Stephen Totilo from MTV Multiplayer writes:
"One thing I know that "Gears of War 2" lead creator, Cliff Bleszinski, and I have in common is that we both grew up playing Nintendo games.
He's got the famously documented "Super Mario Bros." high score printed in the first issue of Nintendo Power.
I've got an NES in the closet of my childhood bedroom with some SNES instruction manuals I saved for some reason.
And so I think Bleszinski and I are both attuned to what Nintendo's lead designer, Shigeru Miyamoto, and the many creators who worked under him, put into the company's best games. There's a certain style of gameplay, a certain feel. It has nothing to do with colorful graphics our springy sound effects. There's a certain way a Miyamoto game progresses. Not many other games have it. But some do, like "Portal," for example.
Of all the non-Nintendo games I've played this year so far, the only one that has that feel is "Gears of War 2." Bloody chainsaw battles aside, this game feels like something Miyamoto touched."
The Gears of War series has been a consistent deliverer of quality for Xbox, but which games are the best?
Gears of War is my favorite video game franchise, and the Locust is my all-time favorite faction.
My rank list:
1. Gears of War 2
2. Gears of War 3
3. Gears of War 1
4. Gears of War 4
5. Gears of War 5
6. Gears of War Judgment (No Locust in multiplayer was a disgrace)
2 is still my favorite but 5 is also up there (for me). Then I'd say 1, 3, 4 and Judgement. Tactics isnt the same type of game, so it seems odd to rank it among TPS when its a strategy game. So I make that one all its own. Pretty fun game too.
The first is and has always been the best one imo - the story, the levels, the set pieces, the soundtrack - as close to perfect as a campaign can get.
I’d say the series had been on a continual downhill slide until 5.
3
5
2
1
4
Judgement
I love the series as a whole, but 4 was pretty by the numbers, and Judgement was just ok.
I played them all since picking up a Series X about 7 months ago. Personally, I don't think time has been kind to the earlier games and they feel very slow and repetitive to play. Whilst the newer games may be prettier, they stick with the original gameplay mechanics too much in my view so as a whole series of titles, I think they are pretty average games.
Not to say they weren't fun and I have a lot of nostalgia for 1 and 2, I just think there are far better action games out there.
What's the best Gears of War game for players? Where to start? This guide should easily lend a hand.
Gears 1 and 2 will always be my favorite Gears titles. The scene where Dom find his wife and then has to shoot her was an epic scene.
My favorite Gears game list
1. Gears 2
2. Gears 3
3. Gears 1
4. Gears 4
5. Gears 5
6. Gears Judgement
Gears Of War is my favorite video game franchise. I can’t imagine how Gears 6 will look in UE5 after watching Hellblade 2 gameplay trailer
One of the reasons why i got the series x. Been fan since the first game.
Played them all recently on gamepass. Great games. But my favorites gotta be gears tactics. Don’t know why. I just had a blast with it lol
The Gears of War franchise's influence has remained to this day with cover systems becoming as ubiquitous as regenerating health. With a new console generation upon us, it's time to list the series from worst to best.
My ranking list
1 .Gears 2
2. Gears 3
3. Gears 1
4. Gears Judgement
5. Gears 4
6. Gears 5
1. Gears 2
2. Gears 3
3. Gears 5
4. Gears 1/UE
5. Gears 4
6. Gears Judgement
Close to my rankings but some differences. My rankings:
1. Gears 3
2. Gears 5
3. Gears 4
4. Judgement
5. Gears 2
6. Gears 1
People will hate on me putting Gears 2 so low but I always felt the graphics were too busy to the point of confusion and the combat/movement hadn't really improved over 1. Lot of cool ideas but execution wasn't the best as far as I'm concerned.
BS.
I've been playing Gears of War 2, going through co-op with my brother and I have to say I've been loving it. It's even more enjoyable than I was expecting. Perhaps I had just forgotten how fun the first one was.
That being said... I don't have a clue what this writer is trying to say. It's a quality title in my opinion, and that's all any game needs to be. I don't really see any Miyamoto-like touches in there... and that's not to say it's better or worse than the games he makes. I just think it's an absurd comparison. Much of what he mentions is done in a ton of other video games. In how they're structured I mean.
So yeah, don't get it at all... but I'm really enjoying Gears of War 2 and I haven't even gotten to try out the multiplayer (aside from doing the tutorials) or Horde mode! Can't wait to sample the rest of this game. Man, I just have too many games to play right now though. It's hard dividing time up among them all.