270°
Submitted by TimmyShire 143d ago | opinion piece

There’s Got To Be A Catch To EA’s Subscription Service

NowGamer: "Call me cynical, if you will, but I just don’t trust EA.

EA has announced a new subscription service exclusive to Xbox One – termed EA Access – that will, for a monthly or yearly fee, gain you access to EA’s ‘Vault’ of games. But it’s not like EA is in this for the love." (EA, EA Access, Industry)

« 1 2 »
ArgumentumAdPopulum  +   143d ago
There's no catch. This is just MS and EA planned hook for their DRM plans that were ruined during Xbox One reveal.
johndoe11211  +   143d ago
Then that would be a catch.
DeadRabbits   143d ago | Trolling | show
choujij  +   143d ago
Let us not forget, this is the same corporation voted worst company in America twice. The same EA which is also apparently having to investigate it's own Origin software behavior.

Yeah gamers would be crazy not to accept their services with open arms...
#1.1.2 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(8) | Disagree(3) | Report
blitz0623  +   143d ago
The catch is if this turns out to be a successful venture for EA, they will spin this negatively like they did with DLC. It's a fair assumption considering it's EA we're talking about. Not that no other company would do the same, just EA has the highest chance of doing it.
uptownsoul  +   143d ago
We don't know how good the EA Access service is going to be…I think it will come down to 5 key questions on the games in the EA Vault

1)How new are the games in the Vault

2)How relevant are the games in the Vault (Sports games & FPS become irrelevant as soon as their successors release)

3)How often do they update the Vault

4)How many games do they add per update

AND 5) MOST IMPORTANT - Do games always stay in the Vault** or do they swap games in and out

**ALWAYS read the fine print ( http://www.ea.com/eaaccess/... )!!! Paragraph 2, sentence 2 says "In particular, Vault Titles are subject to change and may be removed, and the online services for certain Vault Titles may be discontinued."
Dasteru  +   143d ago
@choujij:

"Let us not forget, this is the same corporation voted worst company in America twice."

By gamers, on gaming related sites. EA is not and never has been anywhere near the worst company in America. Anyone who believes otherwise is extremely out of touch with reality.
tbone567  +   143d ago
30 bucks to play all EA games of the past year. Next year we should get Dragon Age, Titanfall, Madden 15, Fifa 15, UFC, etc all for 30 dollars per year. Exciting times for Xbox One owners and EA Access.
DOMination-  +   143d ago
How is that the catch?

Nowhere have they stated that you'll have to stay online to play these games once downloaded. Good luck using PSNow offline to all those going on about anti consumerism.
XiSasukeUchiha  +   143d ago
DRM bait confirmed with EA's access service don't do it everybody or the XB1 DRM will strike again.
gjruk  +   143d ago
Yet my brother on the other console can also play the games I've subscribed to via the EA Access app.
Shinox  +   143d ago
That's exactly what i was thinking the whole time
they were already planning under the tables
Titanfall + Exclusive deals + The always-on DRM
It was all planned before the XB1 reveal , its a conspiracy people
Xsilver  +   143d ago
"There’s Got To Be A Catch To EA’s Subscription Service"

it's EA just wait for it tick toc. http://media-cache-ec0.pini...
djplonker  +   143d ago
One thing I haven't seen people mentioning is that all the EA games from the list have microtransactions...

Up to thier usual tricks!
#1.5 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
styferion  +   143d ago
IMO right now there's no catch or anything, the service is optional and there's still nothing disadvantageous for non-subscriber. Also for gamers who's into annual sport games this is actually quite a deal.

But honestly I'm worried about the future, maybe when there's some significant number of subscriber they'll start to limit something, maybe some content only available for subscriber, can only play online with subscription or something..
Gamble20  +   143d ago
I don't understand how this is "quite a deal" for annual sports gamers. You pay $5 a month for 10% off (so you save $6? Wow thanks EA), on a maximum of what? 4 games a year? It's not like they have 12 great sports games per year. And we all know most gamers are only really getting Madden and FIFA that consistently. So you save $12 on two sports games when you spent $30 for the whole service.

Oh, and you get a ten minute demo a few days earlier. It also forces you to buy digital so you can't recoup any money from the sale of the games.

