Top
800°

Gears of War 2 vs. Resistance 2: The First Two Hours

Ripten.com compares the first two hours of Gears of War 2 with Resistance 2.

The story is too old to be commented.
jkhan3567d ago

He can't be serious?
"Resistance’s gameplay may be tighter and overall more visceral, but Gears of War 2’s engrossing story, captivating characters and its ability to make you feel vital, that you can’t lose to the locusts, is what makes it’s first two hours more successful"

Why bother comparing it in the first place, just go ahead and say it, well Resistance 2 may have better gameplay but we still like Gears 2.

ultimolu3567d ago

If only the joking part was true...D:

I don't see why there's so much R2 bashing. This game kicks some serious ass.

Pebz3567d ago

You forgot the "... and gives it the win by a narrow margin." part of the quote.

The whole purpose of a review is to state WHY a certain conclusion was reached, so just saying "well Resistance 2 may have better gameplay but we still like Gears 2" would be utterly pointless.

They did not declare a definite winner, as if the other was completely rubbish or something, they merely found that certain aspects overshadowed by others, if only very slightly, were enough to tip the scale towards one side.

Or would you prefer this conclusion: "for the sake of the fanboy wars, we declare both games 100% equally enjoyable, subjective taste be damned."?

Answer this honestly if you can: would your reaction be the same if they had said the exact same thing, just in favour of R2 instead of GeoW2?

ultimolu3567d ago

BOTH GAMES ARE GREAT.

Why couldn't this writer just say that? Gears 2 is a great game for 360 owners and R2 is a great game for PS3 owners. There's no need to compare two different games. Even if R2 won, it would be unfair to Gears 2.

Pebz3567d ago

"If this was a UFC fight, Gears of War 2 would win The First Two Hour fight by split decision. They’re both wonderful games, and i think that Resistance’s gameplay may be tighter and overall more visceral, but Gears of War 2’s engrossing story, captivating characters and its ability to make you feel vital, that you can’t lose to the locusts, is what makes it’s first two hours more successful and gives it the win by a narrow margin."

Is the full quote, where they do actually say that both games are great. In an "vs." article, one side is obviously going to win.

The premise of an "vs." article in itself is discussable, but that doesn't seem to be the problem here.

Kind of sad to see having an opinion, about which game one personally finds most appealing, for whatever reasons, become "politically incorrect" for the sake of the fanboy wars, don't you think?

ultimolu3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Did you not get what I said? There should not be a comparison between both games because they're different games! One is a third person shooter and one is a first person shooter! I may not be fond of Gears of War but it would be unfair to both sides.

PoSTedUP3567d ago

i do!! its because the media is sick and tired of sony coming in first every generation and they want someone else to win for a change, thats just the way it works, look at tiger woods for example, he wins the majority of the time and that is why the media f*cking hates him now lol. so they criticize sony for every little thing and try to sh*t on them but im sure MS's money plays a part also ; ), metacritic aka MICROcritic. XD

faisdotal3567d ago

It'd be alot better if everyone posted on the site. Stop them before they think its normal.

doshey3567d ago

more like round who gives a crap just play the games and live life

LethalToxins3567d ago

I don't get people's problems with this revew. Don't take it personally, it's not like 360 fans really get bragging rights from this. BOTH games got 10s. BOTH were loved. One has a bit better gameplay, one has a bit better story. They gave it to Gears on a split decision. Meaning it was so close, it wasn't really about one game being outright better, it was just about personal preference. Solid review. Why the hate? So what if the guy preferred Gears of R2, it doesn't mean everyone will. Take it for what it's worth, but both games got TENS. Good, solid games.

Pebz3567d ago

I completely agree that the games shouldn't be compared, and that both games are probably great (I've not played either yet, so I can't really comment on that) but that is not the point.

My point was based purely on how the content of the article was treated, not the validity of the existence of such an article, which didn't seem to be the issue in the comments I responded to anyway.

The only people that should care about which is "best" is people who own both consoles and only intend to buy one of the games, or someone trying to sell either game.

NegativeCreep4273567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

They know that it doesn't matter whether they say R2 is better or Gears 2 is better, they know that lonely, unemployed fanboys will argue likes its the day of rapture between the ps3 fanboys and the 360 fanboys.

