Buddy Acker from SpawnFirst reviews episode 1 of The Wolf Among Us: "The Wolf Among Us is off to a great start with Faith. I'm intrigued—no, excited—to see where Telltale takes the story from here. Time will tell if The Wolf Among Us can live up to its predecessor. It's going to be a challenge, but it's a goal that Telltale is more than capable of achieving. They hasn't steered me wrong before, and I don't expect them to now."