Game Debate writes: "We all know that the Godfather 2 is arguably one of the greatest movie sequels ever produced and so appreciate the pressure put on EA Redwood Shores. But the sad truth is, even when you forget about all the film-to-game adaptation stuff, at the core we are looking for a good game. Fidelity to source material etc comes second. Godfather 2 still sinks into total mediocrity and becomes simply another addition to a league of truly dreadful game sequels. And for a genuine fan of the original Godfather game, this is heartbreaking."