I don't think they are ripping anyone off, it just sort of seems like a sneaky way to get people to pay for DLC.
PoodlePuncher  +   143d ago
EA will never make less money off of games through a new type of service. We're talking a huge corporation here, they don't pay people a ton of money to come up with new ideas on how to make less money. I'm thinking they will eventually charge more for the service, or the games offered will eventually be older, crappier games. Of course when they first announce it they have to make it sound good. The ol' bait and switch.
jnemesh  +   143d ago
The catch is that EA has crappy games, DLC, microtransactions, and free-to-play mechanics in retail games.

I have done just fine without a single EA game in my library over the past several years, I am sure I won't be missing much here!
dmitrijs88   143d ago | Trolling | show
NYC_Gamer  +   143d ago
It's apart of the games being offered as service that many pubs and etc have been talking about
GamingSinceThe80s  +   143d ago
The catch is its $60 a year to play a few old games.
#3 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(22) | Report | Reply
Dudebro90  +   143d ago
$30....
ShowanW  +   143d ago
Wrong...

I got the service for $30 for the year...
And games will be added...

I don't really care for EA at all... But if all I have to do is fork over $30 for access to a variety of games, then why not...
mcstorm  +   143d ago
It all depends how you look at it. For some one like my dad who dose not play games online and he only tends to buy old games then this is a great deal as he only has to pay £30 a year and gets games like Fifa, BF ect that he buys later on and dose not need to get gold too.

Also if everyone decides to go down this rout in the end and they offer a service say £50 to 60 a year for all new games included then it could save a lot of money as if I look at the amount of games I buy a year it could save me a lot of money if you work it out right as 1 game digital tends to be £54.

It could be a great idea but only if done right but I don't see media being dropped soon too as having the option of both will be needed for the next few gens I think.
ThatOneRiggaNob  +   143d ago
The fact that he really thought it was $60 a year and two people agreed with him just shows a major problem with some people nowadays.
Axios2  +   143d ago
Old games?

So you're playing BF5 now?...No

You're playing FIFA15?...No

Peggle 2 just came out

I see a lot of bitter tears about the OPTIONAL service.

ppl will decide if it is worth it to them personally

@ Koruptor, learn to read because it CLEARLY states that those games are all available now.

@ yo mama, the games are all less than 8 months old, Peggle 2 just a few months, in your blind hatred you are inserting what is by example not the case. What you think will change has zero value in reality, I know that facts hurt you, but if you can't dealwithit, don't bother making up garbage. Try making up garbage for PSN next time, how about "the price will double next year".

@ ziggercat, FIFA and BF4 are still $50
#3.5 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(11) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
kurruptor  +   143d ago
You don't get any of those games for free. You only get to trial them for 5 days pre-release.

The games you get for free are old. FIFA 14, Madden 25.
Yo Mama  +   143d ago
You know they're not going to put the new versions of those games on that service for at least a year once they're released. So I hope you enjoy paying for and playing Madden 25 and Battlefield 4 long after the new versions are released.

It just looks like a better deal than it is now because they had to release some games and they happened be the current ones available. But that will change.
#3.5.2 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
thunderbird86  +   143d ago
@kurruptor. Yes and you get peggle 2 and battlefield 4. All 4 are in the vault right now.
ziggurcat  +   143d ago
@axios:

and you won't be playing BF5 or fifa 15 via EA access, either. those games won't pop up in their service until they've dropped in retail value. that's what yo mama is saying.
GamingSinceThe80s  +   143d ago
Oh I thought they said $5 a month.And they did but its $30 for a year up front.So I was half right.lol Well thats not so bad then.
#3.6 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
TimeSkipLuffy  +   143d ago
This is the catch:

Yeah... because now that I got gold I have to pay for another subscription to get old EA titles for gold... and then more publishers are going down the same route...

At the end of the year I pay:

+ Gold membership (for indies + MS games)
+ EA membership
+ UbiSoft membership
+ Campcom membership
+ Take 2 membership

Subscription total a year: over $200
While I just could have one subscription and get games from all publishers... even if it might be slower. But two X1 and two X360 games a month is quite good.

If I had the option to pay $5 a month more for Gold to get 2 extra games that would be a whole different story.
MooseWI  +   143d ago
Companies will never work together as a whole like that. That's like saying Democrats and Republicans will one day work together. It's all money.
styferion  +   143d ago
no, but you can't deny the possibility that if this service works out it'll tempt other big publishers to do the same..
Dudebro90  +   143d ago
You are talking as if you aren't going to buy more games ever again.

