Over the last few years, Reddit has become a popular destination for mmo gamers. The site boasted an almost Wild West feel as gamers were free to express their opinions on the online games they love (or hate). Developers used the platform to interact with their player base, especially through the AMA (ask me anything) threads that are used to ratchet up the hype as well as fostering communication. However, recent events in some mmo subreddits of debate being stifled and certain topics being banned are running contrary to the wild and open atmosphere that had led to Reddit's success. What does this mean for gamers, and how open should mmo subreddits be?