120°

In Defence of 'The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild'

Screen Critics Shaun explores the backlash to Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - exploring the aspects of the game that made his adventure memorable.

Read Full Story >>
screencritics.net
kevnb2425d ago ShowReplies(3)
goken2425d ago

huh? BOTW is an excellent game. i've not played it personally, watched quite a bit though (don't have a switch). i could tell that it's a crazy awesome game. basically feels so much like the original zelda... i couldn't believe it was possible

link2Dpast2425d ago

It was incredible but i wouldn't claim it as the best one like many people have. In my opinion it's a game of preference. For me personally the exploring at times felt a little to much and with so much empty open space felt kind of useless. In that exploring there were rewards but you soon realized the rewards weren't worth all the time you put in. I always felt a trophy system would of helped me push for more and I'm Not a trophy guy but man this game was absolutely perfect for Ninty to Introduce a trophy system. Like I said it's all preference, the leap from the original story driven linear format took a huge back seat and was a completely different game which at first I was hooked but started to eventually miss the old way. I still believe WindWaker is still top because of the mix of exploration and story driven aspect they made blend so well still holds up today.

Sono4212425d ago

Exploring absolutely never paid off. The best thing you could stumble on was some nice new armour. Stumbling onto a shrine was very uninteresting because that's all there ever was to find, that and korok seeds (The little guys hiding behind the same 3 puzzles/challenges spread throughout the world) Never once did you stumble onto something that felt unique, everywhere was just more of the same, and even when you think you finally found something truly unique.. ooh, just another shrine, whereyou just get another spirit orb, to increase your hearts/stamina. Not to mention fighting the groups of enemies for the chest behind them absolutely never paid off. Fight 6 enemies to get 5 arrows or Opal? No thanks i'll pass, its not worth wasting the weapons/potential hearts or food, ever. Even the Divine beasts don't give you anything worth wild.. just handicaps to make the game even easier. One of the best things about Zelda was always wondering what new item or ability you were going to get, and what new areas it would help you access. There is absolutely none of that in this game. You have everything from the get go, only difference between you at the begining of the game and the end, is more hearts and inventory space. Well obviously armour and weapons too, but weapons break so quick and most armors barely help with anything. There is absolutely no payyoff. The best and probably only payoff is the Master Sword, just because the thing never breaks permanently. Not to mention every Shrine and Divine beast is very easy.. even though some of the divine beasts had very cool layouts, still very easy. I truly believe it is the worst console Zelda to date, Skyward Sword was even better.

link2Dpast2424d ago

I agree with everything you said!!. I remember at one point getting into a side quest of the past hero leaving you a special item to help on the journey, boy was I hyped, took me forever and when I finally found the chest it was 100rupee🙄 😅. Another moment that stuck out to me was a big part of the map on the right side I had never actually gone to since the story never got me there and kind of sucked because it was beautiful.

Sono4212424d ago

That's just it, never any pay off, but I would like to add one more pay off, getting your house, very cool. I wish we could do a little bit more with it, like have it be a waypoint on your map or anything.. but still cool, also I thought the Tarrey town was really cool too, but with that once again.. no pay off, I mean you completely put together this town from nothing and get almost nothing for doing so.. I mean the cutscene of the wedding was a nice special moment.. but still.. have this town sell everything to you for less or something! It wasn't exactly an easy thing to do..

zwicks2425d ago

Just finished the game today. What a great adventure. I know I didn't see everything. But I really like that the game let me take on Ganon when I felt ready - not when the game decided it was time. Some of the best 90 hours I've ever had in gaming. And my favorite zelda. Happy gaming out there!

SoulMikeY2425d ago

Nobody needs to defend this game. My personal favorite game of all time, and inarguably in the top 10 for any gamer. Provided you weren't on your HZD vs BotW bs....

deafdani2425d ago

Inarguably? Nah, it's very arguable. Lol. Just like with any other game out there.

I loved the crap out of BOTW, but I'm not sure if I'd include it on my personal top 10 of best games ever.

Show all comments (20)
90°

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is the anti-Breath of the Wild

Polygon: "To get back to the way Ocarina made us feel, it was necessary to reject almost everything about it."

LG_Fox_Brazil118d ago

Ocarina of Time changed my life forever, such a masterpiece

Zeldafan64118d ago

Hard to believe it's 25 years old already.

Cacabunga118d ago

The feeling this game gave me the first time i had my hands on it is indescribable.. i still get the chill from that day..
botw is like a spin off of the series.. it’s fun but with many flaws and the most important which is Zelda formula isn’t there..

FinalFantasyFanatic117d ago

I can't even remember how many times I played through OoT, I finished that game, and collected everything so many times.

Vits118d ago

I generally agree with the author here. However, if I had to point out a single game as the 'anti-Breath of the Wild,' that would be Majora's Mask. Pretty much everything in that game is interconnected, relies on something that the player must have done previously, is timed, and can be considered a puzzle in itself.

gold_drake117d ago

but still considered the best of the seties.

i would have liked botw to be more like ocarina.

franwex117d ago (Edited 117d ago )

25 years from today whatever Zelda is out people would too be looking fondly at Breath of the Wild.

Ah the more simple times of the 2020s.

babadivad117d ago (Edited 117d ago )

It isn't...

20°

Zelda Tears of the Kingdom Black Friday deals 2023 - save 15% on Link's latest adventure

The best prices we've found this Black Friday for Zelda Tears of the Kingdom as well as the previous game, Breath of the Wild.

Read Full Story >>
videogamer.com
170°

Nintendo not thinking about older Zelda games, "difficult to say" if classic style will return

The Legend of Zelda series producer Eiji Aonuma has again commented on the possibility of revisiting the style of past entries in the series – but there are no plans as of now. Speaking with RTL Nieuws, Aonuma said that games like Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom were possible because of what came before them.

Read Full Story >>
nintendoeverything.com
GoodGuy09292d ago

Which is very sad. I still wish we could get a zelda like twilight princess, the dark tone and theme in the traditional style. But times have changed and the masses prefer open world sandbox. Smh. Perhaps we can get a proper hd remake of ocarina of time some day.

CDbiggen257d ago

I played 100 hours of Tears of the Kingdom, enjoyed it, but ready for a game like that next.

kythlyn291d ago

If they can bounce between 2D and 3D Mario games, they can bounce between classic and modern Zelda games too. I thought this was a given when the Switch combined a handheld with a primary console.

Inverno291d ago

Then this is where I part ways. I won't disagree with anyone who says that the old formula was getting stale. And I do think BoTW in a few ways was a step in the right direction, but there's way too much good that was left with the old formula in the transition.

CrimsonWing69291d ago

I want it to. I’m sorry, but these new Zelda games I just can’t get into.

Duke19291d ago

Well that sucks. I still love the classic formula WAY more than the Hyrule Engineering Simulator

Show all comments (26)