80°
Submitted by toocoolgames_14 221d ago | opinion piece

"I Don't Need Critics to Tell Me What I Should Like"

We’ve all heard this statement many times before, but it’s spoken by those who don’t understand the proper role of a critic. (Culture)

PinkEye  +   221d ago
Who says that they are? They're just telling you what THEY like. And if you have a particular publication that consistantly likes the games u like (my only fave is gamespot, i think IGN isn't critical enough when reviewing), and has the same criticisms about issues u don't like in some games, than u found a match worth considering. U still don't have to worship every opinion they have though.

Sorry but I won't just blindly buy a game anymore. With games being incomplete to sell dlc, microtransactions, pay to win model, etc I am not willing to pay $60 without some kind of insight as to what is in it and if the journey makes up for the initial cost.

But at the end of the day, I o rely on user reviews. I trust those who were excited enough to get it day one, only to give it a bad review after paying $60. Nobody does that for no reason. I trust the opinions of those who bought it, more so than someone who never had to pay for it (corporate reviewer)and might have been paid/bribed/supported via ads by the game publisher who gave them an unpaid version of said game to review.
#1 (Edited 221d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
DaleCooper  +   221d ago
I rely on a mix of critic and user reviews when I buy games. I was told by another person on here to "try it for yourself, don't listen to critics". That'd be nice, if I didn't have to spend 60 dollars to "try" it. Unfortunately, I do have to rely on other people's opinions, but reading reviews from several trusted journalists has kept me from buying a bad game in at least ten years.
PinkEye  +   221d ago
Yep. Watch Dogs got good reviews, but I waited. After 2 weeks the user reviews poured in and I new I was dealing with a slightly better-than-average game at best. Why pay $60 for that when I can buy like 3 $20 classics that I haven't played yet (Catherine, Dragon Age Origins, Demon's Souls, all of which are far more challenging games with a rewarding sense of accomplishment and are only $20 each). Sounds like a better use of my $60.
no_more_heroes  +   221d ago
I use reviews to tell me what's in a game, not what I should think of what's in it. I already know what I like and what I'm willing to accept. I just need to know how that particular game "plays". So give me all the reviews and gameplay clips possible. I'll make up my own mind on what I see.
MEsoJD  +   221d ago
Reviews are meant to help you determine whether you want to purchase the item in question or not.
Chrono  +   221d ago
Can't you just, like, ignore them?
Baka-akaB  +   221d ago
" A good critic doesn’t try to make a consumer feel stupid for purchasing or not purchasing a product. A good critic doesn’t try to explain why all “real gamers” should buy a certain title. It has nothing to do with elitist labels."

True but sadly it often isnt like that . There have been multiple instances when do try to guilt or shame their public about a game they'd rave about , but wich ultimately failed in sales and/or public opinion .

And on another matter , i can't and won't ever accept the huge disconnect between the preview period and the review . There have been too many cases , even with the previewers and critics being one and the same , where they go just above informing people about a title , but would rave and hype it to death . Only to admit it being mediocre and crap in reviews .

in some cases , a whole year of constantly hyping of the game . Making it the second coming of jesus , even till the month before release ... only to suddenly discover , after extensive time with the products and its most apparent flaws , that those wasnt that awesome .

I find the practice dishonest . And no it can't always just be chalked up to some hyped person having spent but a few minutes with the title . Some publications had quite the time to try the games at various stage of development and right before release . They just cared to be an infomercial for a year , and when faced again glaring issues that everyone could see , were pressed to tell the truth solely in the reviews .
#6 (Edited 221d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
knifefight  +   221d ago
Ideally a critic would tell you what THEY like, not what you should like.

This is why I hate the phrase "must buy." Call it great; call it wonderful; call it the best, if you want. But when you say "must buy," then that's a critic indeed telling you what you should and shouldn't purchase. No. Don't do that. Tell me what you like and why you like it. End it there.
Artista  +   221d ago
I like kotaku review system.. No score, just read.
I also look at user reviews. That's about it.
Inception  +   221d ago
This days we have trailers, demo, or video games rental so why we should listen to critics?

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Blizzard unveils new Cindermane Charger mount for World of Warcraft

14m ago - Blizzard has announced a new fiery new steed for the residents of Azeroth, the Cindermane Charger... | PC

'Woah Dave Deluxe' Coming Soon as Free Update with New Levels and Characters

14m ago - TouchArcade: One of the cooler Super Crate Box [$1.99] style games from 2014 was Choice Provision... | iPhone
10°

Find Love During A Study Trip To Japan In Visual Novel Tokyo School Life

14m ago - Siliconera: Dogenzaka Lab has published Japanese studio M2 Co.’s visual novel Tokyo School Life o... | PC
20°

RaceRoom Racing Experience: Sonoma Raceway Track Now Available

47m ago - Sector 3 Studios recently released the Sonoma Raceway circuit for their free to play PC racing si... | PC
Ad

N4G GOTY Call for Nominations

Now - Nominate your favorite games of 2014 in our GOTY categories! | Promoted post
20°

'Majora's Mask 3D' honors original classic | O'Colly Review

48m ago - On top of it looking gorgeous, the remake streamlines aspects of the Nintendo 64 title without co... | 3DS