It garners almost as much attention as some priest going along and saying to the Muslim religion and saying that Buddha was nothing but a made-up cartoon character and the Muslim religion saying that Christ is nothing but a fantasy to the Christian faith. That is how passionate some fanboys are with that 7.7 pound console lying next to their television.

3567d ago
RememberThe3573567d ago

I gotta give you bubbles for you objective comments,they were refreshing. I know a lot of people don't agree with you, but I think thats obviously because they're bias. Now, theres nothing wrong with that, we're all a little bias in one way or another. I'm bias toward the PS3 but you can bet your ass I'm picking both these up.

Ju3567d ago

I can only agree to that. Well objective comment. Bubble+.

I have the feeling R2 sometimes does not get the reception we fans would like to see. But this certainly does not apply to this comparison from Ripten. I think it was very balanced.

I understand why fans might be "disappointed". PS3 fans just want to see their hype confirmed. At least once. And the media response is always a mixed bag. Somehow, it seams, this does not happen in 360 reviews. But this is just my impression.

I haven't played GeOW2. And probably never will (just my personal preference). But, I will give credits where credits are due. And I have to admit, that its what it is. A top title for the 360 and a clear challenge for PS3 titles. Even though, obviously I was hoping R2 would remove all doubt. Well, it did not. Otherwise this wouldn't even be a discussion. Two great games. Competition is pushing the limits as a result.

I personally don't care, really. For me R2 just pushes the limits again. And the more I play it, the more I am enjoying the game.

3567d ago
Liquid_Ocelot3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

"""R2's mulitplayer is a straight copy of COD4. Gears 2 on the other hand has its own identity."""

yeah why play Predator, Alien, Kill Switch, Dead Space when u can get all that on GeoW2 *cough* 1.5 *cough* yes Im a fanboy lmao xP
plus none of those games that i mentioned above have the EPIC water effects that GeoW2 has nor the AWESOME "hammer of Dawn" or whatever is called xD lolOlol so these 2 are a plus

Mr Fancy Pants3567d ago

-I'm playing R2 right now and it's epic and the graphics are really good, specially the water(it doesn't react like real water but still looks good)!!! this game is highly recommended!!!! the campaign is awesome and the co-op is insane! the competitive is even better then one from R1.

R2 is so addicted that i have been playing it since this morning. almost 12 hours straight and running. ;-)

Doppy3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Overall both games are equal because the other has what the other is missing. Gears has the very next gen look and Resistance does look good for the amount of things they stuffed on the Blu Ray disc, but Gears looks better. Gears also has a great campaign, and Resistance 2's campaign is the weakest of it's selling points (however the campaign is still very enjoyable, but I expected more). Resistance 2 has the online on lock. Probably one of the best online experiences I've had this gen. And Resistance 2 has the Gameplay revamped to near perfection (I have some very minor gripes, but nearly everything is on point). It pointless to argue which game is better, if you have both consoles get both games, and see which one you enjoy more, which is the only way to pick a winner if there has to be one

PS

Gears of War 2 story is not as good as they lead you to believe, it's passable B movie quality, but it doesn't hamper the game so I guess that's why people care.

arika3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

i admit geow 2 is good but a measly 5 to 8 hours campaign while r2 has 12 to 16 hours and online multiplayer that can't match up to resistance 2. and i'm sure that by next year geow 2 will have a pc version, and i will just wait for that one to come out.

pixelsword3567d ago

...and you smile the second time around. Since I wanted to get Dead Space first but got this because of the collector's edition, I wanted to quickly finish R2 so I can get the story over with and go to the store, but DANG, if the whole thing isn't slick. Anyone going into the towers, Chicago, and a few other areas know that those graphics may have been some of the best in a console shooter EVER.

I mean, CHEEZ!

ThanatosDMC3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Remember on Resistance 2 when you crashland and have to see the sight of those many cocoons before they hatched???? Yeah, that screwed with my nerves, probably yours too... especially when Grims started popping out of the cocoons you destroyed the second time back... THEN BAM!!! Grims flood the screen and you run out of ammo... then all you see are claws coming at your face!!!

They really kicked up Resistance 2... i mean, the lighting on the guns and all the levels and your flashlight really makes shadows. Funny how they nitpicked the first part of the game and makes you wonder if they ever finished it. Kraken fight was awesome!

The furies in the game pissed me off everytime those things killed me. Chameleons really mess you up especially when you're sniping and one suddenly pops up inches infront of you only to rend your body a new one.

