Pure Nintendo: "Wildmane Studios is one person. Chests O’ Booty (although a year old PC port) is their console début. This makes many of the games missteps understandable. I’ve no doubt Wildmane’s next Wii U eShop game will be better, and I am looking forward to see what the Studio comes up with next. In the meantime, how do I score Chests O’ Booty? It’s lacking both in accessibility and an addictive nature when compared to its peers. Still, this is a casual title, offering a twist on a popular genre, and selling for a budget $1.99 price. It wasn’t for me, but it’ll probably find success with others. So I can’t give it a bad score."