Try our new beta! Click here
Submitted by Jasmino924 615d ago | opinion piece

Why the New Study About Black Video Game Characters and Racism is Inherently Flawed

J Station X writes

"Racism still exists. From the day to day micro-aggressions muttered under breaths, to the vocal suggestions in protests and online that any person of colour is less than their white peers and to the systematic oppression of those who don’t happen to be white. It’s around us and poisonously so, to the point where it infiltrates every aspect of society.

A place where it is most called into question and analysed is video games, where a (small, but meaningful) margin of non-white characters are seen. But can the behaviours of these characters influence our views on race? A new study seems to think so." (Culture, Fight Night Round 4, PS3, Saints Row 2, WWE Smackdown vs. Raw 2010, Xbox 360)

prodg52  +   615d ago
Very well written article.
iceman06  +   615d ago
This is exactly what I was saying in the very first discussion of this article. There is an inherent "bias" in this study. The issue is pretty simple...there was no pre-screening. Therefore, we know NOTHING about racial bias, stereotypes, or prejudice that existed BEFORE the actual study. Let's not even go into the "more or less" racist idea. Finally, and pretty important, is that there was no control group. Why not do the same thing for minorities to see if they show similar changes in attitude while playing these games? This would at least provide a basis for quantifying the results, to an extent, and allowing a basis of comparison.
About the only thing this really shows, if at all, is that something that was a known issue remains an issue.
Hicken  +   615d ago
Well said.

Seems like half these studies that involve gaming seem to have a conclusion they want to come to; anybody that knows anything about science knows that this will inherently skew the results.
Ashunderfire86  +   615d ago
This article hit it right on the nail! Especially the part where the author said,we are dealing with systematic racism. Yes racism is a system that is the reality. The movie and gaming industry need to be more diverse, and stop giving us slave movies like 12 days of Slavery. Why can't they make movies or possibly even games about Africans and Queen? There are a lot of good stories out there.
Ashunderfire86  +   614d ago
I meant to say African Kings and Queens (I did that comment on the cell phone typo my bad) in that paragraph.
legionsoup  +   615d ago
Gereralizations are wrong no matter who gives them. It's wrong to say that all blacks are violent. However, it's also wrong to label all Americans (or any other culture) as being unwelcoming (or racist).

Individual people can be extremely racist. Just because that one person goes to a certain school, or is from a certain country, doesn't mean that person is the representation for that entire pool of people.
Activemessiah  +   615d ago
Am I the only one that doesn't see race or sex in video games? It really doesn't register that I'm playing as a woman or black or a goat for that matter when playing, my first thoughts are functionality in terms of what they're capable of but never have I once thought "hey why aren't there people like me".
telekineticmantis  +   615d ago
Sometimes I see gender. It depends on how out of place the character seems. The girl from heavenly sword was a good fit, but the new Lara Croft felt out of place in a highly violent videogame. Then again so did the guy from farcry 3 and sometimes the great Nathan Drake does aswell.

Honestly I also see race, if the character isn't awesome like kratos, I feel like it was a wasted oppurtunity, and if he's too stereotypical(and not in a funny way). It just seems corny.
#5.1 (Edited 615d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
RebelWAC  +   615d ago
Yup, you pretty much hit the nail on the head. I would´ve simply replied to whoever came up with this theory with a "You and the people that provided you with enough reasons to come to this conclusion must be out your got damn simple minded mind" and kept it moving.

Racism is far more complex yet that "study" is as shallow as the mind of a racist.

@iceman06 You´re one clever individual I´ll tell you that much. Respect.
#6 (Edited 615d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Cobra951  +   615d ago
Ohio is one of the least valid places for a study like this. There is ingrained racism here. Almost all of the murders here are black on black. There is a serious disconnect between the white and black communities. In other words, the racism existed before the study; and the study did absolutely nothing to separate existing racism from game-induced racism--totally invalidating it.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Snapimals Cheats: Guide, Tips & Strategy for Android/iPhone Game

13m ago - Postcard Pics are sold to visiting photo enthusiasts (a.k.a. your museum visitors). For Postcard... | iPhone

Why common sense tells us to avoid Rainbow Six Siege: Yet, I can’t pass this one up - VGFirst

29m ago - Excerpt from the article "At its finest, Rainbow Six Siege offers a brutally visceral, tactic... | PC

See What TV Series Premiers this Month

Now - Check for a complete overview of season premiers this November. | Promoted post

Exile's End Review [MonsterVine]

44m ago - MonsterVine: "East and West have combined to create a action platformer clinging to the golden ye... | PC

Visual Novel Honey Rose Shows Off Its Schoolgirl Wrestling Action In First Trailer

57m ago - Honey Rose, the visual novel and wrestling hybrid game, got its first trailer. | PC

Hear About Final Fantasy XIV's Korean Service from Producer Naoki Yoshida

58m ago - Naoki Yoshida talks about Final Fantasy XIV in Korea and more. | PC