Submitted by karamsoul 455d ago | opinion piece

Are Games Trying to be Too Serious?

Chris West writes: "So I recently finished playing through Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons and I’ve got to say, I wasn’t impressed. The art direction was quite beautiful and the setpieces were done well, but I found the story aspect to be inorganic. The game consisted entirely of unconnected events that are generally considered to be either sad or touching. Considering how much praise this game has been receiving, I welcome all forms of backlash with open arms. While my opinion of Brothers isn’t the focus of this article, it’s place in a pattern of serious and humorless video game narratives is. A narrative featuring serious themes and subjects isn’t a bad thing as long as the writing and story is good, but it seems everybody is aiming to make their games dark and depressing because everyone else is doing it." (BioShock: Infinite, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, Culture, DmC: Devil May Cry, Metro: Last Light, PC, PS3, PS4, Spec Ops: The Line, The Last Of Us, The Walking Dead: Episode 1 "A New Day", Tomb Raider, Xbox 360)

Iltapalanyymi  +   455d ago
nah. look at japanese titles like killer is dead, etc.
Gozer  +   455d ago
This guy needs to play Borderlands 2, bad.
admiralvic  +   455d ago
"Personally, I blame the excellent The Walking Dead Season 1 and Spec Ops: The Line for starting this trend. The problem with this trend is that lesser writers shoehorn in dramatic themes and tropes in the hopes of creating a deep and emotional experience; instead they get an inorganic mess that fails to do what they wanted it to do."

And thats where I stopped reading*...

People need to stop cherry picking examples and claiming unrelated events are somehow related in these theories that go nowhere. Before TWD and Spec Ops there was BioShock 1/2, Catherine, Deus EX is pretty serious from what I recall, Resistance, Killzone, Dead Space, God of War, Ninja Gaiden, Metal Gear Solid and many many many more games that took the serious approach (some games, like NeverDead actually took itself too seriously at times).

At the same time we had Disgaea 3/4/D2, Neptunia, Borderlands, Bulletstorm (nothing in this game was remotely seriously), Deathspank, Dead Rising (did you play Off the Record?), Bayonetta (really anything PG), Army Corps of Hell and no silly game list would be complete without Far Cry 3 Blood Dragon (<3).

This isn't a trend, it's either a reach for an article or someone who just so happens to play a lot of "serious" games (then again, they considered DmC serious...). I mean, there is only a finite number of ways you can take a story and some games go for the dramatic feel and others go for the comedic feel and other games say **** it and do whatever (pretty much anything Suda 51 has done).

* Note, I actually read the article.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Elder Scrolls Online: Tamriel Unlimited PS4 and Xbox One unlock time revealed

20m ago - PS4 and Xbox One players know when they'll be able to jump into the world of Elder Scrolls Online... | PS4

Roundabout will drive you round the bend on PS4

20m ago - VVV: "Originally released on PC before being ported to Xbox One earlier this year, bizarre part d... | PC

The Witcher 3

Now - All the lore you need to know. | Promoted post

Batman: Arkham Knight hands-on preview - Looking at the man behind the mask | MMGN

20m ago - MMGN plays Batman: Arkham Knight with Rocksteady's Dax Ginn. | PC

Splatoon (Wii U) Review - JPS

21m ago - "Following the success of the Metroid Prime series, Nintendo fans have been waiting for their tak... | Wii U

Sony, Climax Studios & nDreams to Speak at Playhubs VR Event

21m ago - VRFocus reports on the announcement of a new VR event, hosted by Playhubs, which will host speake... | Industry