forza II for lunch ;-)
The lighting doesn't really aid the comparison much. However i am always astounded how Polyphony can pull off such amazing car models on any platform. I can imagine that the pre-rendered additions (backgroounds, spectators) can relieve the system of some heavy calculations which may allow for far higher numbers of polygons to be used per car though.
gthd won easily. but i still hate the game lol
The Xbox games look better the 360 games are so advanced its hard to catch them in the right light. The two pics of the red cars on the bottom of that pic; the xbox game blows the on on the right out of the water. Anyway they're all mixed up with low and high rez Xbox pics and lots of those pics are old on the Xbox side with old gameplay pics compared to nothing but GTHD replay pics lol. (((((((Look at all you dissagreeing with me muhhahahaha Check out the 2nd pic and you'll see that GTHD looks like 5th generation ass, its not even in the same ball park sorry you made me do this but the praising of replays is getting rediculous. Like i said it's no wonder you can't find gamplay to gameplay comparisons but only GTHD replays to forza old ass pics and old ass gamplay mix comparisons ((((((((Replay hype is over rated, its no wonder you can't find much real ingame pic of GTHD and why they never mix gameplay with replays as they do with Xbox 360 games in these comparisons.))))))))))) 1st comparison: Old low rez unfinsish Xbox 360 compared to a high rez finished game. lol 2nd comparison: High rez unfinished Xbox 360 game compared to a finished high rez PS3 game. lol 3rd Comparison: Very old unfinished Xbox 360 game compared to a finished high rez PS3 game. lol 4th comparison: Unfinished old ass pic of an Xbox 360 compared to a finished PS3 game. lol 5th comparison: Unfinished old ass pic of an Xbox 360 compared to a finished PS3 game. lol 6th comparison: Unfinished old ass pic of an Xbox 360 compared to a finished PS3 game. lol 7th comparison: unfinished old build of a xbox 360 game compared to a finished PS3 game The rest old ass pics of and old build unfinished xbox 360 game compared to a finished PS3 game. I even seen they threw some old ass gameplay pics and compared then to a high rez replay of a finished PS3 game.
I failed to see the "finished PS3 game" oh wait, you are talking about GTHD, just to let you know its an unfinished demo of what GT5 will be.
I do remember you POG...the very guy POG saying...don't even talk about that "ps2ish demo". "it's just a demo...Forza2 blows it out of the water". "PS2ish"...yet now you're calling it a "high-res finished game" hmmm...contradictory much? Is picture number 2 meant to be GTHD? That isn't the concept GTHD...as the game only includes one level...the level that they released...the level of the mountain. That's the only one POG...so showing that, of course it isn't. But still is it a fair fight...a ps2ish demo...against a full fledged game?
GT will be release AFTER Forza releases. Still more works needed to be done.
You're kidding me right? They're "SO ADVANCED" that it's hard to catch them in the right light??? You have got to be the biggest loser to ever grace the internet. Seriously, what's wrong with you dude? Are you in the special class at school...be HONEST!!!
Dude you dont even compare the games in question. You just say Xbox is better than PS3. They're BOTH better than GT are they? So fanboy. Interesting side note, the other day when they had the GT vs Life shots I actually had them round the other way. I thought the GT shots were the real shots and vice versa. I'm such a dumbarse.
P.O.G... Being a 360 fan, I don't expect you to know that GTHD has something in the title after High Definition... And that's CONCEPT, as in NOT a finished game. It is just to give an idea of the 1080p 60fps goodness that Gran Turismo 5 will be. I can't wait to see what the final product will be like. The GTHD Concept is pretty damn impressive, and that came out shortly after launch. Gran Turismo 5 is still at least a good six months away, and I can't wait to see what kind of magic Polyphony Digital can come up with in that timeframe!
You could probably add Dirt and Burnout to this too. The question will be which one will be the most fun... or which will give each person the individual or online experience that they want. Some like the drifting of PGR some like the customization of Forza, some like the beauty of GTHD. Burnout will probably win in all around fun.
Apparently Burnout Paradise will be better on PS3 than Xbox 360. Burnout was born on Playstation. WTG Criterion!
They all look great, perhaps GTHD has the edge on a couple of screenshots. PGR4 will be the best _arcade_ racer though.
obviously Gran Turismo looks much better.
i'm standing by my "it looks so great because there's only 1 car on the track" until polyphony proves me wrong and GT5 looks superior to GT:HD with 7 other cars on the track... other than that.. the white Suburu shots of GT:HD look the best
I agree i was only pointing out that these are pointless comparisons Turn10's working on the visuals as we speak and PGR4 already looks better than anything shown and its months away. Most those pics of Forza are from 3-4 builds back how funny is this thread. I'v been looking at those same Forza 2 pics in that compaison piece for a year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol No JOKE!!! Why won't they do it with more than one new pic of forza. lol WoW! do you know how hard it was to find real gameplay pics of GTHD and its now wonder the game is completely hyped on replays alone. Game to game they're not even in the same ball park GTHD is too dark and lifeless for a true next gen SIM with no depth to say the least. All you can really find are replays of GTHD theres no shame in hiding. As you can see in the 2nd pic of GTHD, its not even in the same ball park as Forza visually with gameplay. The Sony hype machine has skill what they're trying to do is no different from past generations. All the hype can not and should not be about replays you're doing yourselfs dissservice doing so. lol. Cant really find GTHD gameplay and for good reason. (((((#16.2)))))) agreed! thats the impression i get also, thats my point in this over hyped crazz. I got the pics from this site. Bring a flash light its dark in there. http://www.gamespot.com/ps3... lol The GTHD gameplay looks like ass with 5th generation enviroments and effect on cars. http://www.dailytech.com/Qu...
Yeah I'm looking forward to PGR4 actually. I typically don't like racing games but it's maybe the best arcade series for racing. Looks good visually too. Still very impressed with GTHD. Forza looks good too, but the other 2 games interest me more, personally.
it's funny how you compare a ps2 with the 360 forza...
This GT-HD we keep seeing is this the free demo of the now canned ps2-tech GT-HD? If so when can I see shots of the REAL next gen racer GT5?
WOW!!!!Forza looks like plastic,GTHD looks so real
Some XB fans can argue some things but just because Forza is your ONLY decent racing game don't try to make it out to be anywhere NEAR as good as GT...
I really hope you are talking about Graphics when you say, " Forza is your ONLY decent racing game don't try to make it out to be anywhere NEAR as good as GT". You don't know anything about Forza 2 in order to know which game is better in terms of gameplay and features to make an intelligent non-fanboy judgement. The level of details and realism in terms of physics and game play being attemped with Forza 2 + all the online features are non existant when on GTHD. They are simply not there. Does GTHD looks better in terms of graphics, I'm ready to give you that... but when it comes to gameplay... you may want to hold until they are both out.
GTHD should be compared more to GPR4 since Forza 2 is a different type of game. GTHD does not even have damage, so they only had to focus on shiny graphics. Also, can someone verify that these pictures are actual gameplay, and not CGI or pre-rendered footage. We all know all consoles are capable of playing media files. I am not saying that GTHD does not look they way these pictures look, honesly I don't know.
They are of replay/photo mode for GTHD. Meaning that there is more motion blur and 4xAA added. Forza2 replay mode adds 4xaa (it's 2xaa at 720p the rest of the time)
Do you know what "CGI" or Pre-rendered" even means? The replays in GTHD ARE realtime, they are using the same graphics engine as the rest of the game. In other words, that is the games graphics