100°
Submitted by s8anicslayer 448d ago | opinion piece

Opinion: Stop Being So Rigid In How You Define Games

GI - "One thing I’m consistently annoyed with as developers break new ground in interactive entertainment is a subset of gamers dismissing new experiences by saying, “it’s not a game,” or “it’s barely a game.” (Culture, Gone Home, PC, PS Vita, PS3, The Stanley Parable, The Walking Dead: Episode 1 "A New Day", Xbox 360)

mattdillahunty  +   448d ago
we're at the point now where we need a new definition of what a video game is, and what it means to be a gamer. if you imagine the average gamer of the late 80's or early 90's, you're likely imagining someone a lot different than the average 'gamer' today.

likewise, games themselves are (or can be) vastly different than what we experienced decades ago, or even years ago. and this is less about the technology behind them, but rather the philosophy behind them. if we can come up with a new definition that everyone could agree on, then we wouldn't run into problems like trying to decide whether Journey or Dear Esther fit into this somewhat archaic checklist of what a video game should be.
#1 (Edited 448d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
DarthJay  +   448d ago
"Interactive entertainment" is great and all, but when I have to judge it up against actual games that require a great deal more gamey stuff to be developed for it, that's when I have a hard time with it. I know a lot went into creating the Beyond: Two Souls experience, but when I have to judge it as a game against games that have tons of actual movements and mechanics and engines and you have to do a lot of things to make it work, then I am going to give the Bioshocks and Grand Theft Autos and Battlefields of the world a little more credit.

That doesn't take away from the fact that Beyond or Walking Dead are great experiences, but they are barely games. I loved every second of The Walking Dead and I don't even like or watch the show or read the comics. I just have a hard time giving THAT GOTY over a game like Borderlands 2. Story of the year? Different ball game. GAME of the year? No. You point and click. It's barely a game.

That's not an insult. I'm going to buy every single episode of the new one and love every second of it. But I love the fact that it's not really a game and it's more of an experience. I'm buying it for that exact reason. I'd rather do this than watch a movie.
mixelon  +   448d ago
A game without much gameplay is still a game. Its like the point and click adventure games that were massive in the 90s. Most of them had no lose state, they were all just moving around and using X object on Y object to cause Z scripted outcome.

Nobody was arguing whether those were games or not at the time.. I don't get why people are constricting the definition over the years - it should be widening.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Roguelike Lamp and Vamp Now Available On The App Store

15m ago - TTP:" A new roguelike game is now available on the App Store, a really interesting game developed... | iPhone
30°

Let's own up to our politics in gaming culture

15m ago - Discussions are supposed to make games better, not divide the community. Perhaps it's time to ret... | Culture
20°

Dying Light Guide: Old Town Side Quest Guide

16m ago - Old Town is another area in Dying Light that you will get some side quests in. Some are easy to f... | PC
30°

Resident Evil HD Remaster Review: Monster's Ball [NDTV Gadgets]

18m ago - NDTV Gadgets says: "Resident Evil HD Remaster's design restrictions heighten the game's survival... | PC
Ad

See what games are coming out in 2015

Now - Visit our release calendar to see what games are coming out in 2015. | Promoted post
20°

Life is Strange Review | Xboxachievements

19m ago - Xboxachievements: "Teenage years are tough. Imagine how different those years might have been, h... | PC