You could have 2-3 subscriptions' for $60-$90

Or buy 1.5 new games, or 2-3 $30 games.

The service is for people who dont want the latest and greatest ea titles when they bit the shelves for $60.

Nothing wrong with that.
TimeSkipLuffy  +   143d ago
actually that is what I'm doing. I play old games while I wait more games to appear on Gold and PS+...

If you see the blogs and forums you'll see many ppl complain about the games... why indies why not retail games. Now you want them to spent more money to get retail games in their subscription?
Corpser  +   143d ago
How's that a bad thing if you have the option for these subscriptions? Anytime you don't see the value in any of them, dont subscribe! It's xbl gold and ps+ That have online mp behind the paywall that's the problem, you can't just unsubscribe unless you don't want to play online anymore
TimeSkipLuffy  +   143d ago
The problem is that now you have to pay more for games that you could have got in your initial subscription. As for PS+ we got several EA titles already in our PS+. Now with this we have to pay extra to get those games...
Linchpin  +   143d ago
Only a moron would think there isn't a catch... this IS EA after all.
PrinterMan  +   143d ago
Also, the fact that it is only on XB1 and not the other platforms their games are also available on does indicate to me that Microsoft is heavily involved. The XB1 to date; Let's see now...Slower sales than expected, Disgusting first reveal, Having to make a Kinectless version, price drop, PR problems up the wozoo. Guaranteed MS has funding & interest in this deal. EA's greed and MS as well really shows here.

I just wish EA would spend more time and effort fixing BF4 netcode/hit detection issues rather than squeezing our pockets with this crap.
Rob_Ko  +   143d ago
last EA game I bought was probably Mass Effect 3, so it was long time ago, next one is going to be Dragon Age Inquisition, but I don't see a point to spend 5$ to get 6$ discount,
lol 1 dollar profit, wow
jackanderson1985  +   143d ago
you'd also get early access to the game.... also a profit is a profit
ThatOneRiggaNob  +   143d ago
not to mention since the discount pays for itself you'd also get access to madden 25, fifa 14, bf4, and peggle 2 while basically saving a dollar. Plus you will also get to play 2 hrs of dragon age five days early just to water your tongue a little bit before you get the actual game. So you get a ton of other stuff on the side of that 1 dollar profit.
Rob_Ko  +   143d ago
actually I'm not interested in any of these games. trully.
danowat  +   143d ago
You don't need gold to access the vault games.
KYU2130  +   143d ago
So far they haven't reveled if live gold is required
danowat  +   143d ago
They have.

I am in the preview, and you do not need gold to use the service, you only need gold if you intend on using the multiplayer in said games.
CrowbaitBob  +   143d ago
I can't even imagine a scenario that involves an Xbox One without a Gold subscription. I just can't.
kurruptor  +   143d ago
I think only about 50% of people subscribe to Gold (similar to PS+).

Not everyone plays online games. Destiny will be the first online game I've played in the PS3/PS4 era. [I do subscribe to PS+ though for the discounts and free games]
Destiny1080  +   143d ago
it seems like a great deal but I think in the end it will boil down to. if you don't have an ea subscription you cant download this demo
stuna1  +   143d ago
The only catch I see is removal of my madulla oblongata.
paulogy  +   143d ago
There's no catch. It's fairly obvious there are only going to be a handful of games in the Vault at any time.
#10 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
frostypants  +   143d ago
Yeah, kind of funny how many haven't figured that out.
TheFallenAngel  +   143d ago
People are again hyping xbone stuff. I don't think this will be a big thing like people makes it seem.
Cobra951  +   143d ago
Of course there's a catch: You pay way ahead of getting your money's worth (like a season's pass) and then you don't get anything for good. You have to keep paying to keep the access. It's "games as a service" garbage, and I will never pay a dime for it.
Dewitt  +   143d ago
Tin foil hats for everyone!

Seriously, 2.50 a month for a service of AAA titles that you could never get at that price. Play all EA games 5 days early and progress carries over. 10% off all digital stuff, no locked in contracts besides what you pay for. Where is this catch?
#13 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Onenyte  +   143d ago
I need to get the licence plate of the turnip truck you fell off.....

Read the article,it makes perfect sense.
#13.1 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
Godmars290  +   143d ago
Its not going to be ALL EA games. It wold be foolish for them to put out everything they've made at once. Also likely to have an always online requirement.

