"As Western-themed FPS titles go, the original Call of Juarez did a lot of things right. It looked good, most of the gunplay was very enjoyable and the under-used setting ensured that the action felt rather fresh. Unfortunately, the game was also somewhat let down by the fact that it forced you to spend half your time as a wimpy chap named Billy who specialised in crawling about and sneaking past people. These stealth sections were harsh and largely quite irritating. This was a cowboy game, after all - and we wanted to be shooting men in hats, not skulking about in the dark like some kind of woodlouse."