90°
Submitted by Redinfamy 185d ago | article

No Difference in Physical Activity Among Wii, Kinect and Move?

GamerFitnation: With the new console generation just started, the big three systems of the last generation are getting significantly cheaper. Those considering a cheap console for exergaming may be wondering which one is best for them. A new study suggests the variations between various forms of motion gaming may not be that significant. (PS3, Wii U, Xbox 360)

xHeavYx  +   185d ago
There may not be physical activity differences, but if I'm playing a ping-pong game, holding something would make it a bit more realistic, especially with the Move because you can hit trick shots. Another thing is the 1-1 tracking
jmc8888  +   185d ago
I agree with the premise that Move was much more accurate then Kinect.

It really did pick up the subtle flip of the wrists to denote which way you want to spin the ping pong ball.

Move actually exceeded my expectations on how well it worked, and made Kinect look like a POS in comparison.
Shadowstar  +   185d ago
Kinect was great for some very limited applications. Dance Central was the only thing I would term a game that really used well, though. The rest was pretty much garbage.
Bigpappy  +   185d ago
There is a huge physical activity difference. Kinect sports and adventure used both your legs and arms a lot. There is a lot of jumping squatting and running between those to games. For workout it is almost impossible to cheat Kinect, but was very easy to do so with the wii and move, for obvious reasons. I was hoping to see how the body tracking works on the new PSeye. But alas, Sony is not quite ready to focus there just yet. Probably waiting to see what M$ does to counter with something almost like it.

Quite obvious if you just focus on hand movement there is no difference. With these games I mentioned, using your hands don't even account for 1/3 of the activity.
#1.2 (Edited 185d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(9) | Report | Reply
xHeavYx  +   185d ago
Nice attempt at stealth trolling, you made it too obvious though, nobody copies MS, everything they do has pretty much been done before
WeAreLegion  +   185d ago
I'm sorry, but it was pretty freakin easy to trick all three of them, even in workouts.
Geekman  +   185d ago
No.
Funantic1  +   185d ago
So nothing is needed in your hands with the Kinect to get the same physical workout that the move can provide. That's good. Many people have complained about the move and Wii remote slipping out of their sweaty hands. Some even claimed the remotes slung out their hands into the tv causing damage. I prefer the hands free Kinect.
BattleN  +   185d ago
I disagree!
KonsoruMasuta  +   185d ago
"Some even claimed the remotes slung out their hands into the tv causing damage."

Those people are idiots. There is a reason BOTH controllers come with straps.
wonderfulmonkeyman  +   185d ago
That's why you use the wrist straps.
Not using them and damaging a TV is on the consumer's head.XD
WeAreLegion  +   185d ago
You say that, but nothing on the Kinect is anywhere near as accurate as Sports Champions 1 & 2. That fun factor is lost without accuracy.
rainslacker  +   184d ago
Many people? Who? Where? Never once seen remote slipping out being a problem since the first month of the Wii's release, when wrist straps pretty much became standard, and all motion control games came with a disclaimer because people are idiots.
TheTimeDoctor  +   185d ago
they all suck.
spicelicka  +   185d ago
lol truer words have never been spoken.
R00bot  +   184d ago
Motion+ on the Wii was good, but only two games really make you get it. Skyward Sword and Red Steel 2 were both great games that showed the potential of the Wii remote.
Too bad no other games have used it well.
stuna1  +   185d ago
But there is a difference! Move controllers, and WII motes tracked hands only! Kinects tracks hands and feet, thereby using more kinectic motion and expending more energy.
OtakuDJK1NG  +   185d ago
Wii Balance Board track Body though
R00bot  +   184d ago
You can get up and move with the Move and Wii remote. It's just that it's kind of optional with those ones. I guess if you're cheating the game, then you might be doing less work.
Anyway, why does it matter?

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Dragon Ball Xenoverse Playable & New Trailer at TGS

9m ago - Tokyo Game Show will occur from September 18th through to September 21st and Bandai Namco has jus... | Xbox 360
10°

Stick It To The Man! launches on Xbox One today

9m ago - Stick It To The Man arrives on Xbox One today. | Xbox One
40°

Nintendo will be hosting a private Smash Bros media event at PAX

14m ago - Over the past few weeks, an incredible amount of Super Smash Bros. for Wii U and 3DS details have... | Wii U
30°

Stardock’s CEO Calls Out Kotaku For Being Trolls, Games Media As Toxic

14m ago - One Angry Gamer "Well it was bound to happen sooner or later but someone finally had the balls to... | Industry
Ad

Need Cash? (US Only)

Now - How would it feel to have your money struggles solved by this time tomorrow? We give fast loans from $100-$10,000+, and repayment terms up to 60 mo... | Promoted post
40°

Koei Tecmo Ponder If They Should Have Included Female Link In Hyrule Warriors

45m ago - Siliconera: "It’s already been two weeks since the release of Hyrule Warriors in Japan, and in a... | Wii U