Also, you should have clarified British Pounds or US Dollars.
Godmars290  +   143d ago
So, paid access to betas, which wont be available after the release of said new games, with discounts and older titles to distract from the fact that you're paying for beta access.

So then it becomes about when they put out new, AAA, titles, handing out early access for five days giving 10% for buying the full game.

Yeah, when you only look at it that way, paying $30 a year for limited access to 1-2 new AAA releases within that year - maybe - is not a good deal. It just looks like one because of the older games also available.

Its also going to embed what is the worst trend in the gaming industry: setting a fix release date regardless of a game's condition. EA's going to have to put out "something" on a regular basis, and that's going to effect quality.
#13.3 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
PrinterMan  +   143d ago
AAA titles? If you're talking about access to new titles how do we know they are AAA? Because EA says so? Pshaw.
Dewitt  +   143d ago
AAA title is defined as a major publisher made title, such as EA.
jackanderson1985  +   143d ago
the catch is they want people to move digital... the more people going digital the reduced costs on brick and mortar shops... EA doesn't care about gamestop as they know gamestop won't stop shelving their games.... by offering this service they get the full price back 54 less MS's cut only rather than 60 less the cost of physical media (disc, box, "manual", cover sheet etc), gamestop's (or other retailers) cut, MS' cut, shipping and so on.

at 30 a year you're saving money if you buy 6 or more games (break even at 5) not to mention games that will be on the service you might not have other wise considered (peggle 2 for me for example).

yes it's a form of DRM in the sense you need to have an active sub, can't trade them in if you go digital and by the wording games are rotated out of the vault (i see this happening heavily with sports games as there is a yearly iteration with them) and are gone for good
#14 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
MegaSackman  +   143d ago
No catch, EA is a great company now, didn't you know?
Macdaddy71  +   143d ago
If you would read the thread from EA, the catch is you play the beta other word the Demo!!! You have to buy the Full Game to play it...EA not giving us games like PS Now, dang Read it.. I don't know what this guy is talking bout, looks like he did not do his home work before writing this thread...
Do you really think EA going to let you play Madden 15 for $4.99 a month!!! You are crazy, demo/beta yea...
Think bout it EA done tried to charge us for demos!!! This is a way to do it n gamers liking it
jackanderson1985  +   143d ago
eh it's the full game you get.... the EA Access is in Beta... the games are full games though
kaileb  +   143d ago
I read it on twitter 2hr only for dragon age and since its a full game it will time the intro.
jackanderson1985  +   143d ago
@kaileb yeah the new games not in the "vault" are limited to a two hour window but macdaddy was referring to games within the vault and that's what i was referring to
MasterCornholio  +   143d ago
Its EA so I would be cautious about this. Sony did reject their proposal for some reason.
theRell  +   143d ago
Sony has PS Now that's still in beta. Allowing direct competition on their system so soon wouldn't even make sense, it takes away potential business.
Mattz  +   143d ago
Lol.. its funny watching people scramble to pass hatred against ea and ms with this service.

At the end of the day £20 a year to play battlefield 4 and Peggle 2 is cheaper than purchasing so.. what now?

Its a cheap service and if they add a few ganes every month or two - bonus.

If you get use of two games anyear along with other benefits then you would be a fool not to subscribe.

XB1 it is then.. :)
Godmars290  +   143d ago
Its a flat fee with EA having complete say with what's available through it. Newer games will likely be limited to demos/beta/timed, and XBL Gold will probably be needed.

One thing that really does need to be considered is DLC and microtransactions. Are people really going to be stupid enough to essentially rent full games while buying map packs or other little bonuses?
#19 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
theRell  +   143d ago
I tried it for $5, cancelled the auto-renewal, downloaded some games I wouldn't buy, played them as much as I wanted. Next month, I'll go for the $30 for the yearly. Early access with discounts, I'm sold. Not even worried.
WeAreLegion  +   143d ago
No. People just can't read. The "vault" consists of handpicked titles that change every once in awhile. You're not getting their entire lacklog or anything. 10% off new digital titles is handy, if you purchase that many EA titles. I don't, but some do.
hardeepmeghera  +   143d ago
I for one buy a whole ton of EA games just cause they appeal to me. I'm ashamed to say this but I might actually like EA.
hardeepmeghera  +   143d ago
Kinda ironic that the two games that I play on a daily basis on my ps4 in which I spent about 120 dollars in getting them now is on sale for the Xbox one for 30, in this access package. I'm not gonna lie, I'm pretty salty about this.
Clown_Syndr0me  +   143d ago
As much as we hate DRM its the way of the future. I don't game on PC but I know most people get digital copies, so they obviously cant sell them.
Only difference is, PC gaming is far more affordable.
SliceOfTruth888  +   143d ago
There is no catch the only catch is that gamers think companies should love them. The fact people are bashing this and saying PSN+ is for gamers not this just shows how silly gamers rationale is. Lets take EA Access for what it is

