GameZone writes: "Sometimes you need to keep your expectations at a certain level when it comes to playing and reviewing games. Certain games are released that everyone jumps on the bandwagon to offer unlimited praise regardless of their imperfections or striking similarities to other games. Then other games are released that still offer a fun gaming experience yet reviewers and hardcore gamers still pan them. It seems we're at this point with many Wii games coming out since they don't have the hardcore appeal that many reviewers and gamers want nowadays. Mario Super Sluggers is going to be one of those games that won't have the hardcore buzz to make it a sure fire must have game. However the game is still a fun experience that should keep families and friends playing for hours."