Top
70°

Are Cutscenes Inherently Bad?

There is a growing sentiment among a lot of gamers that cutscenes are an inherently bad means of telling stories in games. These people say that cutscenes are nothing but an imitation of film, with the argument being that games are different from other forms of entertainment and should tell their stories in a way that is unique to video games.

Read Full Story >>
hardcoregamer.com
The story is too old to be commented.
ChaosKnight832d ago

Yes, Metal Gear Solid 4 is like a friggin movie.

Matt666832d ago

no if the cut scenes tell a good story then I don't mind

loganbdh831d ago

Ill agree to that sir, thats why I also like Indigo Prophecy, Heavy Rain and Beyond 2 Souls

SlyFamousthe3rd832d ago

"There is a growing sentiment among a lot of gamers that cutscenes are an inherently bad means of telling stories in games."

Who are these gamers? I love cutscense its been a part of gaming for years and I hope it never changes. I would love to see who these are that are hating on cutscense. Next they are going to say that a game does not need a plot, oh wait.

Panzart832d ago

Cutscenes are a tool, and like any other tool it can be used incorrectly. Cutscenes aren't inherently bad but there are games which use them poorly.

I enjoyed Metal Gear Solid 4 and loved the cutscenes, but that is from the perspective of someone who is used to the way Kojima makes games. I don't think anyone else could get away with how he tells a story, at least not with the way AAA works right now.

CrossingEden832d ago (Edited 832d ago )

Too many cutscenes IS a bad thing in my honest opinion. Especially if the writing of your game is not very good despite all the relatively sad attempts to imitate film. Many developers that are praised for their storytelling are actually part of the reason why storytelling in video games is held back, because they are not good storytellers in anyway shape or form to anyone who has any knowledge of storytelling, screenwriting, and characterization principles. Games that are guilty of this are games like David Cage games and every metal gear solid besides 3. (and only if you consider it to be a parody that's not supposed to be taken seriously and remove the overly long exposition).
Games are an interactive storytelling medium so taking away the control from the player for long times on end to spill exposition is the opposite of what's good for the medium. Games like the dark souls, journey, and brothers a tale of two sons take advantage of interactive storytelling by integrating the story into the actual gameplay by using lots of mise en scene, (or at least a video game equivalent of it) while not spoon feeding the player every little bit of detail.
One of the main problems of video game storytelling and making grounded realistic relatable characters who speak like actual modern day people is the fact that video game dialogue usually has to end with "go there, do this" in some way shape or form to let the player know where to go next. Western games have been very successful at integrating that line into realistic human dialogue. Most recently, Infamous Second
Reggie:Hey Delsin, I found that control tower you were looking for.
Delsin:Oh really? Where is it?
Reggie"Well you did say that you wanted to see it while we're here."
Delsin:"Shut up...space needle?!"
Reggie"Space needle."
^This feel and sounds like how people in the real world talk. Hell, some games like the Left Behind DLC of The Last of Us even decided to not include that kind of dialogue in exchange for grounded realistic characters.
What people like Kojima and David Cage don't seem to understand is that video games are NOT films and are not a substitute for films. Video games will NEVER get something like "Wolf of Wall Street" So their graphics engines can be as pretty as they want but in the end it always turns out that much worse looking games end up telling the better stories. That is especially true for anything David Cage puts his hands on.
i.e
-Journey
-Walking Dead
-Papers Please
although that's not to say that triple A games can't tell fantastic stories too
-Last of Us
-Infamous Second Son
Btw, please don't try to defend David Cage's writing, I know there are fans of David Cage games, but let's not fool ourselves into thinking he's a good storyteller or writer.
https://www.youtube.com/wat...
https://www.youtube.com/wat...
At least Kojima is a genius when it comes to good cinematography and takes advantage of the fact that video game cutscenes have a controllable camera, as seen in Ground Zeroes, where the entire intro is one long camera shot with no cuts. Something that would be pretty hard to pull off in an actual film.

darx832d ago

Metal Gear is the worst!