1)30 bucks per year its 2.50 per month...there would have to be a severe lack of content for this to be not worth it

2)Access to the Vault. The term Vault here is interesting. Vault would mean games that will stay forever and you would have...are you ready for this...ACCESS to the VAULT of EA GAMES. Common sense at its best here. So for the 30 dollars per year you get access to what WILL become tons of games

3) You start off with last years Madden, Fifa, Peggle, Battlefield 4. This is genius because this will actually keep the community's alive and EA can keep making money by you buying DLC. Its win win for both consumer and EA. Yeah you may own these games, just like i do, but i dont own plants vs zombies, UFC, NFS. Once these start to get vaulted...i will be joining asap

4) Early access to EA games and 10% discounts. The value of the games you get in the vault is already worth 30 bucks now for ea games you want to buy at launch you can at a discount? Also get them a week early? Id pay Bungie 10 extra dollars right now to have the full retail copy of destiny. I am sure many sports games fans feel the same way for multiple titles.
DirtyPimp  +   143d ago
ps plus is for gamers
lemoncake  +   143d ago
The games are old, a pathetic 10% off the digital price which are already over priced and the biggest catch is that they are the base games without the dlc so you end up buying expensive content for something you don't even own.
theRell  +   143d ago
So paying $30 to access games (plural) for a year and getting discounted prices on the DLC for said games is bad how? You don't own it, but come on, it's a pretty good deal. It's hard to even deny it.
ghostface9  +   143d ago
This is a great deal for x1 owners and I will be getting the yearly subscription at 30 dollars hate off to EA for this there moving in the right direction. Now if only ubisoft would do this they have the best library of games out there.
kaileb  +   143d ago
Can i trade the game that i buy on ea early access?? I know im saving 10% but if i sell the game dont i get more? The beta is 2 hrs only right? If i get the nhl15 10% off why would i get it again for free on there vault program? Should i just wait till the nhl16 to get the nhl15 on the vault??i got nba14 free on ps+ albeit its ps3 but now they might not even offer any ea games in there right??
Roccetarius  +   143d ago
Subscribing to a service, in order to access games is exactly what they want for the future. They get full control of your playing habits, and consumers are gullible enough to let them.

Oh, and Origin is actually Malware itself, because of the information it leeches from people.
#28 (Edited 143d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
HonestDragon  +   143d ago
Not necessarily a catch, but more like a ploy. It ensures that gamers who go for digital-only downloads and yearly sports games will chuck up the additional money to get access from EA and (in this case) Microsoft. It keeps those gamers loyal to the digital subscriptions by enticing them with these offers.
Ripsta7th  +   143d ago
If it fails... The costumers werent ready for it, typical EA
« 1 2 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

New Dot Arena promo image features cute Korean idol Youngji

23m ago - It was recently revealed that rising Korean star Youngji has been chosen as the spokesmodel for t... | iPhone
20°

Chrono Trigger, Secret of Mana Tracks Coming To Theatrhythm Final Fantasy: Curtain Call

37m ago - Theatrhythm Final Fantasy: Curtain Call is getting a downloadable content pack with music from Ch... | 3DS
30°

RouteZ

38m ago - In RouteZ, your goal is quite simple: drive to survive! Barrel through hordes of zombies in searc... | Arcade
30°

DreadOut Act 2 Will Be Out Soon, New Screenshots Show Fresh Horrors

38m ago - Fatal Frame-eseque horror game DreadOut has been updated in preparation for the forthcoming secon... | PC
Ad

Win a PS4!!

Now - Join us on Filmwatch to find out how you can win a free PS4 this holiday season! | Promoted post
40°

Far Cry 4 Review | ITF Gaming

40m ago - Far Cry 4 is a great game and is extremely addictive. While the characters are either a little bo... | PC