GamesAreEvil writes: "For SVR2009 owners there's the added bonus of it being able to import your save across to access an even larger roster and your already-created characters, but that doesn't stop the game from being any more repetitive. It hasn't progressed too far from SVR2009's amateur design, either: the graphics are still terrible, the animations clumsy and the controls unresponsive. Legends of Wrestlemania attempts to be a progressive evolution of the series disguised in retro garb, but ultimately it ends up wrought with its own set of inexcusably fatal flaws".