Dismissal in Case of Sony 'Killzone' Graphics

"A class action lawsuit accusing Sony Computer Entertainment of embellishing the quality of its "Killzone: Shadow Fall" videogame's graphics has been dismissed. The joint stipulation was filed by Ladore on April 22. Settlement terms were filed under seal. The stipulation said each party will bear its own costs."

Read Full Story >>
The story is too old to be commented.
extermin8or1319d ago

Ouch the Costa he must have incurred vet he wishes he hadn't bothered now.

Letthewookiewin1319d ago

Ya probably has to sell his X1 now.

xer01318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

*High 5!*, for that one ;-)

donthate1318d ago

What does this have to do with the Xbox One?

UltraNova1318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

@doth nate

Well two things,

First the guy who went against a game is no gamer this much is clear.

Second, if he was a Playstation fan he wouldn't sue them trying to tarnish one of their best dev's reputation.

Which leads to the logical conclusion that he is either a money grabbing piece of S*** or a bitter MS fan trying to hurt Sony, or both! Take your pick!

AND...lets not forget all the rabbit MS fanboys making the most of it every time this lawsuit came up, firmly involving the XB1 in this story.

ON topic: Well finally this ridiculous lawsuit is done and over with.

DevilOgreFish1318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

@ donthate

nothing, there is no paper trail leading to it. It's just cynical thinking Because it's looked upon as a direct competing platform.

He could have owned a pc as well and expected his pc standards to be met. Or he could have been a Wii-U owner who bought into advertisements. I use to buy into the publicly, and listen to the people that took part in backing it up.

peshkavusCA1318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

belongs to ^PS a-hole fanboy. Doesn't belong to the good side of PS fanboys.. Letthewookiewin and UltraNova ;)

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 1318d ago
kparks1319d ago

This guy is a moron all the BS and headache he went through the last couple years for something this stupid! Everyone trying to make a quick buck Hope he feels stupid.

Azzanation1318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

Did you even bother reading the article? The guy and Sony made an agreement which is probably what he wanted. Sony also probably paid him enough to not pursue.

The problem with Gamers today especially in this article is that you will allow corps to try to sell you a product which is misleading. If no one takes a stand then corps will do this. Sony would have learnt there lesson here, they tried to sell a game to the public and mislead people in believing there playing a Full HD game.

This outcome works out for gamers on all platforms. Stop supporting these corps like there your holy grail, Sony did the wrong here and got away with it. Lets hope we never see this again.

Stupid on the guy for suing but even stupider by Sony for putting themselves in this situation.


EXACTLY!!! I guess you and I are few of the many people here who actually read and understood what was being said here. Both parties settled, usually when "settlement terms" have been has or will be exchanged to the suing party. What is more telling is the fact that neither parties are speaking on the situation.

What I think happened is, they paid the guy a undisclosed amount of $ under the stipulation that neither party is to speak on this again.

Jalva1318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

As dumb as this guy was to sue over such a trivial issue, maybe it will teach Sony not to straight-out lie about the resolution of one of their games in future, just so they can avoid inconveniences like this one.

wegetsignalx1310d ago

Sony did not lie, Killzone MP can be indistinguishable from 1080p in some instances.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1310d ago
ninsigma1319d ago

Good. Was a stupid move to begin with. Just some moron trying to get easy money so they don't have to do anything. Glad he failed.

hello121319d ago (Edited 1319d ago )

Actually it was settled out of court by Sony

That lawsuit has now been dismissed in a California court, with a possible settlement being reached between the two parties.

The lawsuit was originally seeking $5,000,000 in damages for, in part, negligent misrepresentation, false advertisement, unfair competition, and fraud in the inducement. How much of this was actually given to Ledore, or settled upon by Sony is not clear and will likely remain a secret as many settlements do.

He got money its obvious Sony did not want to fight this in court and lose.

[email protected]

The evidence is clear this guy was paid off to go away.

1319d ago
hasamalaha1319d ago

Ya they gave him $60 back.

ninsigma1319d ago

You gave me two links. One link is from December 2014 saying they couldn't dismiss it. The second which you quoted which is from TODAY says it is dismissed but hasn't a clue whether it was settled or not. I don't get it. Were you trying to prove point or something??

DragonKnight1319d ago

@KNWS: A settlement usually occurs not because of the chance of a loss, but because the company doesn't want to waste time and money on a frivolous lawsuit they can not benefit from. Ledore winning over Sony could have been a pay day for him, Sony winning over Ledore would have simply cost them money. IF they settled, and there's no reason to think that they have at this point, it's because Sony didn't want to waste years on this case.

In any event, Ledore is an idiot.

johndoe112111319d ago

It is a CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT. If sony settled out of court then everyone who the case covered, which would be everyone who bought Killzone Shadowfall, would be compensated, not just him.

xer01318d ago (Edited 1318d ago )

@KNWS - I am embarrassed for you.

UKmilitia1318d ago

yep have the money back for your game is what should of been the outcome.

when i bought BF4 it was a mess but whats point of sueing DICE/EA for a mess.
i just took the game back to the shop after a month and said why and got a full refund.

wegetsignalx1310d ago

This is completely wrong. The case was Dismissed, there was no class action settlement. Sony would not have lost the case if it went through court. Everything you said is wrong.

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 1310d ago
blackblades1319d ago

Yeah, didn't he lose money for going to court by court fee or whatever. Either way it was a dumb move taking a big company to court over something minor.

Randostar1319d ago

Yup, i loved how so many people were supporting him when this happend. "Good teach sony not to lie about 1080p. If its not native 1920x1080 then its not 1080p" I think suing a company over that is a little extreme.

OB1Biker1319d ago

Yea the whole thing is ridiculous as if they dont have more important things to worry about than the way it achieved 1080p with no upscaling

Volkama1319d ago

Uh oh, ob1 bought into the "we don't upscale, we just scale up" explanation :(

BitbyDeath1319d ago

Stupid how it got that far to begin with.

freshslicepizza1319d ago

just goes to show people will try and sue over anything.

MasterCornholio1319d ago

Well it was stupid in the first place. Surprised that this guy didn't go after Uberporn yet.

MasterCornholio1319d ago

Ah jeez.

I meant Ubisoft not Uberporn.


SpinalRemains1381319d ago


Freudian auto-fill slip?

Volkama1319d ago (Edited 1319d ago )

Damn these new-fangled phones and their dictionaries that learn words while you innocently google uberporn...

Randostar1319d ago

Man, i really wanna screen cap this.

wakeNbake1319d ago

This guy must really like 1080p.... and free money.

hasamalaha1319d ago Show
rainslacker1319d ago

Since each side has to pay their own fees he probably spent a lot more to bring the case to court than he would have gotten from the settlement. Since this was a class action suit, anyone participating in the suit will eventually get a letter saying that they are entitled to a payout or compensation. I can't imagine the payout would be more than $60, and would likely be less. It's also possible that the settlement came to nothing. The guy who started the suit certainly wouldn't get any five million dollars in damages...particularly since it wasn't actually false advertising, just very dodgy advertising.

In the end, it's the lawyers representing his case that made out on this.

Show all comments (60)
The story is too old to be commented.