Jarrett from Irrational Passions played Goat Simulator. He's conflicted.
"I’ve reviewed a good number of games in my time, and even though each game is different, with reviews that reflect each one’s singular uniquity, they are all based on similar ground rules. Does the game run well? Is it enjoyable to play? Does it do anything to advance the genre or medium? So what do I do with a game that deliberately headbutts those concerns like a rage-fueled farm runaway? Play it, obviously, but damn well not review it."