GameSpy writes: " Madden NFL 09 All-Play is part of EA's efforts to create new branding targeted directly at the expanded audience created by Nintendo and the Nintendo Wii. The All-Play branding couldn't be closer to the truth. This is a stark contrast from your hardcore Madden: Madden NFL 09 All-Play is a football game that anyone can enjoy, from kids to adults, hardcore football fans and gridiron neophytes alike. EA's efforts in bringing Madden over to the Wii have all been admirable, but this year it has refined the gameplay, added full-featured online play support, and generally taken the game to the next level. While the graphics aren't impressive, Madden NFL 09 All-Play's gameplay can more than hold its own against its PS3 and Xbox 360 counterparts."
+Wii controls work very well
+Online play is fast and fun
+Wide array of gameplay modes
-NFL Superstar and Franchise modes feel stale
-No bullet passes online