Tiger Woods PGA Tour 09 All-Play is a very good game. The Wii-remote control scheme works well, but still has enough problems that make the traditional analogue controls a far better option. The presentation is overly complicated and creates a barrier to anyone not familiar with the series and the graphics and sound leave a lot to be desired.
Online play is fantastic and there is so much to do that most players will never complete everything. The addition of Wii Motion Plus controls and Wii Speak functionality will certainly add immensely to the 2010 version, but that is no reason not to pick up the 09 version.