Are The Witcher 3's Perfect Scores the Result of Hype?

It’s a given that The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a fantastic title. But is any game capable of pulling down perfect scores without pre-launch hype?

The story is too old to be commented.
jackanderson19851287d ago

If the games good the hype shouldn't affect it.

Also since one of the staff of vgrhq basically admitted downgrading because of hype it puts into question any scores handed by this site

RocketScienceLvlStuf1287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

I've never seen a games review scores affected by hype. Watchdogs and Destiny are perfect examples

1287d ago
admiralvic1287d ago

"I've never seen a games review scores affected by hype. Watchdogs and Destiny are perfect examples"

Like I mentioned in my other post, I would say hype negatively impacted both. A lot of people were expecting much better games than we got, which in turn probably lead to a harsher review/score than another title that wasn't as hype would have got. Though mind you, this is all fairly theoretical.

The point being, hype is neutral and CAN have a negative or positive affect on the score.

Erik73571287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

Ughh last time I checked Watchdogs was a generic Ubisoft downgraded game and it got 8.5's from a lot of "professional" review sites. Tons of hype fake bullshit scores for that unfinished rushed down graded game.

Seriously, that game sets a record for the most downgraded and consumer manipulated game.

dantesparda1287d ago

"Are The Witcher 3's Perfect Scores the Result of Hype?"

Of course it is.

rivencleft1287d ago

I was about to say the same thing, Watchdogs is the perfect example. I believe that hype hurts game reviews, getting excited about what's supposed to be an awesome game only to be let down in the end, which is definitely what Watchdogs was for me. I'm super hyped and excited for Witcher 3 and am quite glad the reviews are so high for it, makes me even more excited to play it.

SilentNegotiator1287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

Hype can only hurt - not help - reviews, by setting expectations too high.

nix1287d ago

Don't forget GTAIV, guys.

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 1287d ago
admiralvic1287d ago

"If the games good the hype shouldn't affect it. "

It doesn't work that way I'm afraid. Hype ultimately affects your expectations, which affects how good or bad a game is perceived. You can see a bit of this with Destiny and a lot of other games that had a lot of praise/hype, then were widely panned/disliked.

"Also since one of the staff of vgrhq basically admitted downgrading because of hype it puts into question any scores handed by this site"

Not that I want to get into it, but VGRHQ loves sensationalism. I remember a while back they had an article called something like "I hold Nintendo to a lower standard," which was an article basically explaining that they hold Nintendo to a different standard (you should never have 1 universal standard, so it was expected). Also, since VGRHQ doesn't specifically name anyone, there is no proof any of the things actually exist.

Not like it takes much to go "When talking to a fellow journalist he admitted to scoring The Witcher 3 lower because it didn't have enough sex scenes" and then write an article around the supposed quote.

kingeliran1287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

The game is already played by alot of PS4 gamers, they gave the game 10/10 saying its best RPG they ever played. and those are people that actually playing not reviewers.

starchild1287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

Did they really imply that? I'm not going to give such an article a click, but if they really basically admitted to lowering their score to go against the hype then I will never visit this site or give them a single click. That is horribly irrational and unfair.

The Witcher 3 has had a decent amount of hype, but definitely not outlandish hype. If anything, hype tends to cause unrealistic expectations and people being let down, thus resulting in lowered scores. Either way, hype should not affect your scores. If you aren't able to avoid letting hype affect you, either negatively or positively, you shouldn't be reviewing games, period.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 1287d ago
uth111287d ago

probably. I get a sense that too many reviewers are afraid to go against the grain and give out scores based more on how they think other reviewers will score it rather than what the game deserves.

I'm talking in general, not Witch specifically

Allsystemgamer1287d ago

I'm playing it right now. It's a 10/10 for me.

Great strategic combat, better conversations and more consequence than mass effect and dragon age, beautifully crafted world, all characters have their own personality; even the minor peasants. It's just a very very good game.

Stapleface1287d ago

If sites give low scores people claim they are going for hits, etc. If they give high scores they are due to some reason be it hype, exclusivity.. Im sure some don't want to go against the grain as well. Either way reviewers just need to review and not think of anyone else's opinion. They are screwed either way they score it.

darksky1287d ago

The Witcher series has always had great lore and gameplay. Making it open world just makes it even better. I thought the older games were around 8/10 worth so this is bound to score higher.

OB1Biker1287d ago (Edited 1287d ago )

Totally agree. I got to that idea long ago a lot of reviewers rate a game on what they think most people will rate it and actually making reviews somehow irrelevant to me. Except of course the few lower or higher rated than expected to get clicks.
I'm sure this game deserves great reviews though.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1287d ago
NoctisPendragon1287d ago

10/10 is a lil too much , i don't see how the gameplay gets away with a 10/10 unless an other freature has somehting like 12/10 or whatever .

Thunder_G0d_Bane1287d ago

Ahh here we go with the nonsense articles.

The Order had huge hype the reviews still didn't go well so your point is invalid.

Erik73571287d ago

Watch dog and Call of duty come to my mind with over hyped bull shit scores.

Genova841287d ago

Agree. Are Bloodborne's scores due to hype? No, the game owns! Same thing here. GOTY showdown!

Septic1287d ago

The WItcher didn't have masses of hype though. Good hype but not stratospheric like Titanfall and others. It depends on each person's experience.

Hoffmann1287d ago

No other games in 2014 reached the hype for Destiny and Titanfall by far. Those games got multiple hundred articles on all the big sites. They were overhyped.

gangsta_red1287d ago

I would throw in The Order also, there were a few points even on N4G where we were flooded by The Order articles.

SourtreeDing1287d ago

i would throw in Watchdogs for sure.. what a let down... my only regret this gen so far

Show all comments (63)
The story is too old to be commented.