Patrick Waring at GameCloud Australia writes:
"I love Borderlands as a series, so if this collection had also included the first game, with all of its DLC, then maybe it would be worth it. All of the games in a single, easy to access collection would be pretty great, and if they’d released some additional content to go along with it, then it would have been amazing. As it stands, this is good value for money if you don’t own either game, and that’s about it. You can’t easily switch between the games, there are still bugs present, one of the games is missing, and the extra content in the form of “Claptastic Voyage” would’ve been coming out regardless. But hey, apparently it’s already gone Gold status anyway, so maybe Gearbox will let us have the first game after all."