Submitted by jcnba28 492d ago | videocast

2D Metroid vs. 3D Metroid - Nintendo Podcast

IGN - Which era of Metroid games comes out on top? ( Metroid Prime, 3DS, GameCube, Nintendo, Nintendo DS, Super Metroid, Wii, Wii U)

Attached Video
DryBoneKoopa85  +   493d ago
My vote is for a new 2D Metroid. Like Jose said, Retro nailed it the first time with Metroid Prime. With Retro taking time to focus on 2D lately with Donkey Kong Country Returns and Tropical Freeze I would like to think that it was a warm up to a solid new take on a 2D Metroid game.

Like they all said, in the end if its a new 2D or 3D Metroid game I will be totally pumped and excited to play it!
Chrischi1988  +   492d ago
If Nintendo thinks it can feed its fans with just 2D games, then no wonders Nintendo doing so bad with its "home console" right now. I would expect such things for its handhelds. 2D Donkey Kong, barely 3D Mario, 2D Mario, there are enough plattformers, we get enough Indie plattformers. I know many love the 2D Metroid, I am not saying, they should not do them, I am just saying, that they should do both and not only 2D.
Realplaya  +   492d ago
You have no say in what they do you don't own a Wii U. Go buy one then come back and demand certain games from Nintendo.
Chrischi1988  +   492d ago
Shut it, I own a Wii U from day one and anyone on this board in the Wii U Area knows me for one of the biggest Wii U defenders, but this doesnt mean I am blind and take every shit, especially from somebody like you. New to this board? Obviously, or you wouldnt say such a thing.
#1.1.2 (Edited 492d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report
Benjaminkno  +   492d ago
Boo... why would you think that making the first 2d Metroid home console game in 25 years wouldn't be groundbreaking?

Super Metroid is still one of the best games ever.

I would pay good money to play a "decent" 2d Metroid game 3x that size. Are you serious?
Chrischi1988  +   491d ago
I said, why cant we have both... why do you guys put words in my mouth and insult me for it? I did not say I dont want 2D Metroid, I said, I want both and I would think it is a step back, if they release only 2D games for their home console, buuuhuuu, so bad.
BelkingOfSony  +   492d ago
super metroid destroys any other metroid game. 2D metroid > 3D metroid.

@Allsystemgamer - metroid prime was great imo, and so was metroid fusion, but super metroid is imo the greatest game i've ever played.
#2 (Edited 492d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
Allsystemgamer  +   492d ago
Oh come on metroid prime is absolutely amazing
randomass171  +   492d ago
I like Prime more than Super, but I like Prime and Super WAY more than Other M.
PrinceOfAllSaiyans  +   492d ago
I hope 3DS gets a new Metroid game. I highly doubt it tho.
TheSsus  +   492d ago
I know I'll get disagrees, but IMO 3D Metroid > 2D Metroid. 2D can never achieve the level of immersion that the Prime series had.You actually felt the isolation. Though 2D had more iconic Bosses (Mother Brain, Kraid and the sort). By the way, when I say 3D Metroid I exclude Other M, that game was just terrible.
higgins78  +   492d ago
Other M gets such a bad rap, in my opinion only because it's in the company of such greatness, otherwise it was a good/very good Metroid game.
Picnic  +   492d ago
I never played the 2D Metroid games and I never wanted to. The only thing I've ever liked where someone's in a spacesuit is the Alien series of films. Why? Because it's not really about space. It's about complacent humans being shown their own greed. It's a twist on the old haunted house murder mystery idea where people are picked off. The difference is that everyone knows the culprit but even all staying together would be no guarantee of safety because it's non-human and can't be reasoned with, can't be bought.

So I got a bit of a sense of that from the first Metroid Prime game. They could have called it Aliens really.

I played MP2: Echoes for a short while and felt that it had lost what I found interesting about the first game. Echoes was a sci-fi game, it wasn't one where the mystery of the level design or art direction was giving me a feeling of specialness.

I liked the first MP game on the Cube because it was more or less like playing Resident Evil crossed with Banjo Kazooie type upgrading.

It was the fact that the sci-fi was downplayed that endeared it to be. The synhthy music, the ice and fire worlds just like a Mario or Zelda game.

I doubt I'll ever feel the need to play another Metroid game. It can't add to what the first 3D one did for me without overdoing it. Only a reboot , a remimagining of the first Metroid Prime game but with different puzzles and extra rooms or an extra level would probably satisfy me. but I stress- it's not about being a sci-fi game for me. Maybe it is for you but, if it is, I bet there are other sci-fi games you prefer much more. In which case you are not a primary Metroid Prime fan. MP is about superb level design, puzzles, atmosphere, and music. The sci-fi is secondary.
#5 (Edited 492d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
higgins78  +   492d ago
A lot of great, iconic and masterful 2d Metroid games in the catalogue, however - for me, Metroid Prime alone eclipses all of them, trust me, that is NOT an easy thing for me to say/admit. Prime is everything a Metroid game should be and more...isolation, exploration and tension, all wrapped up in a visuals that feel alive and controls as tight as a drum.
jcnba28  +   492d ago
Couldn't agree more!
Geekman  +   492d ago
3D. There are enough sidescrollers on the Wii U.
MorbidPorpoise  +   492d ago
2d Metroidvania for the 3DS please.
3d Metroid for U please.
Benjaminkno  +   492d ago
Prime 3 is still too advanced for most "advanced" gamers.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Journey (PS4) Review | NZGamer

11m ago - "Journey’s beauty isn’t solely from its art or music, or the experiences crafted by its level des... | PS4

Are We Overreacting to the Rock Band 4 Tracklist? | Music Monday

16m ago - Jake Valentine from The Game Fanatics writes: "A sample of the Rock Band 4 tracklist is on displa... | PS4

'Warhammer: Arcane Magic' - a Digital Boardgame for iOS

Now - Arcane Magic is a turn based strategy game set in the Warhammer universe. Play it now on Ipad and Iphone. | Promoted post

The Point - How Rockets & Cars Made the Best Sports Game in Years

26m ago - "Danny discusses how much time & talent is required to make a beautifully simple game, and how Ro... | PC

Let's Play - No Time To Explain

38m ago - AH: Geoff, Jack, Ryan, and Michael play a game. That's it. No nothing more. I can't say anymor... | Xbox One

Rocket League Review - BGU

52m ago - "It’s not hard to get bitten by the Rocket League bug, even non-sports fans will find themselves... | PC