20°
Submitted by vickers500 2274d ago | article

Criticism: Towards a better game review structure

There's a lot of dissatisfaction regarding how games are reviewed coming from a number of quarters; there is an equally vociferous defense of the typical numerically-based reviews. Over at GameSetWatch, Simon Parkin takes up the issue of the reviewer-reader divide, especially in terms of what readers want out of a review (even if they don't know it). (Arcade, Culture, GameCube, Mobile, Nintendo DS, PC, PS2, PS3, PSP, Wii, Xbox, Xbox 360)

jamilion  +   2274d ago
Stupid Proposition
"can compare, for example, Mass Effect with Rock Band and see which one is empirically better"

Anyone with a logical mind wouldn't compare the two to begin with!

I dont know how this would solve the problem! People will still find ways to criticize the reviewers and this wont stop the Reviewers from being bias.

Funny how Kotaku has started to post these articles about reviews and comparing games!
clintos59  +   2274d ago
Kotaku is obviously anti sony...
Ever since sony black listed them from reviewing there games, kotaku has been hating them ever since. I am glad sony doesnt take crap from these losers. Just look at all the crappy info they try and do just to talk down on MGS4. Please if u dont like the game go play Halo 3 since alot of u analyst overhype the crap out of these games with mediocre storyline.
ChickeyCantor  +   2274d ago
funny, some say they are anti Nintendo or Anti Microsoft....
maybe its just blindness? we wanna see what we want to see?

OT:
Reviews can be totall BS in my opinion, as long they leave out RATINGS. How the hell does one come up with a Float? how the hell can a human mind say " no i dont think its a 0.4 but a 0.5 .
Its based on complete BS.
If they leave out the ratings, the only thing that would be left over is the wall of text.
People either read them because the reviewer is good, or they ignore him because he is writing totall bullsh/t.

They could tell you BS but in the end they give the game a 9 and people will be hyped as hell.
#2.1 (Edited 2274d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
10°

Waiting on a true next-gen MMORPG

24m ago - People don't really know what they want till they see it, and with newer titles coming out, each... | PC
20°

Ionball 2: Ionstorm Review | Gamecrastinate

25m ago - Ionball 2: Ionstorm is a modern-day take on the classic brick-breaking games of our past. Develop... | PC
20°

Review: 'Madden NFL 15' impresses | News10

25m ago - 'Madden NFL 15', the latest edition of EA Sports' pro football video game series, isn't perfect,... | Xbox 360
40°

Bioshock [iOS] Review: A Capable Port of a Great Game- AppSaga

40m ago - Last year, 2K/2K China delivered iOS gamers the excellent XCOM: Enemy Unknown port. They’re back... | iPhone
Ad

Metro Redux (PS4) Review

Now - Ken returns to the Metro for this amazing remaster. | Promoted post
20°

BioShock for iOS Review | Pocketmeta

40m ago - BioShock for iOS ends up being a bunch of potential that is lacking polish. It is a fantastic sto... | iPhone