Submitted by RGDfleet 192d ago | opinion piece

Why Mashing Buttons in Games is Stupid

One thing that game designers need to remember is that in order to engage and possibly immerse a player you need to connect with them mentally as opposed to physically. This is basically the reason why the Nintendo Wii wasn’t quite the revolution we were promised. When it is all said and done; nothing reminds you faster that you’re playing a silly videogame than a control scheme which constantly demands that you flail plastic objects around for its own amusement. (Culture, Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots, South Park: The Stick of Truth)

alextdarling  +   193d ago
in my opinion the "controller mashing" part in mgs4 WAS AMAZING
LAWSON72  +   192d ago
My fingers got fatigued and I felt Snakes pain, lol. Very immersive
PoSTedUP  +   192d ago
i agree, it completely added to the tension, immersion, excitement and EMOTION.
Saurian  +   192d ago
This is another example of new/young gamers being completely baffled by long established gaming conventions. Even the terms they use, "mashing", is completely wrong and just illustrates their lack of basic knowledge.

You don't "mash" the button, as in, you don't clumsily stab at it like the author of this piece seems to do. Rather you "trigger" the switch using a slight, but rapid motion. It's a skill which you develop over time and as a game mechanic I feel it is a very good way of making the player feel the physical exertion of a particular moment.

I know most modern gamers want games to be passive entertainment, but I wonder if they would actually still be interested in the medium if/when they finally get their way. When you swing all the way over to what these people want out of games, what you end up with is a film.
BeganwithNes  +   192d ago
The button mashing is not that bad in south park. It actually leads to hilarity in the parts that it is used.
Snookies12  +   192d ago
I was watching my friend play my copy, and there's that scene with Kyle/Cartman in school... Those who played the game know which one. He was laughing so hard trying to tap the button, he almost couldn't do it. That was the perfect use for button tapping.
NiteX  +   192d ago
There was only one part that it went overboard and now I'm thinking it just bugged out. Besides that I love it, it works very well and it's not overdone.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Destiny Review: Hope for its future - PlayStation Universe

4m ago - "There isn't enough there to totally enamor me or to acknowledge that it’s the revolutionary work... | PS4

[WKG] Preview: Hitting The Court Again With NBA 2K15

29m ago - At this year's Gamescom Show, Abdallah Hussein from We Know Gamers was given the opportunity to p... | PC

The ESRB: Twenty Years of Sex and Violence

57m ago - The Entertainment Software Rating Board began rating games 20 years ago today, with an initial ba... | Culture

Interview: The Developer looking to resurrect SSI with Seven Dragon Saga

1h ago - Digitally Downloaded sits down with Tactial Simulations Interactive's Producer/Lead Designer, Dav... | PC

Celebrate the new TV season with Filmwatch

Now - With the 2014-2015 TV season right around the corner, come join us on Filmwatch as we celebrate and give all you TV lovers something to enjoy! | Promoted post

Here’s Your September 19, 2014 Indie Game Bundle Update

1h ago - This week there are 31 indie game bundles available. | PC
Related content from friends