Top
170°

EDGE review scores

The latest EDGE review scores are now available (September 2009).

Read Full Story >>
nintendoeverything.com
The story is too old to be commented.
knox3037d ago

what i surprise i dont agree with most of the scores like always

ryuzu3037d ago

Edge perhaps stick to reviewing games in the context of their platform.

So Rolando 2 is a good iphone game, and gets a score which represents that. However, that score cannot be compared to a game on a different platform - for example Wii,Xbox,PS3 because they're not iphones!

Taken this way, a score of say 6 for a Wii/Xbox/PS3 game does not mean it's worse than Rolando 2, it just means that the Wii/Xbox/PS3 is capable of and should deliver more.

Ultimately that means that scores in Edge mean nothing as multi-plat scores, and should be taken as specific and non-comparable across platforms.

r.

njr3037d ago

Edge must live only to ruin metacritic scores

GWAVE3037d ago

A person who takes Edge scores seriously is not a real gamer. Period.

lordgodalming3037d ago

Brutal scores. An iPhone game gets the best score of the month? Yeesh. At least they liked the new MegaTen game.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3037d ago
jack_burt0n3037d ago

Oh its good to see that Rolando 2 is the best gaming experience this year.

*Spits on edge Magazine*

knox3037d ago

rofl that was what i was thinking but they didnt mess up the transformers review at least!

knox3037d ago

here lets which ones i dont agree with:

Wii Sports Resort <- to low
Battlefield Heroes <- to low
Rolando 2: Quest for the Golden Orchid <- to high
The Punisher: No Mercy <- to low
A Witch’s Tale <- to low
Droplitz <- to low
Tales of Monkey Island: Launch of the Screaming Narwhal <- to low

JohnR3037d ago

and you've played those games? these comment threads are only good for fanboys and people who think they know a lot about games. review scores are opinions based on the game and its surrounding infrasturcture (price, platform, full-game or dlc etc). i see nothing wrong with these scores. too many people think that it's an injustice if their fav series doesn't score at least a nine. get over yourselves. edge is one of the few publications that doesn't pander to fanboys and publishers, always wanting games to either score a 10/10 or a 1/10.

knox3037d ago

i have played most of those games (im not saying i played them all) but all it takes is judgement......your telling me rolando 2 should get a 9 over everything else reviewed?

JohnR3037d ago

i don't see why it shouldn't. is it because it's an ipohone game that it doesn't a high score? i don't even know why you're comparing those other to rolando anyway, it's notlike there scores mean anything in relation to each other; there not even on the same platform so why a problem with rolando scoring high? gaming isn't restricted to just sony, microsoft and nintendo.

PS360WII3037d ago

Geez. Well at least they were fair with Devil Summoner

Show all comments (23)
The story is too old to be commented.