390°
Submitted by john2 339d ago | news

Assassin's Creed 2 Lead Accuses Warner Bros & Monolith For Using Their Code & Assets In Middle-earth

DSOGaming writes: "Well, let's be honest here. The first game that came on our minds while watching Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor's pre-alpha gameplay walkthrough was Assassin's Creed. Monolith's title looked too similar to Ubisoft's series, and it appears that we weren't the only ones getting those AC vibes from this new LOTR game." (Assassin's Creed 2, Middle-earth: Shadow Of Mordor, PC, PS3, PS4, Xbox 360, Xbox One)

WorldGamer  +   339d ago
Drama for your and my mama. The games do look very similar.
MestreRothN4G  +   339d ago
And soon we will find how much they're similar.

In any minute, a video comparison will pop out.
PeaSFor  +   339d ago
after all, all fps in the world are "ripping off" Wolfenstein3D.
vishmarx  +   338d ago
now i am to believe that WB doesnt have enough money to rent a 5yr old engine to make a game with much higher production values
GameSpawn  +   338d ago
You don't need a comparison... watch the walkthrough of Shadow of Mordor on CVG:
http://www.computerandvideo...

It's freaking uncanny even to an amateur eye.

This still looks like an interesting game despite the controversy. Hopefully someone fesses up to licensing out the assets so the game can stay as is, because if they are forced to pull any or all AC2 related assets the entire game may change for the worse.
#1.1.3 (Edited 338d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(1) | Report
MestreRothN4G  +   338d ago
Again: only by having both side by side we can REALLY see if the animations are equal. Almost equal = story is over.
#1.1.4 (Edited 338d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
assdan  +   338d ago
Just wow.
YellowTempes  +   338d ago
And there is nothing wrong with that. I think that any RPG should put in the Assassin's Creed climbing code.
mobijoker  +   338d ago
I just checked out man....
Its clear as crystal they are using the AC mechanics...

But I don't mind that...the game looks and plays great...
Let the devs battle on patents or rights....
As a consumer if a game is good I don't care...
PockyKing  +   339d ago
Even if it is using those assets, lots of game developers share assets. Not a big deal in my opinion as long as they're credited for it.
Double_Oh_Snap  +   339d ago
Indeed, lets wait and see. I'm sure both parties with comment soon.
Nasdac  +   339d ago
It is funny that they don't speak about the copy-paste they make in AC2 from Sly Cooper 2 but still critisism others. They copy every inch of the game from top to bottom.
Salooh  +   338d ago
The game looked fun. It combine AC, God of war, prince of persia and with some RPG elements in one game. Even though i know it will be another new assassin creed with repetitive gameplay but it's still something new and refreshing compared to AC. Hope it release the way they want it. I would buy both day one so i don't care if it copy AC. It looks fun to me..
TheDivine  +   338d ago
The chase mission running after some jackass is exactly like AC, the part where four humans were captured looked like it was reskinned from AC4's rescue pirate missions, the climbing, rope walking, assassinations, combat all looked identical and it even has Eagle Vision for Pete's sake. The walking movement looked the same. Its either a clone or reused code from AC but I happen to love AC and love LOTR so I'm all in. Still lets call a spade a spade. This is like PS All Stars or Dante's Inferno, clone to the max.

Ubisoft could've lisceneced the engine or assets. Just because this guy says its his code doesn't mean its his code. Even if he wrote it he worked for Ubisoft who owns it now and what they do with it is none of his business.
#2.2.1 (Edited 338d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report
john2  +   338d ago
Precisely. If they admit licensing - and credit AC2 - then everything is fine. However something tells me that this won't be the case
liquidhalos  +   338d ago
This looks fun, its the first time ive heard of this game, if it still goes ahead im getting it
DARK WITNESS  +   332d ago
Sharing assets happens all the time, thats not the issue. if they took assets without asking then it's not really sharing.
CyrusLemont  +   339d ago
The 8 minute gameplay video screamed Assassin's Creed in terms of climbing and parkour right down to the animation. There was even one of those ropes across two buildings that looked identical to the ones in Assassin's Creed lol. It still had some originality in other aspects though. It'll be unfortunate if the game gets delayed because of this as it looks really good. Hopefully a formal apology is issued due to the lack of acknowledgement and permission?
sarshelyam  +   338d ago
I was doing this in Sly before Assasin's Creed.
Mills93  +   339d ago
some animation's did look straight from AC but I suppose a lot will be changed before release

So much more hyped for this then the next AC, although I still need to give BF a try
WolfLeBlack  +   339d ago
Let's be fair to the guy, when you go read all of his Tweets he doesn't actually have a problem with his coding being used, and seemed genuinely enthusiastic about the game itself. But he did mention that if AC code is in the game it'd be nice to get a mention in the credits :D
ThatKanadianKid  +   339d ago
Things taken out of context as usual.
CrossingEden  +   339d ago
Was wondering about this. I did think that the parkour animations looked EXACTLY the same. Plus as a lead developer it's highly believable that he would recognize HIS work more than anyone else.
#6 (Edited 339d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Lilrizky  +   339d ago
Well yeah, even as a person who didn't develop the game I noticed it immediately. I was like Ok, the climbing looks similar, but a lot of games to the climbing thing nowadays, The protagonist crouching and the rope being almost identical to AC games did it for me. Oh well still looks awesome
OrangePowerz  +   339d ago
He can't recognize code without having to actually read trough the source code unless he lives in the matrix.

Many games use similar animations now, Tomb Raider has climbing animations that look like the ones from Uncharted.