Dont even get me started with the multiplayer's co-op and competitive modes!

deeznuts3567d ago

I wouldn't worry about it jkhan.

did the writer mention the one negative about the first two hours of gears2? After you're done with the first two hours, you're halfway finished with the game.

I keed I keed. Just started R2 today. Gears 2 should be here monday.

theKiller3567d ago

and the other is 20 hours long, so of course gears of war 2 will have more deeper story in the first 2 hours because the game is short and they need to put everything in these 10 hours, while resistance take it more slowly since blue ray can handle 20+hours easily

Sarcasm3567d ago

I don't really see a problem with this. It seems like whoever did this comparison actually liked both. But only one has to be declared a "winner" and it's just their opinion.

Personally, the winner for me ends up being Resistance 2 over Gears 2. The co-op in R2 is ridiculously addicting for some reason.

Must... kill... more... chimera... collect... more... XP...

Jake11113567d ago

I have both GOW2 and R2.

Finished both.

I will keep this short. R2 blows it away. GOW2 is more of the same as GOW1. I only counted 5 bad guys at once during any real fighting. I also noted a huge amount of framerate drops during some scripted battles with only a few guys fighting against me.

R2 was Epic and amazing from beginning to end. This is not Fanboyism. I have both systems and only want the best games.

This is my honest opinion.

My Review GOW2 8

R2 9.5

BenzMoney3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

"There should not be a comparison between both games because they're different games!"

Hahaha! This has got to be one of the dumbest things I've ever read. "You shouldn't compare two things that are different, because they're not exactly the same! You can only compare two things that are the same!"

Seriously? Because I thought the whole point of a "comparison" is to look at two or more different things and contrast them against one another?

Give me a break.

In fact, why don't we look at the actual definition of "compare", shall we?

"1. to examine (two or more objects, ideas, people, etc.) in order to note similarities and differences"

And this, people, is the kind of asshattery that you can find only on N4G. In the name of defending one's console. Pathetic.

Ju3567d ago

@Jake1111, I actually read your post before it got deleted, and was "WTF, do we have censorship here now on N4G?" when it was gone all of a sudden. I haven't seen any insult in your post, maybe a bit, well, hm, emotional. But then, if these standards would apply to all posts, this thread should be half empty...so, I think this was a weird decision to delete your post, IMO. Just an observation (OT, of course).

+ Show (25) more repliesLast reply 3567d ago
Firstkn1ghT3567d ago

HAHA, why compare the first 2 hours? Anyway the comparisons have already gone through the meat grinder and Gears 2 easily sits at the top. Gears 2 is being called one of the best shooters ever while Resistance is getting mixed reviews but most are great so just leave it at that. I will play Resistance 2 when I have the chance cuz I love me huge bosses but Gears 2 is at a higher level than R2.

ultimolu3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Gears easily sits on top?

Tell me Knight, what has Epic done to revolutionize the game as a whole? How about saying both games are good and therefore both sides should enjoy them?

This is what I mean by 360 fans and the damn superiority complex. I cannot stand when people get on as if they're better than everyone else. It's very annoying.

And don't you EVEN dare use that logic with me concerning the PS3 because even *I* know the PS3 has a few flaws as well.

Grimlock: Is that so? Then let me see your PSN username? In others words, you didn't play it.

baum3567d ago

As usual, taking the reviews as gospel, eh Firstknight? I love your comments, you only embarrass yourself and your kind. Keep up the good work, fanboy.

"Reviewers said this, so it MUST be true!" Classic.

3567d ago
PoSTedUP3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

lol grimlock. getting a little offended? no? XD

yea i see the sarcasm too..

ZombieNinjaPanda3567d ago

I love the use of sarcasm ;)

Anyway, if you have truely played it, you wouldn't be saying any of that, because anyone that sees gaming as just as entertainment, and not as godly matter, would see that both games are amazing.

So please shove it. :)

Firstkn1ghT3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Oh brother, another weak attempt on verbally attacking me Baum? Your getting to predictable. Tell me if you don't like to read other reviews or other opinions than why are you even on this site? This site is nothing but opinions. If you stand firm on your statement than you shouldn't even be on the internet. You should know that opinions and reviews especially on this site brings interest especially when the *MAJORITY* of reviews/opinions are positive. And you should know that the majority always rules. In this case, the majority of reviews all praise that Gears 2 is one of the best shooters ever created and R2 is one of the best shooters on the ps3. BAUM you are now my pwnage # 1001.

