50°
Submitted by TheLastWriter 232d ago | opinion piece

Video Game Criticism Back On Track

PSXE: The state of video game criticism might have gotten off track last generation, but there looks to be a change taking place now. It is for the better I say. (Industry)

SpiralTear  +   233d ago
"Until recently though I've felt like things got off track somewhere in the PS3/Xbox 360 generation. Maybe that was because of the explosion of gaming related content on the internet, fanboy extremes..."

This is still a persistent problem. It's just as bad now as it was during the launch period between the 360 and PS3. The criticism of the annual release leniency and the downright broken 10-point scale are things I can agree with, though.

There's still much improvement to be made, so I wouldn't call it "back on track", but more and more outlets are opening their doors to game criticism. There are a lot of independent Youtube channels that provide some surprisingly in-depth and articulate critiquing of games, and that's definitely welcome to see. Interesting article.
MultiConsoleGamer  +   233d ago
It's all about knowing who you can trust. Most of the big sites are still nothing but paid advertising. And now we have a new problem with the smaller sites, the agenda press.

They also say that most gamers get their information from word of mouth. Unfortunately for many that means visiting a message board. Of course you should never trust anything you read on a message board, those things are totally corrupt and agenda driven. They're antiquated dinosaurs filled with sock puppets, PR agents and fanboys who spend more time posting online then they do playing games.

So what's the sollution? Know who you can trust. The media would also benefit from more sites like N4G. The industry in general would be helped by the growth of video game news aggregators such as this one.
admiralvic  +   233d ago
"The media would also benefit from more sites like N4G. The industry in general would be helped by the growth of video game news aggregators such as this one."

The irony is that the opposite is actually true.

What typically happens is a lot of sites tailor make articles for the express purpose of getting them on N4G. I can get into a long winded rant about all the mechanics/elements that go into this, but I can assure you that some sites create articles for the sole intent of networking them.

Thats not to say N4G is all bad, because it also makes it easier to get news and get your information out there, but just saying that the ease of networking also attracts the ease of getting traction on an article perhaps wouldn't have otherwise.

"So what's the solution?"

In the end, the solution is to read things with an open mind and be okay with doing some research. Sometimes a review you might not agree with (score wise) might have a fair reason to dislike it and sometimes a review with a score you agree with contradicts what the review tells you. However, I could also get on an endless rant about how ill-informed some writers are and how rarely anyone will actually call anyone out.
#2.1 (Edited 233d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
MultiConsoleGamer  +   232d ago
The gaming industry and the media that covers it both need more news aggregator websites.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories

Styx: Master of Shadows Video Review | Gaming Judgement

10m ago - Styx: Master of Shadows is a good stealth game that shows signs of weird design decisions by the... | PC
10°

Let's Play - GTA V - Fly 'n' Chat Mystery Play

10m ago - Geoff, Ryan, Ray, Michael and Gavin have a little chat and do... something in GTA. Try and figure... | Xbox 360
10°

‘Assault Android Cactus’ Early Access Impressions | Analog Addiction

10m ago - Hope Hornsby, Analog Addiction. "Upon starting the campaign of Assault Android Cactus, the debut... | PC
30°

Review: 'Magic: The Gathering Duels of the Planeswalkers 2015 Garruk's Revenge'

10m ago - Examiner's David Leavitt writes: The Magic 2015 Garruk's Revenge expansion is far more than ju... | PC
Ad

Getting started in Archeage

Now - Quick overview from Curse on everything you need to get going in Archeage. | Promoted post
10°

GamesBeat: Fantasia: Music Evolved adds a creative element to the music game genre (review)

10m ago - Disney Fantasia: Music Evolved is one of the most interesting music games developer Harmonix has... | Xbox 360