The rope looked like a rope, not much that can be changed about how a rope looks and it was not used in AC2, they had that later.

There are clearly very clear similarities, but acusing a company of stealing code and assets is a rather serious accusation, especially when there is zero proof.
scruffy_bear  +   339d ago
Looks like a pure copy of Assassin's Creed 2

Related video
PS3Freak  +   338d ago
Looks pretty damn similar that's for sure.

Definitely feels a lot like Batman too.
#7.1 (Edited 338d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
ExitToExisT  +   339d ago
The game is carbon copy of AC in terms of gameplay but i don't think AC2 code or anim is being used.
Ashunderfire86  +   339d ago
Man this is like saying Visceral Games use the code for God of War to make Dante's Inferno, yet Santa Monica Studios never complain like this guy. I say it looks a lot like Batman Arkham Series Than Assassin's Creed 2. As a matter of fact it looks better than Assassin's Creed, and probably plays better too.
OrangePowerz  +   339d ago
Just because it looks very similar to AC doesn't mean they use it's code. Tomb Raider has parts that are similar to Uncharted, doesn't mean they took their code.
Salooh  +   338d ago
True but it's obviously the same code, Anyone who played AC will see the similarity in Parkour and sword fighting system. The rest is different though that's why it's refreshing.
OrangePowerz  +   338d ago
That doesn't mean it has to be the same.code. Using the same code means that they took the source code of AC and copy and pasted it into theirs. That is a serious allegation to make as it would be against copyright law.
blackbirdi  +   339d ago
first of all its in the pre-alpha stAGE THATS mean the assets are just place holder , second many of the developers are from warner studios montreal which they had worked before at ubisoft montreal too like Ben Mattes, third it seems they are using some batman arkham stuff so he should be quite and don't make a such drama most of the games shares the sAME codes ... and who knows he leaves ubisoft long ago so no body knows if they bought the codes/assets from ubisoft
#11 (Edited 339d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Relientk77  +   339d ago
I am watching it now, and it literally plays like Assassin's Creed lol

http://www.gametrailers.com...
Dmd  +   338d ago
I've just watched it and here's my two cents: since ACII people are begging for a better combat, better stealth, and freedom to play the missions in a non scripted way. If Shadow's of Mordor is an AC copycat, it also looks to be the best AC game yet! lol
They have a better - faster combat, a crouch button(!) and a much less scripted mission scheme of gameplay. It's like they heard AC's fans and are in their way to release the better game!
Crossbones  +   338d ago
That's what I was thinking to.
KillrateOmega  +   338d ago
Always some drama. God forbid a game have similar, realistic animations.
Ulf  +   338d ago
LoL BS. Next Epic will sue everyone who made a TPS for "looking like Gears".
sarshelyam  +   338d ago
I saw hints of Assassin's Creed, Darksiders, and Soul Reaver. Not sure that means it was ripped...certainly inspired, but what isn't these days?
miacosa  +   338d ago
Just saw an 8min video and it sure does look like a skin for AC.
andjudunno  +   338d ago
AC never had a crouch mechanic
deadfrag  +   338d ago
Well it seems to play way better in terms of gameplay than AC!The combat sword fighting is much better implemented from the looks if so its a welcome to me because AC combat sucks badly and this one seems to go the better route!
#19 (Edited 338d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
JasonKCK  +   338d ago
LOL I actually want to play this more than Assassins Creed.
nishanth123  +   338d ago
You Bastards! Why don't you leave the game alone. Just when I thought I'll see a decent open world LOTR game, this happenes. Unbelievable!
AnEwGuY  +   338d ago
I felt the same way when I played Uncharted, just months after finishing Tomb Raider: Underworld. There's a very fine line between borrowing and stealing, when it comes to game design.
Lamigol10  +   338d ago
Who gives a s**t as long as it's a great game ! We get to enjoy the game .. the warring companies go to court to settle it ... everybody's happy !!
Hellsvacancy  +   338d ago
I don't care, I'm sick of the AC games anyway, they're too easy, this new LOTR looks cool
Gamesgbkiller  +   338d ago
stole it or not .. at least they are improving on that.

AC games didn't change that much in gameplay wise.

This game does alot more.

We just have to wait and see.
KontryBoy706  +   338d ago
This game has Assassin's Creed and Batman written all over it!
john2  +   338d ago
Yeap, those two games were definitely Monolith's inspiration. Exploration = Assassin's Creed and Combat = Batman

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

CarGamingBlog's Top 3 Xbox One Racing Games Of 2014

1h ago - With the year just about to expire now is the perfect time to reflect upon the year’s best racing... | Xbox One
30°

The most awesome game trailers of 2014

1h ago - "As the clock ticks down on this great gaming year which brought as many games, like Grand Theft... | Culture
40°

A Response To The Daily Mail's Comments On 'Sinister Video Game Secrets'

1h ago - Clipping Error responds to the recent Daily Mail article which commented on how thousands of chil... | Culture
40°

Love Dungeon, Starring Bruce Lee, in Development for Commodore Amiga

1h ago - Carl Williams writes, "The Commodore Amiga is a gaming computer that simply won’t stay down as fa... | Retro
Ad

Looking for a Loan with Low Interest?

Now - Prosper cuts out the middleman to connect people who need money with those who have money to invest...so everyone prospers! | Promoted post
30°

EA Access now available for Xbox One users in India

1h ago - EA today launched its Access service for Xbox One users in India. For those of you who don’t know... | Xbox One