"Tell me Knight, what has Epic done to revolutionize the game as a whole?"

Well for one Gears brings gameplay that isn't very common in todays games. It might not of created something new but I can't think of many games that have similar gameplay to Gears. On the other hand, I can think about a hundred games that play like R2. R2's mulitplayer is a straight copy of COD4. Gears 2 on the other hand has its own identity.

Just face it, more people are excited about Gears 2 than R2. Both are great games but the majority of people agree that Gears 2 is just the better game.

*EDIT BELOW...*

"You really can't say both games are great, can you? You're extremely biased Knight. That's really, really sad."

Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuum, Did you not read my last sentence?

ultimolu3567d ago

"Well for one Gears brings gameplay that isn't very common in todays games."

Like what" Explain yourself please. I want to know more.

"It might not of created something new but I can't think of many games that have similar gameplay to Gears."

What makes Gear's gameplay unique? Tell me.

"On the other hand, I can think about a hundred games that play like R2. R2's mulitplayer is a straight copy of COD4. Gears 2 on the other hand has its own identity."

You have some nerve to make a comparison between R2 and COD4. That's all I'm going to say.

You really can't say both games are great, can you? You're extremely biased Knight. That's really, really sad.

baum3567d ago

So now you can't insult fanboys and trolls, they are the ones that should be banned.

3567d ago
RememberThe3573567d ago

I personally don't have any problems with your opinions, it that way you state them. You do come off as have a superiority complex, and thats a bit annoying. We're all people behind these words, it's not asking too much for you to show at least a like respect for you fellow gamers.

Cheeseknight283567d ago

You can seriously call him biased just because he happens to like one game over another? Are you that blind? He even said both were great games!

Just look under your post for "extreme bias." 'Tears of Bore'? Seriously? I acknowledge that they are both great games, even if I haven't had the chance to play Resistance 2 yet. I'm not gonna make up biased BS just to further the childish war on this site.

Firstkn1ghT3567d ago

Okay one more time for the slow.....Maaaajooooorityyyyyyy yy ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuules!

Everybody has their own opinion but the majority agrees that Gears 2 is the better game. End of discussion. I win.

Ju3567d ago

Quality != Quantity. Never was, never will be.

XxZxX3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

HAHAHAHA First Knight, Seem like you wanna talk about Majority, Seem like the majority shift from XBOX 360 to PS3 and Wii. What you gonna say about that? Majority finally agree XBOX 360 is sh*tty now?? What about Majority of publishers say PS3 software now sold better... so YOUR "MAJORITY" gonna say about that huh. Funny you call other weak attempt. Yours is fragile as well.

plain rice3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Majority rules? lolol

ultimolu3567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

Majority of who exactly? You're not explaining yourself properly.

I could also say that the majooooooority of people also thinks R2 kicks ass and Gears 2 is also great but not their preference.

Your biased opinions shows even more. :/

RememberThe357: Knight is an example of a 360 fan with a superiority complex. That's what I was talking about.

+ Show (13) more repliesLast reply 3567d ago
Zerodin3567d ago

Gamers prefer Gears 2 over Flopsistance 2.

ultimolu3567d ago

Gamers get both games and shut the hell up.
You dumb retard.

ZombieNinjaPanda3567d ago

There is a difference between gamers and fanboys.

I'm sure you are confusing the two. :)

Montrealien3567d ago

I bought and am enjoying Gears 2.

I bought and am enjoying Resistance 2.

I win.

ultimolu3567d ago

Damn straight you win. You're a true gamer.

Needs moar FLOP3567d ago

Resistance is just another FLOP for the FLOPstation!!!

cLiCK_sLiCK93567d ago (Edited 3567d ago )

"Gears of War 2 vs. Resistance 2: The First Two Hours"

With those first two hours i'm done with Gears2.
And I loved the ending. It reminded me of the Pokemons endings.
=p endsarcasm/

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 3567d ago
ZombieNinjaPanda3567d ago

Both games are great. Right now I have fully enjoyed R2.

Now it's time for me to enjoy gears 2.

With cooperative :)

Panthers3567d ago

Do they really think that the GOW story is better than the R2? I love R2s story.

I just started but they better start explaining how the Chimera got all this technology. I mean they havent even said if they are aliens or not.

elorm93567d ago

They are both good games and they take different approaches to the shooter genre. Nuff said.